Synopses & Reviews
This book is a study of popular responses to the English Reformation. It takes as its subject not the conversion of English subjects to a new religion but rather their political responses to a Reformation perceived as an act of state and hence, like all early modern acts of state, negotiated between government and people. These responses included not only resistance but also significant levels of accommodation, co-operation and collaboration as people attempted to co-opt state power for their own purposes. This study argues, then, that the English Reformation was not done to people, it was done with them in a dynamic process of engagement between government and people. As such, it answers the twenty-year-old scholarly dilemma of how the English Reformation could have succeeded despite the inherent conservatism of the English people, and it presents the first genuinely post-revisionist account of one of the central events of English history.
Review
"Ethan Shagan has given us a wonderful book which seeks to get beyond the often dry academic debates that often dominate the field of Reformation history." Presbyterian History"In this masterful study, Shagan shifts the frame of reference through which the progress of the Reformation in England is understood. Recommended." Choice"A worthy addition to Cambridge Studies in Early Modern British History, an essential and extensive series with which experts ought to make themselves fully familiiar." Bibliotheque d'humanisme et Reniassance
Review
"Ethan Shagan set out to fire controversy and in this he will succeed." Thomas F. Mayer, Augustana College
Review
"[A] fascinating interpretation of the English Reformation...Shagan asks imaginative and fresh questions of the evidence...Lucidly and incisively written, Shagan's work offers much to ponder." William Wizeman, S.J., Fordham University, Sixteenth Century Journal
Review
"Shagan explores the key social, religious, cultural and governmental elements in England's conversion to a Protestant nation...[a] comprehensive text..." Northwestern
Review
"...an impressive response to revisionists who argue that the English were inherently conservative and resistant to religious change." Religious Studies Review
Review
"A well-written, innovative work that makes an important and provocative contribution to the debate about why Catholicism lost its hold on the English people." Journal of Interdisciplinary History
Review
"One of the most thought-provoking books of the last decade on this much-worked topic." Renaissance Quarterly
Review
"This is a book that students of the English Reformation must read, as much for its historiographical arguments as for its case studies...This book is an effective attempt to move the debate over the English Reformation off dead center...Based on extensive archival work, this volume does not pretened to be a history of the Reformation; rather, is presents an argument about how reformation occurred. It refreshingly quits trying to count converted noses and conservative faithful and asks a most reasonable question: what did people do in the face of reform from above?" - Journal of Modern History, Norman Jones, Utah State University
Synopsis
This study of popular responses to the English Reformation analyzes how ordinary people received, interpreted, debated, and responded to religious change. It differs from other studies by arguing that the subject cannot be understood simply by asking theological questions about people's beliefs, but must be understood by asking political questions about how they negotiated with state power. Therefore, it concerns political as well as religious history, since it asserts that, even at the popular level, political and theological processes were inseparable in the sixteenth century.
Synopsis
A study of popular responses to the English Reformation after Henry VIII's break from Rome.
Synopsis
Includes bibliographical references (p. 311-326) and index.
About the Author
Ethan H. Shagan is Assistant Professor of History at Northwestern University. He received his Ph.D. from Princeton University in 2000 and was a Junior Fellow of the Harvard University Society of Fellows. He has published articles in The English Historical Review, The Journal of British Studies, The Journal of Ecclesiastical History, and in numerous edited collections. This is his first book.
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements; List of abbreviations; Note on the text; Introduction; Part I. The Break with Rome and the Crisis of Conservatism: 1. 'Schismatics be now plain heretics': debating the royal supremacy over the Church of England; 2. The anatomy of opposition in early Reformation England: the case of Elizabeth Barton, the holy maid of Kent; 3. Politics and the Pilgrimage of Grace revisited; Part II. Points of Contact: The Henrician Reformation and the English People: 4. Anticlericalism, popular politics and the Henrician Reformation; 5. Selling the sacred: Reformation and dissolution at the Abbey of Hailes; 6. 'Open disputation was in alehouses': religious debate in the diocese of Canterbury, c. 1543; Part III. Sites of Reformation: Collaboration and Popular Politics under Edward VI: 7. Resistance and collaboration in the dissolution of the chantries; 8. The English people and the Edwardian Reformation; Conclusion; Bibliography; Index.