A Map of Glass
by Jane Urquhart
A review by Yvonne Zipp
Islands and beaches play prominent roles in Jane Urquhart's novels, but readers
won't find any bikinis or blooming hibiscuses. The Canadian writer isn't interested
in tropical paradises. Her shores are northern - places where the extreme conditions
serve as a stark backdrop to unfolding epics.
Her sixth novel, A Map of Glass, is no exception. It opens during a
snowstorm on an abandoned island, where a septuagenarian man wanders to his
death. His name was Andrew Woodman, and he was a "historical geographer"
and scion of the family that once prospered on Timber Island. His body is found
by Jerome, a young conceptual artist -- there's usually at least one artist
in Urquhart's novels -- who'd come to the island to chronicle changes made by
A year later, Andrew's longtime lover, Sylvia, shows up at Jerome's door with
Andrew's journals. "The day that you found Andrew you became ... the end
of the story," Sylvia explains to Jerome, who would really prefer not to
think about his grim discovery. "You were, in a way, the last thing he
Sylvia, who hates change, has lived a prisoner to a mysterious "condition,"
which is never named. She can catalog every item in her family home, and has
more intense relationships with china horses than her husband, a well-meaning
doctor who agreed to take her off her weary parents' hands. Andrew and a blind
friend, for whom Sylvia makes tactile maps, are the only ones who have ever
treated her like a whole person.
The first third of the novel is essentially an overly long setup to get down
to the business of reading Andrew's journals. While Sylvia and Jerome, who (of
course) is battling his own childhood demons, are likable, this early section
is marred by self-conscious dialogue and too many neat parallels. Jerome "is
drawn to abandoned scraps," like peeling paint and rust; Sylvia fixates
on paint peeling in her hotel room. Sylvia remarks that Jerome's girlfriend's
name, Mira, sounds like "mirror." Uh, yeah. It also means "look"
in Spanish, but can we get on with it?
This slow windup is a real shame, because readers who give up too soon will
miss out on a truly memorable family: the Woodmans, 19th-century artists and
businessmen whose greed scars the landscape. As soon as Jerome opens Andrew's
journals, the novel kicks into high gear. Fans of The
Underpainter, perhaps Urquhart's best novel, know that she excels at making
100 years ago feel as vibrant as yesterday. (In fact, a problem with Glass
is that the present feels less urgent than the past.)
The patriarch is Joseph Woodman, a ferocious shipbuilder who left England in
a fury after his plan to drain Ireland's bogs was shelved. But the story really
belongs to his two children: lame, intelligent Annabelle, who paints only shipwrecks;
and Branwell, a fresco artist who wants nothing to do with the family business.
Branwell's wife, Marie, an orphan with a flair for French cookery, and their
son, "Badger," complete the family circle. Just for good measure,
Urquhart throws in a rival shipbuilder and a Slovakian groom who moonlights
as a bear-training, fortune-telling flamenco dancer.
In the present day, all that's left of the Woodmans are two physical landmarks:
Timber Island and a hotel buried under the sand -- what Andrew calls "a
biography of stones." The story of their rise and fall unfolds like an
epic, but at the length of a novella. Despite the economy of pages, Urquhart
still has room for lovely touches, like the buried hotel and Annabelle's "splinter
book," a scrapbook made of used matches and fragments of wood. And for
images of decline, it's hard to beat an elderly Joseph, wandering about Timber
Island like The Onceler from The
Lorax, wondering why there are no more trees.
The novel's title comes from a work by minimalist artist Robert Smithson, in
which he heaped pieces of broken glass at a site where the sun would catch them,
creating Map of Broken Glass. Smithson's interest in maps and entropy
is reflected throughout the novel: Both Andrew and Jerome chronicle changes
in the natural landscape over time, and Joseph Woodman and Sylvia both turn
maps into art. The frailty of material success, and the powerful changes the
lust for money can wreak on the land are also woven throughout.
Urquhart also spares a fond thought for vanished occupations. Jerome muses
wistfully on life as a "fence-minder," and, when she comes across
models for ship's figureheads, even practical Annabelle succumbs to a moment
of nostalgia. "It is wonderful, when you think about it, that there were
men in Quebec who devoted their lives almost entirely to the carving of mermaids."
It does take quite a bit of time for A Map of Glass to get its bearings,
but readers who persevere are likely to feel themselves amply rewarded.
Yvonne Zipp is a freelance writer in Kalamazoo, Mich.
News, Culture, and 21 FREE issues
The Christian Science
Monitor offers independent, thoughtful journalism, together with stimulating cultural criticism. This award-winning newspaper is hard to find at
newsstands. But you can get the entire paper weekdays in a convenient PDF, with a hyperlinked table of contents. The Monitor Treeless Edition costs only $8 a month, half the cost of a print subscription, and now you can try it free for one month.
Find out more about this special offer.