Synopses & Reviews
Iandrsquo;m Neither Here nor There explores how immigration influences the construction of family, identity, and community among Mexican Americans and migrants from Mexico. Based on long-term ethnographic research, Patricia Zavella describes how poor and working-class Mexican Americans and migrants to Californiaandrsquo;s central coast struggle for agency amid the regionandrsquo;s deteriorating economic conditions and the rise of racial nativism in the United States. Zavella also examines tensions within the Mexican diaspora based on differences in legal status, generation, gender, sexuality, and language. She proposes andldquo;peripheral visionandrdquo; to describe the sense of displacement and instability felt by Mexican Americans and Mexicans who migrate to the United States as well as by their family members in Mexico.
Drawing on close interactions with Mexicans on both sides of the border, Zavella examines migrant journeys to and within the United States, gendered racialization, and exploitation at workplaces, and the challenges that migrants face in forming and maintaining families. As she demonstrates, the desires of migrants to express their identities publicly and to establish a sense of cultural memory are realized partly through Latin American and Chicano protest music, and Mexican and indigenous folks songs played by musicians and cultural activists.
Review
andldquo;Among the most original and important contributions of Iandrsquo;m Neither Here nor There are: its focus on one California region, which helps us to see that migrants do not come to an undifferentiated andlsquo;United States,andrsquo; but rather to specific locations with distinct regional economic and social dynamics; its sensitivity to gender and sexuality as key sites where social change gets registered in the lives of individuals; and its brilliant discussions of the popular music of Los Tigres del Norte, Quetzal, and Lila Downs as repositories of collective memory, sites of moral instruction, and mechanisms for calling old and new communities into being through performance. Patricia Zavella also makes clear the causes and consequences of residential density and overcrowding in immigrant communities, surely one of the most important but least understood features of contemporary immigrant life. Iandrsquo;m Neither Here nor There is an outstanding work that will be welcomed by specialists as well as general readers. It makes unique and valuable contributions to scholarship and civic life and presents an exemplary model of sophisticated and socially engaged research.andrdquo;andmdash;George Lipsitz, author of How Racism Takes Place
Review
andldquo;Patricia Zavellaandrsquo;s timely Iandrsquo;m Neither Here Nor Thereand#160;serves as an example of a broadly accessible approach to the study of the working poor. Drawing from ethnographic fieldwork in central California, Zavella analyses the daily challenges encountered by Santa Cruz Countyandrsquo;s Mexican migrantsand#160;and Mexican Americans, with an eye towards issues of family, gender, sexuality and legal status.andrdquo;
Review
“The breadth of Patricia Zavella’s
I’m Neither Here Nor There: Mexicans’Quotidian Struggles with Migration and Poverty is staggering.... It is undeniable that Zavella is a rigorous, experienced, and sophisticated
ethnographer who has made a monumental and original contribution
with I’m Neither Here Nor There.... [It] amplifies the words of marginalized people who ‘cannot shout’ (p. xii) yet justifiably “feel entitled to dignity in exchange for their labor” (p. xi).” - Chad Broughton, American Journal of Sociology
Review
andldquo;Zavellaandrsquo;s book is an important read for scholars of migration, transnationalism, citizenship, and political economy, as well as those whose work engages gender, sexuality and race. While set in the US, Zavellaandrsquo;s conceptual frame and analysis can be a useful tool for Canadian scholars, particularly those working in the areas of migrant integration, immigration status and radicalized poverty.andrdquo;
Review
andldquo;Iandrsquo;m Neither Here nor There is a powerful, highly original ethnography about the complexities of the Mexican migrant and Mexican American population in the United States. By drawing primarily on work by scholars of color about people of color, Patricia Zavella decenters staid ways of understanding immigration, such as assimilation and the underclass models. Her use of the concepts of peripheral vision, double vision, and border thinking are particularly effective, as is her political-economic analysis of capitalism and neoliberalism in Santa Cruz County, California, and the poverty and challenges that they create for the areaandrsquo;s working poor.andrdquo;andmdash;Lynn Stephen, author of Transborder Lives: Indigenous Oaxacans in Mexico, California, and Oregon
Review
andldquo;This is the way ethnography should be written: with stories that entice, analysis that dazzles, and just the right mix of humor, music, and in-your-face dignidad. Border and migration studies will never be the same after Patricia Zavellaandrsquo;s impassioned new book, Iandrsquo;m Neither Here nor There.andrdquo;andmdash;Matthew Gutmann, Brown University
Review
andldquo;Iandrsquo;m Neither Here nor There is a compelling examination of structures of difference, of becoming and belonging, and of forms of border thinking that map spatio-conceptual cosmos and the human integuments that hold them together through andlsquo;transcommunal subjectivity.andrsquo;... If only every book were as intellectually productive, ethically inspiring, and politically compelling.andrdquo;
Review
andldquo;With detail and sensitivity, Zavella illustrates how changing gender roles and generational expectations are affecting and transforming Mexican diaspora communities as migrants create inventive strategies for survivalandhellip;. Theoretically sophisticated yet written in an accessible style, this book is especially apropos for graduate courses dealing with themes of globalization, immigration, transnationalism, and border life and is also recommended for general readers interested in these themes.andrdquo;
Review
“The breadth of Patricia Zavella’s I’m Neither Here Nor There is staggering.... It is undeniable that Zavella is a rigorous, experienced, and sophisticated ethnographer who has made a monumental and original contribution with I’m Neither Here Nor There.... [It] amplifies the words of marginalized people who 'cannot shout' (p. xii) yet justifiably 'eel entitled to dignity in exchange for their labor'(p. xi).” Angela S. Garc�a - Ethnic and Racial Studies
Review
andldquo;The breadth of Patricia Zavellaandrsquo;s Iandrsquo;m Neither Here Nor Thereand#160;is staggering.... It is undeniable that Zavella is a rigorous, experienced, and sophisticatedand#160;ethnographer who has made a monumental and original contributionand#160;with Iandrsquo;m Neither Here Nor There.... [It] amplifies the words of marginalized people who and#39;cannot shoutand#39; (p. xii) yet justifiably and#39;eel entitled to dignity in exchange for their laborand#39;(p. xi).andrdquo;
Synopsis
Studies poor and working-class Mexicans in the USA, showing how migration influences the creation of identity, family, and community and how it affects even those who don't themselves actually migrate.
About the Author
Patricia Zavella is Professor of Latin American and Latino Studies at the University of California, Santa Cruz. She is the author of Womenandrsquo;s Work and Chicano Families: Cannery Workers of the Santa Clara Valley and a co-author of Sunbelt Working Mothers: Reconciling Family and Factory. Zavella is a co-editor of Chicana Feminisms: A Critical Reader, Telling to Live: Latina Feminist Testimonios, and Women and Migration in the U.S.-Mexico Borderlands: A Reader all also published by Duke University Press.