The Last of Her Kind
by Sigrid Nunez
A Rebel in Search of Her Cause
A review by Yvonne Zipp
The college roommate questionnaire is one of the more loaded pieces of paper that
land in incoming freshmen's mailboxes. Not as nausea-inducing as the financial-aid
package, but sobering, nonetheless.
Mine asked, among other things, whether I was looking for a new best friend, or
hoped to "peacefully coexist" with my roomies. Well, who wouldn't want
a best friend? Can't have too many, right?
Sadly, peaceful coexistence sounded pretty good by mid-October, when my roommates
(who had grabbed the room's two closets) suggested that I try hanging my things
from the ceiling to ease the crowded conditions.
But no one at my college expected their questionnaire to do more than spare
them a smoker (and two of my friends drew the short straw on that one, as well).
Certainly, none of us would have had the temerity to request a "girl from
a world as different as possible from her own," as does Dooley Ann Drayton.
Or, as her roommate, Georgette George, puts it in Sigrid Nunez's excellent fifth
novel The Last of Her Kind, "She did not want a roommate who had
been raised, as she had been ... to believe you could make this kind of special
request and expect it would be granted."
Ann (as she demands to be called) was hoping to be paired with an African-American
girl. But at Barnard College in 1968, that was almost as unheard of as co-ed
Ann, who loathes her parents and their money, and frequently wishes she were
black, settles for George, who was raised in poverty by an abusive single mom
and isn't sure she's flattered by Ann's description.
Over the next decade, Ann is swept up in the radical counterculture movement,
while George seeks stability and approval at a women's fashion magazine, when
she's not looking for her younger sister, who ran away while George was at Barnard.
Ann, whose idealism is of the uncompromising and infuriating variety, finally
picks a fight with George that ends their friendship.
Then, in 1976, Ann is arrested for shooting a policeman who was threatening
her African-American lover.
Reading about her case in the newspapers, George finds herself drawn again
to her former friend, feeling that there must be more to the story than the
"Socialite Cop-Killer" headlines. She tries to reconnect with Ann,
and spends the next decades searching for every crumb of information about her
that she can garner.
The novel's title comes from the judge who sentences Ann to 25 years to life,
saying, "May you serve as an example to others, and may you be the last
of your kind."
In an interview, Ann's lawyer, an African-American, comments, "Everyone
can find a reason to hate Ann. To rich, conservative people she's an ingrate,
a traitor to her class.... Poor people and minorities, they're all free to despise
Ann for being nothing but a spoiled, rich white brat..... Most people aren't
willing to believe anyone isn't just as selfish and self-serving as everyone
else. She's one of the last of her kind, all right, but not in the way the judge
had in mind."
Nunez follows the women's lives over about 30 years -- George becomes a mother
to two children and takes care of her mentally ill sister; Ann continues her
activism in prison, where she is serving a life sentence, still angering as
many people as she helps.
Nunez patterns Ann after writer Simone Weil, who, according to her doctors,
committed suicide by starvation. (Weil refused to eat more than French citizens
under Nazi occupation.)
George calls her "selfless to the point of selfishness" and remarks,
"If no one was willing to martyr her, she could martyr herself."
Both George and Ann get generous, vivid characterizations, and Nunez is as
unstinting in her detailed rendering of the idealistic '60s and their dark aftermath
as she is of the worsening conditions in America's prisons.
George's runaway sister, Solange, does her best to fill in the gaps with her
cross-country wanderings with hippies and junkies, and her use of every drug
from marijuana to heroin. (George, for that matter, is also happy to sample
the wares of the era.)
What keeps the novel from being just a history lesson, though, is Nunez's exploration
of the many ways women communicate, and how it's possible to think of a friend
every day, and yet not talk to her for years.
Yvonne Zipp is a freelance writer in Kalamazoo, Mich.
News, Culture, and 21 FREE issues
The Christian Science
Monitor offers independent, thoughtful journalism, together with stimulating cultural criticism. This award-winning newspaper is hard to find at
newsstands. But you can get the entire paper weekdays in a convenient PDF, with a hyperlinked table of contents. The Monitor Treeless Edition costs only $8 a month, half the cost of a print subscription, and now you can try it free for one month.
Find out more about this special offer.