Synopses & Reviews
Perilous Memories makes a groundbreaking and critical intervention into debates about war memory in the Asia-Pacific region. Arguing that much is lost or erased when the Asia-Pacific War(s) are reduced to the 1941andndash;1945 war between Japan and the United States, this collection challenges mainstream memories of the Second World War in favor of what were actually multiple, widespread conflicts. The contributors recuperate marginalized or silenced memories of wars throughout the regionandmdash;not only in Japan and the United States but also in China, Southeast Asia, the Pacific Islands, Okinawa, Taiwan, and Korea.
and#9;Firmly based on the insight that memory is always mediated and that the past is not a stable object, the volume demonstrates that we can intervene positively yet critically in the recovery and reinterpretation of events and experiences that have been pushed to the peripheries of the past. The contributorsandmdash;an international list of anthropologists, cultural critics, historians, literary scholars, and activistsandmdash;show how both dominant and subjugated memories have emerged out of entanglements with such forces as nationalism, imperialism, colonialism, racism, and sexism. They consider both how the past is remembered and also what the consequences may be of privileging one set of memories over others. Specific objects of study range from photographs, animation, songs, and films to military occupations and attacks, minorities in wartime, andldquo;comfort women,andrdquo; commemorative events, and postwar activism in pursuing redress and reparations.
and#9;Perilous Memories is a model for war memory intervention and will be of interest to historians and other scholars and activists engaged with collective memory, colonial studies, U.S. and Asian history, and cultural studies.
Contributors. Chen Yingzhen, Chungmoo Choi, Vicente M. Diaz, Arif Dirlik, T. Fujitani, Ishihara Masaie, Lamont Lindstrom, George Lipsitz, Marita Sturken, Toyonaga Keisaburo, Utsumi Aiko, Morio Watanabe, Geoffrey M. White, Diana Wong, Daqing Yang, Lisa Yoneyama
Review
andldquo;Perilous Memories is a major statement in current discussions concerned with assessing the problematic relationship of history and memory. The authors gathered in this volume edited by T. Fujitani, Geoffrey White, and Lisa Yoneyama forcefully rescue the memories of other wars and genocides in the arena of Asia-Pacific to remind us of the dangerous but necessary task of the present to actualize the past in order to remember the forgotten yet unforgettable. With this volume we have an incomparable guide to what Walter Benjamin once described as the andlsquo;copernican turn to remembrance.andrsquo;andrdquo;andmdash;Harry Harootunian, New York University
Review
andldquo;This excellent interdisciplinary collection of essays gives diverse and heterogeneous voice to many ordinary people who suffered in the Asian wars that began in 1931andmdash;wars that, for many of these same people, never really ended. At every turn, Perilous Memories counterpoints the extraordinary elites who have dominated historical memory with the recuperated experience of their victims. This book is a major contribution to what the authors call andlsquo;critical war remembering.andrsquo;andrdquo;andmdash;Bruce Cumings, author of Parallax Visions: Making Sense of American-East Asian Relations at the End of the Century
Review
andldquo;Unsettling official national accounts with memories of war from Okinawa, Guam, and Taiwan, of the Nanjing massacre, occupied Singapore, and the Hiroshima bombingandmdash;PERILOUS MEMORIES provokes a haunting dialectic between familiar history and endangered memories.andrdquo;andmdash;Lisa Lowe, University of California, San Diego
Synopsis
A rethinking of the differing national memories of the Second World War in the Pacific in light of recent theories of nationalism, imperialism, and colonialism.
About the Author
“Perilous Memories is a major statement in current discussions concerned with assessing the problematic relationship of history and memory. The authors gathered in this volume edited by T. Fujitani, Geoffrey White, and Lisa Yoneyama forcefully rescue the memories of other wars and genocides in the arena of Asia-Pacific to remind us of the dangerous but necessary task of the present to actualize the past in order to remember the forgotten yet unforgettable. With this volume we have an incomparable guide to what Walter Benjamin once described as the ‘copernican turn to remembrance.’”—Harry Harootunian, New York University“This excellent interdisciplinary collection of essays gives diverse and heterogeneous voice to many ordinary people who suffered in the Asian wars that began in 1931—wars that, for many of these same people, never really ended. At every turn, Perilous Memories counterpoints the extraordinary elites who have dominated historical memory with the recuperated experience of their victims. This book is a major contribution to what the authors call ‘critical war remembering.’”—Bruce Cumings, author of Parallax Visions: Making Sense of American-East Asian Relations at the End of the Century“Unsettling official national accounts with memories of war from Okinawa, Guam, and Taiwan, of the Nanjing massacre, occupied Singapore, and the Hiroshima bombing—PERILOUS MEMORIES provokes a haunting dialectic between familiar history and endangered memories.”—Lisa Lowe, University of California, San Diego
Table of Contents
Acknowledgments vii
Introduction / T. Fujitani, Geoffrey M. White, and Lisa Yoneyama 1
1. Memory Fragments, Memory Images
Absent Images of Memory: Remembering and Reenacting the Japanese Internment / Marita Sturken 33
The Malleable and the Contested: The Nanjing Massacre in Postwar China and Japan / Daqing Yang 50
Memories of War and Okinawa / Ishihara Masaie 87
Images of Islanders in Pacific War Photographs / Lamont Lindstrom 107
Imagery and War in Japan: 1995 / Morio Watanabe 129
2. Politics and Poetics of Liberation
Deliberating andldquo;Liberation Dayandrdquo;: Identity, History, Memory, and War in Guam / Vicente M. Diaz 155
Imperial Army Betrayed / Chen Yingzhen 181
Korean andldquo;Imperial Soldiersandrdquo;: Remembering Colonialism and Crimes against Allied POWs / Utsumi Aiko 199
Memory Suppression and Memory Production: The Japanese Occupation of Singapore / Diana Wong 218
Go For Broke, the Movie, Japanese American Soldiers in U.S. National, Military, and Racial Discourses / T. Fujitani 239
Moving History: The Pearl Harbor Film(s) / Geoffrey M. White 267
3. Atonement, Healing, and Unexpected Alliances
andldquo;Trapped in Historyandrdquo; on the Way to Utopia: East Asiaandrsquo;s andldquo;Great Warandrdquo; Fifty Years Later / Arif Dirlik 299
For Transformative Knowledge and Postnationalist Public Spheres: The Smithsonian Enola Gay Controversy / Lisa Yoneyama 323
andldquo;Frantic to Join . . . the Japanese Armyandrdquo;: Black Soldiers and Civilians Confront the Asia Pacific War / George Lipsitz 347
Colonialism and Atom Bombs: About Survivors of Hiroshima Living in Korea / Toyonaga Keisaburo 378
The Politics of War Memories toward Healing / Chungmoo Choi 395
Bibliography 411
Filmography 435
Index 437
Contributors 461