Synopses & Reviews
With contemporary design being redefined by architects and urbanists who are recovering the historic language associated with traditional architecture and the city, how might preservation change its focus or update its mission? Steven W. Semes, winner of the 2010 Clem Labine Award, makes a persuasive case that context matters and that new buildings and additions to old buildings should be harmonious with their neighbors. was also named one of 's most noteworthy books of 2010 and one of "10 Most Compelling Historic Preservation Reads."
Review
"Semes mounts the most thorough attack I've ever read on the anti-tradition stance of many architectural and historic preservation professionals. The need for this book is intense....Everyone, including general readers, will find this book's many illustrations, with their pithy captions, illuminating. This book should help the confused 21st century to create and maintain places of lasting value." New Urban News
Review
[P]resents a persuasive case against the preservation ethic of oppositional styling; that is, the argument that new additions to historic buildings must be deliberately un-period so as not to be confused with the existing, 'authentic" section of the building. Semes illuminates the error of this way of thinking, and walks us through a history of architecture and preservation in the process.[A] stirring and passionate call to get historic preservation right by respecting the past without making it sacrosanct.[A] clear and comprehensive argument'.adds significantly to the discussion, one that should continue as an important topic within the historic preservation, urban planning, and architecture professions.[T]houghtful and thought-provoking'.a must-read for those who care for and care about our architectural heritage.The Decade’s Most Important Book on Urban Architecture….With the publication of this volume, Steven Semes has vaulted into the first rank of contemporary architectural critics and preservation theorists…. should be must reading for all preservationists and people serving on landmark commissions and design review boards. -- Clem Labine
Review
Semes has written an indictment so complete and so damning, and yet expressed with such grace and diplomacy, that all thoughtful preservationists and even some modern architects will finally understand, if not admit, the error of their ways….so clear, so strong and so compelling that professionals in the field may be judges by how they react to it. -- David Brussat
Review
[S]peaks in common-sense terms, it is didactic and approachable, and the laymen who are in the trenches…will find powerful ammunition in it.[B]eautifully illustrated….comprehensive….[N]eeds to be understood and followed by professional architects and preservationists; most of the lay public, which likes old buildings and neighborhoods, is already on Semes’ side. -- Rob Hardy
Review
I do not think I've ever come away from a book more impressed. Its erudition and its force in putting across a complex contrarian argument are incomparable. This book should be required reading for modern architects, who will start to whistle past the graveyard, and preservationists, who will see the error of their ways and, if they are honest, will admit it.... All I can say is read the review - or better yet, go out right now and get the book itself. It is my new bible. -- David Brussat
Review
"Will we ever agree on the future of the past? Probably not. However, with this compelling and accessible study, Steven W. Semes has taken a major step forward towards that illusory goal. . . . [A] thought provoking book." APT Bulletin: Journal of Preservation Technology
Review
"The Decade's Most Important Book on Urban Architecture....With the publication of this volume, Steven Semes has vaulted into the first rank of contemporary architectural critics and preservation theorists.... should be must reading for all preservationists and people serving on landmark commissions and design review boards." Traditional Building
Synopsis
A comprehensive and eloquent argument for "new traditional" architecture that preserves the style and character of historic buildings.
About the Author
Steven W. Semes is Associate Professor at the University of Notre Dame School of Architecture and Academic Director of its Rome Studies Program. A practicing architect for over thirty years, he has designed a wide variety of projects for preservation and new construction throughout the United States. He is also the author of The Architecture of the Classical Interior (Norton) and a contributor to The Elements of Classical Architecture (Norton). His essays and reviews have appeared in the National Trust Forum Journal, Traditional Building, Period Homes, and American Arts Quarterly. He is a Fellow Emeritus of the Institute of Classical Architecture & Classical America.