Synopses & Reviews
One of The Telegraph
s Best Music Books 2011 We live in a pop age gone loco for retro and crazy for commemoration. Band re-formations and reunion tours, expanded reissues of classic albums and outtake-crammed box sets, remakes and sequels, tribute albums and mash-ups . . . But what happens when we run out of past? Are we heading toward a sort of culturalecological catastrophe where the archival stream of pop history has been exhausted?
Simon Reynolds, one of the finest music writers of his generation, argues that we have indeed reached a tipping point, and that although earlier eras had their own obsessions with antiquity—the Renaissance with its admiration for Roman and Greek classicism, the Gothic movements invocations of medievalism—never has there been a society so obsessed with the cultural artifacts of its own immediate past. Retromania is the first book to examine the retro industry and ask the question: Is this retromania a death knell for any originality and distinctiveness of our own?
"Kids today are too besotted with every old thing and a stagnant culture is the result, argues this lively though muddled manifesto. Rock critic Reynolds (Rip It Up and Start Again) visits retro impulses in fashion, architecture, movies, and painting, but focuses on what he claims are the formaldehyde-soaked horrors of retro rock music: tours by geriatric boomer bands; wistful VH1 retrospectives; the musty curatorial obsessions of rock museums and hipster connoisseurs; new bands whose music merely cuts-and-pastes hoary influences; the all-preserving Internet, where adolescents graze in every musical era without developing their own generation-specific sound. There's self-contradiction here, and shallow jadedness musically, '2010 didn't feel that different from 2009, or even 2004' and a strange pique at teens who distinguish aesthetics from novelty ('The attachment on the part of young people to genres that have been around for decades mystifies me'). The author's brief for a self-consciously modernist pop music of 'constant change and endless innovation' itself betrays a retro hankering for 1960s-style rock revolutionism. But Reynolds's mix of canny erudition, critical theory, stylish prose, and vibrant evocations of bands both famous and unheard-of, nails the appeal of retro almost despite himself; as he deplores musical nostalgia, he reminds us why it mesmerizes us. (July)" Publishers Weekly Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
“If I had to choose just one commentator to guide me through the last quarter-century of popular (and not so popular) music, it would have to be—on the basis of knowledge, range of reference, soundness of judgment, and fluency of style—Simon Reynolds.” —GEOFF DYER, author of Jeff in Venice, Death in Varanasi
“Amazing.” —Bruce Sterling, Wired.com
“Looking back over the last 25 years youd be hard pressed to name a music journalist more adept at tracking and defining the zeitgeist.” —Dave Haslam, The Guardian
“Simon Reynolds, one of our most thoughtful music writers, poses a stark question for anyone who cares about the future of pop . . . A devastating critique of the way music is now consumed.” —Patrick Sawer, The Daily Telegraph
“Bracingly sharp. As a work of contemporary historiography, a thick description of the transformations in our relationship to time—as well as to place—Retromania deserves to be very widely read.” —Sukhdev Sandhu, The Observer (London)
“A provocative and original inquiry into the past and future of popular music.” —Booklist (starred review)
“[A] mix of canny erudition, critical theory, stylish prose, and vibrant evocations.” —Publishers Weekly
“Important—and alarming—reading for pop-music aficionados.” —Kirkus Reviews
“A hugely interesting and useful debate starter.” —NME
“If anyone can make sense of pop musics steady mutation from what George Melly noted as its ‘worship of the present, to its current status as a living heritage industry where past, present and what the author calls a nostalgia for a lost future coexist, then youd have to trust Reynolds. Hes a top-table critic whose keen ear is matched by a sharp eye for cultural context . . . An erudite study of pops eternal lock groove.” —Mark Paytress, Mojo
“The worlds finest living music writer.” —Christopher Mosley, D magazine
“Retromania is a terrific book. Reynolds brings profound knowledge and oceanic depth and width to his argument, tracing his theme from trad jazz through the 70s rock and roll boom to the hipsterism of today, via the hyper-connectedness and infinite jukebox of the web. Unlike many of the pop writers who inspired him as a youth, he deploys his high intelligence and vast range of reference lucidly, to argue and illuminate, not dazzle or alienate.” —Steve Yates, The Word
“Compulsively readable.” —FACT magazine
“If I had to choose just one commentator to guide me through the last quarter-century of popular (and not so popular) music, it would have to be—on the basis of depth of knowledge, range of reference, soundness of judgment, and fluency of style—Simon Reynolds.” —Geoff Dyer, author of Jeff in Venice, Death in Varanasi
“If pop music is all about right now, what happens when the past refuses to go quietly? The ever-brilliant Simon Reynolds investigates the cult of retro, the temptations of nostalgia, and the future of music culture—all with a detectives cold eye and a fans hot heart.” —Rob Sheffield, author of Love Is a Mixtape
“One of my favorite music writers wrestles one of my favorite musical paradoxes: Whats up with the fetish for the Old in pops Land of the Eternal New? Unpacking how YouTube makes history more lateral than linear, pondering the remarkable endurance of Englands Northern Soul scene, or wondering if record collecting is indeed a distinctly masculine sickness, Reynoldss deep inquiries lead to a bigger question: Does obsessive engagement with the past make it harder to invent the future?” —Will Hermes, author of Love Goes to Buildings on Fire
“The crowning achievement of Retromania is that it in no way contributes to the cultural malaise it critiques. You may struggle with the suspicion that youve seen it all before and heard it all before—but youve never read anything that approaches the idea of retro from as many entertaining and incisive angles. The present may be collapsing into the past, but this is a book for the ages.” —Greg Milner, author of Perfecting Sound Forever
"'Who wants yesterday's papers?' sang Mick Jagger in 1967. 'Who wants yesterday's girl?' The answer, in the Swinging 60s, was obvious: 'Nobody in the world' That was then. Now we seem to want nothing more than to read yesterday's papers and carry on with yesterday's girl. Popular culture has become obsessed with the past -- with recycling it, rehashing it, replaying it. Though we live in a fast-forward age, we cannot take our finger off the rewind button." Nicholas Carr, The New Republic
(Read the entire New Republic review
About the Author
Simon Reynolds is a music critic whose writing has appeared in The New York Times, The Village Voice, Spin, Rolling Stone, and Artforum. He is the author of five previous books, including Rip It Up and Start Again.