Synopses & Reviews
Acrimony and hyperpartisanship have seeped into every part of the political process. Congress is deadlocked and its approval ratings are at record lows. America’s two main political parties have given up their traditions of compromise, endangering our very system of constitutional democracy. And one of these parties has taken on the role of insurgent outlier; the Republicans have become ideologically extreme, scornful of compromise, and ardently opposed to the established social and economic policy regime. In It’s Even Worse Than It Looks
, congressional scholars Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein identify two overriding problems that have led Congress—and the United States—to the brink of institutional collapse. The first is the serious mismatch between our political parties, which have become as vehemently adversarial as parliamentary parties, and a governing system that, unlike a parliamentary democracy, makes it extremely difficult for majorities to act. Second, while both parties participate in tribal warfare, both sides are not equally culpable. The political system faces what the authors call “asymmetric polarization,” with the Republican Party implacably refusing to allow anything that might help the Democrats politically, no matter the cost. With dysfunction rooted in long-term political trends, a coarsened political culture and a new partisan media, the authors conclude that there is no “silver bullet” reform that can solve everything. But they offer a panoply of useful ideas and reforms, endorsing some solutions, like greater public participation and institutional restructuring of the House and Senate, while debunking others, like independent or third-party candidates. Above all, they call on the media as well as the public at large to focus on the true causes of dysfunction rather than just throwing the bums out every election cycle. Until voters learn to act strategically to reward problem solving and punish obstruction, American democracy will remain in serious danger.
Paul A. Volcker, former Chairman of the Federal Reserve
“More than anytime in my lifetime, the United States is challenged at home and so is our place in the world. When Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein get together to sound a loud alarm about the way our political system is being torn apart, it’s time to listen—and listen hard. Then the tough part—how do we restore some sense of common purpose, of working together to make our government work? Mann and Ornstein set out ways to rebuild political bridges, beginning right now. We better get to work.” Chuck Hagel, U.S. Senator (1997–2009), Distinguished Professor, Georgetown University
“This is an exceptionally important and cogent analysis of America’s breakdown in self-governance. It is an urgent warning of the consequences of our intolerant politics and governing paralysis, and ways to fix it.” Tom Daschle, former Senate Majority Leader
“One doesn't have to agree with every one of Mann and Ornstein’s proposals to appreciate the extraordinary contribution to improving governance that they make in this important book. We could do no better than to use it as a compelling blueprint for urgently needed reform. If every member of Congress would read just one book on the subject, my wish is that it would be this one.”
E. J. Dionne, author of Our Divided Political Heart
“The phrase ‘essential reading’ does not begin to get at the importance of this passionate warning by two of our very best political scientists about our nation’s capacity to govern itself. Mann and Ornstein sweep aside the timid conventional wisdom to inform Americans that our problems are even worse than we think they are. It is absolutely vital that this book’s findings and message enter the consciousness and consciences of journalists, politicians and citizens who care about the future of our republic.”
Paul A. Volcker, former Chairman of the Federal Reserve
More than anytime in my lifetime, the United States is challenged at home and so is our place in the world. When Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein get together to sound a loud alarm about the way our political system is being torn apart, its time to listenand listen hard. Then the tough parthow do we restore some sense of common purpose, of working together to make our government work? Mann and Ornstein set out ways to rebuild political bridges, beginning right now. We better get to work.” Chuck Hagel, U.S. Senator (19972009), Distinguished Professor, Georgetown University
This is an exceptionally important and cogent analysis of Americas breakdown in self-governance. It is an urgent warning of the consequences of our intolerant politics and governing paralysis, and ways to fix it.” Tom Daschle, former Senate Majority Leader
One doesn't have to agree with every one of Mann and Ornsteins proposals to appreciate the extraordinary contribution to improving governance that they make in this important book. We could do no better than to use it as a compelling blueprint for urgently needed reform. If every member of Congress would read just one book on the subject, my wish is that it would be this one.”
