Synopses & Reviews
"On February 12, 2009, numerous observances, conferences and books will celebrate the bicentennials of two major 19th-century figures: Lincoln and Darwin. Historian Contosta (Henry Adams and His World) uses the coincidence of their shared birth date as the basis for a thin, sophomoric comparison of the two men. Both, according to Contosta, introduced paradigm shifts in how people thought about humanity, whether human dignity or our place in the natural world; both men struggled against attempts, such as slavery, to dehumanize people. And both were self-made men: Lincoln in the more usual sense of the term, Darwin because he rejected the path his father had chosen and found his own calling. At first glance, the author notes, Lincoln and Darwin are very different: the former from a frontier family who had little formal education; the latter, from a wealthy family, graduated from Cambridge. Yet they both lost their mothers at an early age; both struggled with doubts about religion, were ambitious and had quick minds. But Contosta mainly catalogues these differences and similarities without delving deeply into their significance, yielding no new insights into these two well-known lives." Publishers Weekly (Copyright Reed Business Information, Inc.)
February 12, 2009, will mark the 200th anniversary of the birth of two of the most extraordinary and influential men in recent historyAbraham Lincoln and Charles Darwin. Contosta makes a compelling case that by studying the similarities (along with the differences) between these two giants of history we are able to understand each man better than by examining their lives in isolation.
February 12, 2009, will mark the 200th anniversary of the birth of two of the most extraordinary and influential men in recent history Abraham Lincoln and Charles Darwin. While the coincidence of these two men being born on exactly the same day might fill astrologers with glee, further reflection points to many parallels and intersections in their lives. In this unique approach to history and biography, historian David R. Contosta examines the lives and careers of Lincoln (the political rebel) and Darwin (the scientific rebel), and notes many surprising and illuminating points of comparison.
Contosta points out that despite obvious differences one born to a poorly educated, impoverished family on the American frontier, the other to a wealthy and prominent English family; one largely self-taught, the other with a degree from Cambridge; one a politician seeking the crowd s approval, the other a reclusive scientist there are striking similarities between these seemingly disparate individuals. Both Lincoln and Darwin:
Lost their mothers in childhood and later lost beloved children at young ages.
Had strained relations with their fathers.
Went through years of searching for a direction to their lives.
Struggled with religious doubt.
Were latter-day sons of the Enlightenment who elevated reason over religious revelation.
Suffered from severe bouts of depression.
Were ambitious as well as patient, with sure and steady mental powers rather than quick minds.
Possessed an excellent sense of pacing that allowed them to wait until the time was ripe for their ideas and leadership.
Contosta makes a compelling case that by studying the similarities (along with the differences) between these two giants of history we are able to understand each man better than by examining their lives in isolation. This approach also affords many insights into the factors that impel special individuals to lead great paradigm shifts.
Today, as American society still struggles to come to grips with the impact of racial integration and controversies over the teaching of evolution, it is more important than ever to understand how two nineteenth-century men with revolutionary ideas helped to shape the present."
About the Author
David R. Contosta (Chestnut Hill, PA) is professor of history at Chestnut Hill College and the author of eight books on American history, including Henry Adams and His World.