Congratulations to Susie Miller, whose essay "Not Just a Little Book" was one of ten runners up in our Decade of Reading Essay Contest. Click here for more winning essays.


Not Just a Little Book
by Susie Miller

In 1996, I taught struggling readers in a Berkeley elementary school. That was the year I met Shelton.

Shelton couldn't read and he knew it. He didn't know the difference between a word, a sentence, a paragraph, or a chapter. Already halfway through first grade, his knowledge of the alphabet was shaky. So we had to back up. We had to go back to the square before Square One of reading.

That first day with Shelton I ran through the questions that I needed to answer: What letters did he know? What words could he write? Could he write a simple sentence? Could he read a simple sentence? How comfortable was he with books? I put out a vast array of tools: markers, magnetic alphabet letters, colored cardstock, drawing pads, stickers, and colorful little books. Shelton ignored all this. He fiddled with the buttons on his blue plaid shirt and stared into his lap.

I handed him a marker and a piece of clean, white paper. I had him write a list of words he knew. We started with his name. He wrote: Shetlon. Not a good sign. He spent a long time thinking and then wrote "me," "I," "man." That was it.

As he looked at the very short list of words he'd written I could see the tears welling up in his eyes. I could feel his disappointment and despair building. He had a bad history with reading. I imagined that he'd mostly heard what he couldn't do. But I was determined to show him what he could do. I picked up one of my very beginning "little books," books with great illustrations and easy, natural language sentences.

"Hey, Shelton, let's read this book. It's called 'I Can Read.'"

We went through the book and I talked about each page without actually reading each sentence to him. We discussed the illustrations and the key words.

I put the book on the table in front of him. "Now you read it," I said.

He looked at me with concerned eyes. He blinked.

"Go on," I said.

"‘I…Can…Read.'"

"Great work!" I encouraged.

He kept going, focusing hard on the words and images. He didn't read every word perfectly. He made mistakes. But he got through it. He figured it out.

"‘I can read the sign, the stop sign,'" he corrected.

He got to the last page, and read "‘I can read the book.'" He turned to me and smiled, huge dimples showing.

"Read it to me again, Shelton," I urged.

He did. "Read it again!" I said. We were beaming.

"‘I can read the paper. I can read the letter. I can read the book.'"

We're not talking novels. This wasn't Shakespeare. But in Shelton's world, this was his first success. It was big. This little book was suddenly very big.

"Come on, Shelton. You need to read this to someone else!" I grabbed his hand and the book and we ran out of my classroom.

We got to the library and found the librarian. "Shelton has something to read to you!" I said. And Shelton read his book.

"Fantastic, Shelton! Wow!" The librarian clapped her hands.

We raced down the hall. Ernie, the custodian, was getting mops out of his closet. "Ernie, Shelton has something to read to you," I panted. Shelton read.

"My man!" Ernie said. "Gimme five!" We couldn't stop smiling.

Next stop, the office. By this time, I was practically in tears each time he read it. Shelton was expanding. His chest puffed out. He smiled from ear to ear. This book was the best book we'd ever read.

We bolted into the principal's office. "Ms. Goodman, Shelton has something really important to show you," I said. "Go on, Shelton."

He suddenly looked a little nervous. Ms. Goodman was the principal, after all. But she sat down on the edge of a table, waiting patiently, and Shelton began to read. He read perfectly.

"You sure can read, Shelton!" Ms. Goodman beamed at him. "You really are a reader!"

"One last stop, bud," I said, after our visit was over. "Come on."

We headed down the hall to his classroom. The excitement was wearing us out. "One more time," I said. He looked at me, hugging that book to his chest. I could see the hope sparkling in his big, brown eyes.

His teacher met us at the door. "Shelton has something to tell you," I said. "I can read!" he said.

Click here for more winning essays