Synopses & Reviews
This work defines the central concepts of Israels national security doctrine as deterrence, geography, manpower, quantity versus quality, offensive maneuver warfare, conventional versus unconventional threats, self-reliance, great power patronage, and peripheral partnerships.
The author describes and explains how these concepts have influenced the war fighting experience of the Israel Defense Forces, including the air force and the navy. Special attention is paid to Israels relationships with the United States, Turkey, and India as they relate to the Jewish states national security, and in particular offers a new interpretation of what really drives these relationships; the motives behind Israeli foreign policy and Israeli arms export policy; and whether Israels national security doctrine ought to include a capability to threaten the existence of hostile Arab (and Islamic) governments. Sections of this book have been used to teach a class on strategic studies at the National Defense University in Washington, DC.
Review
“In a short, insightful book about Israels strategic thinking, Rodman proves a clear overview of Israels national security… [The author] reviews the appropriate paradigm for the analysis of Israels external strategy, and Israels rare attempts to adopt far-reaching goals such as targeting hostile governments.” —Middle East Quarterly
Review
“As Israel and Hezbollah disengage in Lebanon and the international community grudgingly attempts to enforce a cease-fire, the Israeli political and military elites will, no doubt, embark on some significant introspection. Not least, they will wonder why they ostensibly failed to neutralize the threat posed by Hezbollah, even with the support of both the US and the UK. Written in 2005, Rodmans book elucidates upon a number of issues pertaining to asymmetrical warfare and general threats from nonstate actors, an especially relevant subject within the context of the recent violence in Lebanon. In particular, the author states that, should Israel find itself fighting in another regional war, it would be likely to attack its enemies targets with air, sea and land-based ordnance before engaging in ‘ offensive manoeuvre warfare (p. 14) … Well-written and well-researched.” —Israel Affairs
Review
“While Defense and Diplomacy in Israel's National Security Experience was written in 2005, it reads as if it was intended as an alternative to the flimsy analysis of the newspaper and television coverage of the 2006 Lebanon hostilities. The television and news analysis of Israeli tactics in that war tended to view each new action taken by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) from the standpoint of world opinion, or at best, from the standpoint of a single tactical premise and not from an overall strategic objective. Rodmans book, instructs the reader to view IDF tactics from both the historical and long-term perspective. … David Rodmans book provides a well organized, well written, and thorough analysis of Israels military for a period of sixty years. More importantly, it provides an objective basis for understanding Israels military reaction to recent, and present, provocations. Because the threats to Israel must be viewed as existential, as opposed to the threats posed recently to the United States, Israels response must be viewed in the context reflected in this tightly written and cogent work.” —Journal of Global Change and Governance
Review
“This book of essays examines a wide range of topics from the role of the Air Force in Israels National Security strategy, to Israels bilateral relationship with Turkey and the US, to Israels arms export policy and the factors motivating its foreign policy. However, these, and a number of other issues, are all linked together by their centrality to Israels complex, and at times contradictory, national security requirements. Given the challenges facing the Jewish state this work is very timely, all the more so because the author brings a deep knowledge to the subject. All in all a highly informative work that makes an important contribution to the literature on Israeli strategy and involvement in the international arena.” —Efraim Karsh, Head Mediterranean Studies Programme, Kings College, University of London
About the Author
David Rodman has written numerous articles, review essays, and book reviews on various aspects of the ArabIsraeli conflict for professional journals, including Middle Eastern Studies, The Journal of Strategic Studies, MERIA Journal, Israel Affairs, Defence Studies, and Air and Space Power Chronicles. He has also contributed chapters to From War to Peace?, Review Essays in Israel Studies: Books on Israel, Vol. 5, and Between War and Peace: Dilemmas of Israeli Security.