Synopses & Reviews
Well-Mannered Medicine explores the moral discourses on the practice of medicine in the foundational texts of Ayurveda. The classical ayurvedic treatises were composed in Sanskrit between the first and the seventh centuries CE, and later works, dating into the sixteenth century CE, are still considered strongly authoritative. As Wujastyk shows, these works testify to an elaborate system of medical ethics and etiquette. Physicians looked to the ayurvedic treatises for a guide to professional conduct. Ayurvedic discourses on good medical practice depict the physician as highly-educated, skilled, moral, and well-mannered. The rules of conduct positioned physicians within mainstream society and characterized medical practice as a trustworthy and socially acceptable profession. At the same time, professional success was largely based on a particular physician's ability to cure his patients. This resulted in tension, as some treatments and medications were considered socially or religiously unacceptable. Doctors needed to treat their patients successfully while ostensibly following the rules of acceptable behavior.
Wujastyk offers insight into the many unorthodox methods of avoiding conflict while ensuring patient compliance shown in the ayurvedic treatises, giving a disarmingly candid perspective on the realities of medical practice and its crucial role in a profoundly well-mannered society.
Review
"Dagmar Wujastyk's thorough study of medical ethics in classical Ayurvedic texts adds substantially to our knowledge of Ayurveda as a medical system. Ethics here includes the moral attributes required of a physician, personal presentation, medical education, the doctor-patient relationship, medical deception, and much more. In this first rate study, Wujastyk avoids the danger of evaluating Ayurveda from the standpoint of Western medicine. This is required reading for everyone with an interest in Indian medicine or cross-cultural medical history."--Frederick M. Smith, Professor of Sanskrit and Classical Indian Religions, University of Iowa
About the Author
Dagmar Wujastyk is a postdoctoral research fellow at Zurich University in Switzerland and co-editor of
Modern and Global Ayurveda - Pluralism and Paradigms. She has taught Sanskrit at the University of Bonn and Cambridge University.
Table of Contents
Abbreviations
Acknowledgements
Introduction
1 The pillars of treatment
2 On becoming a physician
3 On continued learning and interaction with peers
4 To care or not to care
5 The rewards of medical practice
6 Veracity in the doctor-patient relationship
7 Ethical elisions
8 Concluding reflections
Appendices
A Sanskrit text passages: The pillars of treatment
B Sanskrit text passages: On becoming a physician
C Sanskrit text passages: On continued learning and interaction with peers
D Sanskrit text passages: To care or not to care
E Sanskrit text passages: The rewards of medical practice
F Sanskrit text passages: Veracity in the doctor-patient relationship
Notes
Bibliography