E. J. Dionne, author of Our Divided Political Heart
The phrase essential reading does not begin to get at the importance of this passionate warning by two of our very best political scientists about our nations capacity to govern itself. Mann and Ornstein sweep aside the timid conventional wisdom to inform Americans that our problems are even worse than we think they are. It is absolutely vital that this books findings and message enter the consciousness and consciences of journalists, politicians and citizens who care about the future of our republic.”William Jefferson Clinton, 42nd President of the United States of AmericaIn Its Even Worse Than It Looks, Mann and Ornstein diagnose the roots of our nations new legislative order. In doing so, they draw attention to the forces holding back Americas future and the changes we must make in order to overcome them.” Robert G. Kaiser, Washington Post Reading this book is a little like quaffing a double espresso on an empty stomach its a jolt. For this reader it was a welcome jolt. . . . Thomas E. Mann and Norman J. Ornstein have been Washington fixtures for three decades. They are two of the brightest, best informed and most scholarly students of our politics. . . . [As] Mann and Ornstein document so vividly, at a time when only good government could help us rediscover our footing as a nation, our Grand Old Party defines itself as the party of anti-government. This is why the title of this book is so good: Our situation really is even worse than it looks.” Paul Krugman, New York TimesThe Congressional scholars Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein have been making waves with a new book acknowledging a truth that, until now, was unmentionable in polite circles. They say our political dysfunction is largely because of the transformation of the Republican Party into an extremist force that is dismissive of the legitimacy of its political opposition.” You cant get cooperation to serve the national interest when one side of the divide sees no distinction between the national interest and its own partisan triumph.” Timothy Egan, New York Times[It] is encouraging to see two longtime Washington wise men Thomas E. Mann and Norman J. Ornstein, sensible, nonpartisan scholars and impeccably credentialed authors of good advice that no one ever follows come out with a full-blown polemic against the Republicans who have steered Congress off a cliff.” The EconomistWhat happens to a two-party political system when one party goes mad? That is the question posed in a powerful and angry new book by two scholars at two respected think-tanks, Thomas Mann of the Brookings Institution and Norman Ornstein of the American Enterprise Institute.” The Economist, Lexington Notebook BlogNorman Ornstein of the American Enterprise Institute and Thomas Mann of Brookings are highly respected analysts. . . . Coming from them, the claim that the American system is even worse than it looks deserves to be taken with the utmost seriousness. . . . Mann and Ornstein provide one of the most careful, forensic accounts so far of how Congress has worked in these conditions. They are also astonishingly frank about what they think of the Republican Party and about the media.” Eric Alterman, TheNation.comWritten by Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein, two long-time Congressional scholars, Its Even Worse Than It Looks fillets the traditional media for perpetuating a principle of false equivalence in its coverage of the two parties, the effect of which, they say, has merely masked the GOPs unalloyed march toward the fringes of the right wing. . . . Insightful.” Juan Williams, The HillWe now have historys first draft of the story of this Congress. There is so much political fog right now that it is hard to get a clear view of the reason for the dysfunction on Capitol Hill. But three new books take a step back to get a clear look at the fray, and all three conclude that no-holds-barred, right-wing politics is to be blamed. . . . Mann and Ornstein paint sad pictures of a House Republican Conference that is more loyal to party than to country and intentionally crippling Congress at a time when the country faces unusually serious problems and grave threats.” R. Garrett Mitchell, The Mitchell Report[A] compelling analysis of the gridlock that characterizes Americas domestic politics.” Steve Benen, The Maddow Blog, MSNBC[W]hat we have here is a group of respected, credible, inside-the-beltway establishment types who are now willing to acknowledge what is plainly true: Republican extremism has no modern precedent, and it making governing and policymaking nearly impossible, even during times of crises despite the demands that Very Serious People agree that both sides” are always to blame for everything in all instances. Indeed, theyre making these pronouncements in a surprising, matter-of-fact sort of way. Heres hoping other respected, credible, inside-the-beltway establishment types feel emboldened to be equally candid about reality.” The Daily Kos[An] excellent book that
may have an impact on the 2012 campaign. . . . [It] should be read by every progressive. Its not going to change many progressive minds, but it deepens our perspective on the history of this and the political science perspectives involved. . . . That is one of the keys to the brilliance of this book
