Knockout Narratives Sale
 
 

Special Offers see all

Enter to WIN a $100 Credit

Subscribe to PowellsBooks.news
for a chance to win.
Privacy Policy

Visit our stores


    Recently Viewed clear list


    The Powell's Playlist | January 19, 2015

    Ned Beauman: IMG The Powell's Playlist: Ned Beauman



    I did have a playlist that I listened to over and over again while I was writing Glow, but three years on I'm a bit bored of those songs, which got... Continue »

    spacer
Qualifying orders ship free.
$13.95
List price: $21.95
Used Hardcover
Ships in 1 to 3 days
Add to Wishlist
Qty Store Section
1 Beaverton Philosophy- General

More copies of this ISBN

Meditations (Modern Library)

by

Meditations (Modern Library) Cover

 

 

Reading Group Guide

1. The Meditations refers often to the need to act "unselfishly," yet much of its advice seems to center on seeking tranquillity within oneself and ignoring the outside world. Is this a contradiction? Do other people really matter to Marcus, or is his philosophical outlook fundamentally selfish?

2. What qualities does Marcus praise his relatives and teachers for in Book 1? Are they the same qualities he seeks to acquire in the remainder of the work?

3. Marcus ruled at a time when Christianity was beginning to become more prominent in the Roman world. What elements of Christianity would he have found sympathetic? What elements would have been incompatible with his outlook? Do aspects of Marcus's Stoicism find echoes in other religious traditions, for example in Buddhism?

4. Marcus several times uses the image of life as a play (e.g. 3.8, 11.1, 12.36). What specific similarities does he see? Is the image helpful in encapsulating his philosophy in other ways?

5. "We need to practice acceptance," Marcus says (7.3). "Without disdain." Do the entries in the Meditations show him doing that?

6. At several points Marcus expresses disapproval of the Epicureans for making pleasure their highest goal. Why does he find this attitude so objectionable?

7. The English poet and critic Matthew Arnold faulted the Meditations for a lack of joy. The translator's introduction agrees, and suggests that Marcus's pessimistic evaluation of human life is "impoverishing." Is this a fair criticism?

8. Marcus often describes the world as being in a process of constant change, yet he sees an underlying unity and direction in the way it works. Are these two conceptions compatible? Do modern theories about the nature of the universe make Marcus's outlook more appealing than it might have seemed a century ago?

9. Does the Stoics' emphasis on accepting all that happens to us as natural prevent them from trying to change the world in positive ways? Would a Stoic have participated in the civil rights movement, for example?

10. Marcus asserts (4.8) that only what harms our character can harm us. Is this true?

11. In urging himself not to fear death, Marcus makes use of several arguments found in other ancient thinkers: that others have faced extinction with courage, that death is a natural process, that non-existence did not harm us before our birth and can't harm us after it, that death is unavoidable in any case. Are these arguments intellectually convincing? Do you find them emotionally persuasive?

12. What is the significance of the anecdote about the Spartans at 11.24?

13. Like many Romans, Marcus finds it helpful to use certain historical figures (e.g. Alexander the Great, Socrates, Nero) as touchstones of human virtue or vice. What historical figures serve a similar function for us? Is this practice useful or potentially misleading?

14. Would the Stoics' respect for nature translate into an endorsement of modern-day environmentalism?

15. Marcus's two sketches of his predecessor Antoninus Pius (1.16; 6.30) might be regarded as a kind of "mirror for princes," i.e. a portrait of the ideal ruler. Are the characteristics Marcus singles out the ones we look for in modern-day leaders? What other characteristics might he have added?

16. If you were to compile a catalogue of "debts and lessons" like the first book of the Meditations, who would appear in it?

17. Marcus advises himself at one point "to stop talking about what the good man is like and just be one" (10.16). Is it possible to be good without self-reflection? Are self-reflective people always the best?

Product Details

ISBN:
9780679642602
Translator:
Hays, Gregory
Author:
Hays, Gregory
Author:
Aurelius, Marcus
Author:
Marcus, Aurelius
Author:
Marcus
Publisher:
Modern Library
Location:
New York
Subject:
General
Subject:
Religious
Subject:
Ethics & Moral Philosophy
Subject:
Ethics
Subject:
Life
Subject:
Stoics
Subject:
History & Surveys - Ancient & Classical
Subject:
General Philosophy
Subject:
Philosophy : General
Subject:
Ancient
Subject:
philosophy;classics;stoicism;non-fiction;rome;ethics;history;marcus aurelius;ancient rome;classic;classical;essays;literature;stoic;ancient;2nd century;religion;ancient philosophy;roman empire;latin;biography;stoics;marcus;classical literature;autobiograp
Subject:
philosophy;classics;stoicism;non-fiction;rome;ethics;history;marcus aurelius;ancient rome;classic;essays;classical;literature;stoic;ancient;ancient philosophy;2nd century;religion;roman empire;latin;biography;stoics;marcus;classical literature;classical s
Subject:
philosophy;classics;stoicism;non-fiction;rome;ethics;history;marcus aurelius;ancient rome;classic;essays;classical;literature;stoic;ancient;ancient philosophy;2nd century;religion;roman empire;latin;biography;stoics;marcus;classical literature;classical s
Copyright:
Edition Number:
Modern Library ed.
Edition Description:
Modern Library Hardcover
Series:
Modern Library
Series Volume:
1625-C
Publication Date:
20020531
Binding:
HARDCOVER
Grade Level:
General/trade
Language:
English
Pages:
256
Dimensions:
8.34x5.32x.68 in. .71 lbs.

Other books you might like

  1. Art of Worldly Wisdom Used Trade Paper $1.95
  2. A Manual for Living (Little Book of... Used Trade Paper $6.50
  3. Goodbye Columbus Used Mass Market $2.95
  4. Dune: House Atreides Used Hardcover $4.95
  5. Until the end :a novel Used Hardcover $1.75
  6. Souls of Black Folk (03 Edition) Used Hardcover $10.00

Related Subjects

Business » General
Business » Management
Fiction and Poetry » Classics » Latin » General
Humanities » Philosophy » Ethics
Humanities » Philosophy » General

Meditations (Modern Library) Used Hardcover
0 stars - 0 reviews
$13.95 In Stock
Product details 256 pages Modern Library - English 9780679642602 Reviews:
spacer
spacer
  • back to top

FOLLOW US ON...

     
Powell's City of Books is an independent bookstore in Portland, Oregon, that fills a whole city block with more than a million new, used, and out of print books. Shop those shelves — plus literally millions more books, DVDs, and gifts — here at Powells.com.