TalkingHand , May 29, 2010 (view all comments by TalkingHand )
After reading Old Man's War I used a spare five minutes to do a little research on our illustrious author and after visiting his blog and reading a few of his interviews posted throughout the World Wide Web I've become sort of a John Scalzi expert. So let me take you through the building process that I believe led to Old Man's War;
Go to a bookstore.
Figure out what book's are the hottest sellers
Eliminate all the genre's that you might know even a little bit about
Go home and Google "Military Science Fiction Classics"
Go back to the bookstore and buy Starship Troopers
Find out that a lot of people hated Heinlein for writing that "tongue-in-cheek, fascist, genocidal" novel
Overgeneralize many of the themes present in Starship Troopers
Add a ton of sex to make the novel more "mature"
Add several overdoses of boring sarcasm and lame jokes
Include biblical passages for "religious zealot" effect
Post unedited unrevised novel on blog and wait for the publishers to come knocking
Writing a novel is a hard thing to do, writing a good one is even harder. You can't take short-cuts, you need inspiration, and above all you must be open minded. I love John Scalzi but that doesn't mean that I read and like his books and his blogs. To be sure good is a matter of opinion. As such I'm of the opinion that this book sucks.
Was this comment helpful? | Yes | No (0 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
JulesJones, February 24, 2008 (view all comments by JulesJones)
I'd been hearing good things about this book for a while, so when it was mentioned as one of the incentives to sign up for Tor's new online promotion material, I went straight over to give them my email address. The link for the OMW download arrived just before lunch. I didn't intend to read it then and there, but flicked through the file to make sure it had downloaded properly. Had my attention snagged by some of the dialogue in the first chapter. Decided to read the first chapter while I was reading lunch.
I read the whole book. It's *that* good at getting you to turn the pages.
It's a Heinlein pastiche, primarily influenced by Starship Troopers but with significant nods to some other books, particularly Space Cadet. But it's an original and interesting riff on those themes, not a knock-off. Here it's not the young men but the old men who go to war, and there are some well thought out reasons as to why.
The basis of the book is that the Colonial Defense Force has rejuvenation technology, and if you live on Earth the only way you can get access to it is to sign up to be a soldier when you turn 75. One-time only offer, use it or lose it. Nobody on Earth knows exactly what the technology is or does, because part of the sign-up deal is that you are declared legally dead on Earth, and can never, ever return. Oh, and you're signing for a term of at least two years, and up to ten -- and while little detail comes back to Earth about the colonies, it's clear that soldiering is a risky business.
John Perry's got nothing to lose. He and his wife made the decision to register as potential recruits when they turned 65. She's dead now, and there aren't any other ties strong enough to hold him to Earth. So he enlists in the old man's war, and finds out just what's out there on the other side of the sky. It turns out to involve a lot of hostile aliens and a multi-way battle for territory that can get very, very nasty indeed.
Perry's a decent and likeable man, and it's fascinating to watch him go through the process of being moulded into a soldier. While this is military sf that makes no bones about it sometimes being necessary to fight to live, it isn't a lazy glorification of the military. You could equally well read it as a subtle critique of unthinking glorification of the military. There are some significant moral issues raised in a quiet way and simply left there for the reader to think about if they notice them.
There's a good and funny look at what it means to be old, followed by an exploration of what happens when a mind with 75 years of experience gets a new body that's not just fifty years younger, but seriously tuned for performance. And there's some thoughtful discussion of identity and what it means to be human that makes the book more than just a romp. But it's also a very fine romp, and enormous fun to read.
I do have a couple of criticisms. Perry is both smart and lucky, as befits an action hero, even a 75 year old action hero. But his rapid rise through the ranks and special shininess edge a little too close to blatant Mary Sue territory in places. Yes, it's a pastiche of the pulp style, but it broke willing suspension of disbelief a couple of times, at least for me. And I found the ending a little too abrupt, feeling as if Scalzi had simply run out of story for now. However, there are two more books in this universe, and I was left wanting to go out and buy them.
(There is also one specific issue which bothered me a *lot*, but it bothers me for personal reasons which won't pertain to most readers -- see Nicholas Whyte's detailed post on the Bender episode: http://nhw.livejournal.com /642176.html plus the discussion in the comments thread for why that scene is the way it is and why some of us still think it comes over as a bone tossed to the more rabid "peaceniks are dumb" milsf fans. Lots of spoilers.)
If you're a Heinlein fan, this book's well worth reading. But it works in its own right as well, whether or not you've ever read any of the books it's influenced by. If you're looking for some milsf with some decent science fiction speculation, this one's worth a look.
Was this comment helpful? | Yes | No (6 of 10 readers found this comment helpful)
James Batka, April 10, 2007 (view all comments by James Batka)
John Scalzi's writing is very similar to that of Robert Heinlein and this book in particular pleasantly possesses some of the characteristics of Heilein's Starship Troopers (the Book!). Look for buried social commentary within the action of the story (what is the price of the continuation of the human species?). Look for an acknowledgement to Heilein in the credits.
It, however, possesses enough uniquenss to provide the reader with a refreshing new story and characters.
I'm very much looking for the new stories in this universe - The Ghost Brigades (published), The Last Colony (in editing), & The Sagan Diary (published but not part of the trilogy formed by the previous 3).
Was this comment helpful? | Yes | No (4 of 9 readers found this comment helpful)
Tor Books -
A stunning novel of the long war for human survival--in a universe replete with hostility
"Though a lot of SF writers are more or less efficiently continuing the tradition of Robert A. Heinlein, Scalzi's astonishingly proficient first novel reads like an original work by the late grand master."--"Publishers Weekly," starred review. A Hugo Award finalist.
John Perry did two things on his 75th birthday. First he visited his wife's grave. Then he joined the army.
The good news is that humanity finally made it into interstellar space. The bad news is that planets fit to live on are scarce--and alien races willing to fight us for them are common. So: we fight. To defend Earth, and to stake our own claim to planetary real estate. Far from Earth, the war has been going on for decades: brutal, bloody, unyielding.
Earth itself is a backwater. The bulk of humanity's resources are in the hands of the Colonial Defense Force. Everybody knows that when you reach retirement age, you can join the CDF. They don't want young people; they want people who carry the knowledge and skills of decades of living. You'll be taken off Earth and never allowed to return. You'll serve two years at the front. And if you survive, you'll be given a generous homestead stake of your own, on one of our hard-won colony planets.
John Perry is taking that deal. He has only the vaguest idea what to expect. Because the actual fight, light-years from home, is far, far harder than he can imagine--and what he will become is far stranger.
Powell's City of Books is an independent bookstore in Portland, Oregon, that fills a whole city block with more than a million new, used, and out of print books. Shop those shelves — plus literally millions more books, DVDs, and eBooks — here at Powells.com.