Buy the book. Pass it around. Spread the word. Our nation has a crisis in Congress worse than anything weve seen in 150 years. The sooner more of us recognize that, the sooner we can get to work on solutions that are appropriate to the problem.” Bonnie Erbe, Scripps Howard News ServiceTwo of the most sage politics watchers of our time are congressional scholars Norm Ornstein of the (mainly conservative) American Enterprise Institute and Thomas Mann of the (more Democratic than not) Brookings Institution. Together they've written and just released a book called Its Even Worse Than It Looks.” It is about our broken, dysfunctional, nonfunctioning partisan political system. . . . When and if voters learn to think strategically and reward problem solving, the American impasse might end. If they punish rather than reward obstruction, the blood of American democracy might start flowing once more.” Catherine Poe, Washington Times Ad Lib Blog
Something awful happened on the way to the 21st Century. This should have been the new American century, but by the time the Republican Party got through with us, we were a country, battered, on its knees, reeling from the body blows. . . . Just out and stirring up debate
[Its Even Worse Than It Looks] confronts our uniquely American problem head on.” Tom Moran, New Jersey Star Ledger
[T]wo respected centrist scholars, Norman Ornstein and Thomas Mann, have written a book that moves past the bland and lazy conventional wisdom. They argue, with a truckload of evidence, that the blame in Washington lies overwhelmingly with Republicans. . . . .Our national politics has turned a strange corner. And it is a cop-out to say that both parties are equally to blame. Strained attempts to be even-handed distort the reality we face. . . . The book is titled Its Even Worse Than It Looks and it is both fascinating and alarming." Michael Brissenden, Australian Broadcasting Corporation [Its Even Worse Than It Looks has] blown the lid off the usually staid and predictable world of political punditry.” Barrie Dunsmor, Barre-Montpelier Times Argus (Barre-Montpelier, VT)Mann and Ornstein are among the brightest and best informed political scientists in the country. . . . [T]his book really is a must read for anyone who cares about what is happening to this country.” Ed Luce, Financial Times[T]he authors know what they are talking about, lay it out clearly and are right to broadcast their concern about the health of US democracy. They are also correct and brave to emphasise the asymmetric nature of Americas polarisation. . . . The book is chiefly about what ails Washington and its diagnosis is depressingly convincing. The authors are right to point out that things may be even worse than they seem. If the era of ill-tempered partisanship is here to stay, then gridlocked governance is also a fixture. So, therefore, is Americas decline.” David Frum, CNN.comOrnstein and Mann offer a convincing array of explanations for the trend toward radicalism within the GOP, including changes in campaign finance and in the electorate itself. They offer too a range of proposals to work around GOP radicalism and restore the effective functioning of Congress. If those proposals have a faint wistful air to them, blame the inherent difficulty of the problem, not Mann and Ornstein. . . . [P]owerful and important.” San Ramon Express (San Ramon, CA) [Mann and Ornstein] have been navigating the shifting currents of the Potomac for more than 40 years each; their expertise is beyond serious debate, their credentials are impeccable, their reputations firmly established. Which is why its extremely important to take note of their recent book Its Even Worse Than It Looks.” In it, they lay blame for the current policy morass in Washington directly, unequivocally at the feet of one political party: the Republicans. . . . [A] blistering indictment.” Richard L. Hasen, Slate.com
Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein offer both an insightful diagnosis of the problem of a broken Washington and a set of proposed solutions. . . . Mann and Ornstein have done a great public service in opening a dialogue on how to fix the mismatch between our political and constitutional systems of government.”
The Weekly Standard
Mann and Ornstein
are the deans of the Beltway Establishment, at least its intellectual wing. For them to argue so tendentiously that the GOP is to blame for the ills of Washington offers compelling proof of how insiders view the Tea Party and modern conservatism, as well as the tactics they employ to get across these opinions.”Hendrik Hertzberg, The New Yorker (online only)
Its Even Worse Than It Looks is a cogent, concise, and, in its think-tanky way, passionate book. One of its strengths is that the authors go beyond simply (and quite persuasively) scolding the Republicans. They recognize that the G.O.P.s New Politics of Extremism is enabled by the American Constitutional System broadly understood. . . . The emperor has no clothes, and kudos to Ornstein and Mann for pointing it out. Unfortunately, the Republican solution is to turn the country into one big nudist camp.”
