Synopses & Reviews
During the eighteenth century, some of the most popular British poetry showed a responsiveness to animals that anticipated the later language of animal rights. Such poems were widely cited in later years by legislators advocating animal welfare laws like Martinand#8217;s Act of 1822, which provided protections for livestock. In
The Animal Claim, Tobias Menely links this poetics of sensibility with Enlightenment political philosophy, the rise of the humanitarian public, and the fate of sentimentality, as well as longstanding theoretical questions about voice as a medium of communication. and#160;and#160;and#160;
and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;
In the Restoration and eighteenth century, philosophers emphasized the role of sympathy in collective life and began regarding the passionate expression humans share with animals, rather than the spoken or written word, as the elemental medium of community. Menely shows how poetry came to represent this creaturely voice and, by virtue of this advocacy, facilitated the development of a viable discourse of animal rights in the emerging public sphere. Placing sensibility in dialogue with classical and early-modern antecedents as well as contemporary animal studies, The Animal Claim uncovers crucial connections between eighteenth-century poetry; theories of communication; and post-absolutist, rights-based politics. and#160;
Review
and#8220;Menelyand#8217;s passionately eloquent The Animal Claim accomplishes what many would consider the impossible feat of making eighteenth-century poetry a matter of pressing concern to a wide range of fields, extending beyond eighteenth-century studies and literary studies more generally to include political theory, philosophy, ecocriticism, and the growing field of animal studies. This book is one of the most convincing accounts of the enduring relevance of the eighteenth century to our own moment that I have ever read.and#8221;
Review
and#8220;More intensely and capaciously than any work I know, The Animal Claim perceives and explains the deep connections between the passionate voices of high poetry and the wordless eloquence of animals. Menelyand#8217;s searching readings of eighteenth-century philosophers and of Alexander Pope, James Thomson, Christopher Smart, and William Cowper will redefine significant questions within English literary studies. More broadly, his studyand#8217;s theoretical range and strength make it a new foundational work for ecological understandings of artistic achievement. This is a truly magisterial book.and#8221;
Review
andldquo;Readers will come away from this remarkable book reconsidering many of their ideas about the eighteenth century. Among its many accomplishments, The Animal Claim demonstrates the centrality of poetry not only to the periodandrsquo;s literature but also to the history of political advocacy. With its emphasis on sound and metaphor, its ability to convey affective pressures in excess of word and idea, poetry remediates the unrecognized creaturely voice and represents itandmdash;in both the linguistic and political senses of representationandmdash;in the public sphere. Menelyand#160;reminds us that criticism at its finest can be passionate work.andrdquo;
Synopsis
Today, we tend to react skeptically to claims about our access to the animal mind, the political importance of compassion, and the natural origins of community. However, such claims were widespread in the Restoration and eighteenth century, the long Age of Sensibility. Even so famous a skeptic as the Enlightenment philosopher David Hume wrote that and#147;animals undoubtedly feel, think, love, hate, will, and even reason.and#8221; In The Animal Claim, Tobias Menely shows that for Hume and other thinkers of his time, the acknowledgment of creaturely voice was crucial to their theories of community. Looking primarily to the long eighteenth century in Britain, Menely argues that sympathyand#151;including sympathy with animalsand#151;came to be regarded as a foundational resource of social relation, and that it fell to poets, in particular, to represent creaturely voice in the public sphere. Menely connects this development to new ideas of political community in Britain and the emergence of a viable discourse of animal rights in the age of legislative reform. The result is an original contribution to both animal studies and eighteenth-century scholarship.
About the Author
Tobias Menely is assistant professor of English at the University of California, Davis.
Table of Contents
Introduction
Chapter 1. The Significant Voice: Address and the Animal Sign
Chapter 2. Creaturely Origins: Enlightenment Naturalism and the Animal Voice
Chapter 3. The Addressive Animal: The Augustans and andldquo;Tyrant Customandrdquo;and#160;and#160;
Chapter 4. Creaturely Advocacy: Poetic Vocation in the Age of Sensibilityand#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;
Chapter 5. Sensibilities into Statutes: Animal Rights and the Afterlife of Sensibility
Afterword: The Law and the Factoryand#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;and#160;
Acknowledgments
Notes
Index