Wall Street Journal
[R]eading Its Even Worse Than It Looks by Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein may give you indigestion. That isn't the fault of the authors, who are two of the nation's keenest political analysts. Rather, the blame belongs to the sorry state of America's two-party political system.”
New YorkerNews Desks Ten Best Political Books of 2012
An accessible study of the most important political trend of the past few decades: asymmetrical polarization.”
In the wake of yet another disastrous year in American politics, two of the nations foremost experts on Congress provide their brief, strongly argued take on whats wrong and how to fix it.
Hyperpartisanship is as old as American democracy. In moments of heightened rancor, congressmen and senators used to challenge each other to duels or hit each other with canes. But now, acrimony is not confined to a moment; its a permanent state of affairs. Nor is it confined to Congress; it has seeped into every part of the political process. Thus, Congress approval ratings are at record lows, and both Democrats and Republicans are disgusted by the governments inability to get anything done.
In Its Worse Than It Looks, Congressional scholars Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein present a grim picture of how personal pettiness and childish tribalism have led Congress and the United States to the brink of institutional failure. Though the nation handed the reins of governance to the Democrats in 2006 and then again in 2008, the Republicans pursued obstructionist tactics, and since they were rewarded for those tactics in 2010, things have only gotten worse. Since the 2010 midterms, the legislative process has been stuck in a grinding gridlock because of the Republican Partys refusal to allow anything that might help the Democrats politically, no matter what the cost. At the same time, artificial barriers to compromise such as campaign pledges, the abuse of arcane parliamentary rules and purity tests in primary campaigns have been erected, exacerbating pre-existing structural deficiencies in all branches of government.
Having diagnosed the problem, the authors offer solutions. There is no silver bullet” reform that can solve everything, but increased education, greater political participation, more outlets for responsible, non-extreme voices, and institutional restructuring of the House and Senate will fix Congress functionality and rescue American democracy from the bickering and gridlock of recent decades.
Though partisanship is as old as American democracy, political acrimony is no longer confined to moments of high passion; it’s a permanent state of affairs. Congress is deadlocked and its approval ratings are at record lows. America’s two main political parties have given up their traditions of compromise, creating a mismatch between our Constitutional democracy and the functional realities of modern politics. And one of these parties has taken on the role of eternal adversary; many Republicans refused to so much as acknowledge the legitimacy of those duly elected officials who do not fit within their own rigid ideological framework.In The Road to Obstruction
, Congressional scholars Thomas Mann and Norman Ornstein present a grim picture of how personal pettiness and childish tribalism have led Congress – and the United States – to the brink of institutional collapse. Since the Republicans were rewarded for their obstructionist tactics in the 2010 midterm elections, they have refused to allow anything that might help the Democrats politically, resulting in grinding gridlock. At the same time, artificial barriers to compromise – such as campaign pledges, the abuse of arcane parliamentary rules, and purity tests in primary campaigns – have exacerbated pre-existing structural deficiencies in all branches of government.
Having diagnosed the problem, the authors endorse some solutions, like greater public participation and institutional restructuring of the House and Senate, while debunking others, like independent or third-party candidates. Above all, they call on the media as well as the public at large to focus on the true causes of dysfunction rather than just throwing the bums out every election cycle. There is no “silver bullet” reform that can solve everything, but without attempts to restore functionality to our government, American democracy will remain in serious danger.
About the Author
Thomas E. Mann is the W. Averell Harriman Chair and senior fellow in Governance Studies at The Brookings Institution. He is a former executive director of the American Political Science Association. He lives in Bethesda, Maryland. Norman J. Ornstein is a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and the author of a weekly column for Roll Call, called “Congress Inside Out.” He lives in Washington, D.C. Both are fellows of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. They are coauthors of The Broken Branch: How Congress is Failing America and How to Get It Back on Track.