Inside and Other Short Fiction: Japanese Women by Japanese Women
by Cathy Layne
New Views of Japanese Women
A review by Terry Hong
Putting Ruth Ozeki's name on a book's cover is an unconditional guarantee that
I will buy that book. And I'm not alone: Ozeki's novels My
Year of Meats and All
Over Creation have been international successes.
The cachet associated
with Ozeki's name has apparently not gone unnoticed in the publishing world. On
the cover of Inside and Other Short Fiction: Japanese Women by Japanese Women,
released this month by Kodansha, only Ozeki's name appears -- "with a foreword
by Ruth Ozeki" -- and one must open the book to see that this is a collection
of eight stories compiled by Cathy Layne (a transplanted Liverpudlian Tokyo-ite
editor who also translated three of the stories), by eight different authors and
four additional translators.
In spite of the fact that the eight women
represented in this anthology are award-winning writers in Japan, they are virtually
unknown to Western audiences, with the possible exception of Amy Yamada, whose
are available in English. But the very fact that they are not widely read abroad
is exactly what makes this collection worth noting. As Ozeki writes in the foreword,
these stories "paint a picture of contemporary Japanese women's lives that
is fresh, new, and possibly even shocking to readers in the West."
stereotypes of Asian women have long abounded. Growing up half-Japanese in New
England, Ozeki remembers a veteran who called her "Suzy" when she was
small. Only years later did she recognize the reference to the Hong Kong prostitute
in the 1960 film The World of Suzie Wong. Ozeki lists other pervasive perceptions
of Japanese women, from the submissive Madame Butterfly to the alluring geisha
girl to the docile office lady and self-sacrificing salaryman's wife.
Ozeki notes, "In recent years the popular imagination has begun to depict
women with a new kind of agency and autonomy." She remains cautious of the
changing images of today's Japanese woman - "still so often derived from
the male imagination and drawn by his hand," she astutely observes - and
inserts a contemporary sociological context: "The traditional family, whose
ballast was the stay-at-home wife and mother, is breaking down. Marriage and birth
rates are declining, while the divorce rate is escalating. Career opportunities
for women, too, are on the rise, and many women opt to marry later, or not at
all. As a result of these and other social factors, Japanese women today have
more economic and sexual freedom than ever before."
Each of the protagonists
in this collection -- from teenagers to single women to middle-age wives -- is
searching, sometimes fruitlessly, for love, companionship, understanding. These
are stories about the universal desires that color all human relationships.
by Tamaki Daido introduces a self-absorbed girl who babbles on about her shallow
relationships as she casually contemplates her sexuality. In contrast, the teenaged
girl in the eponymous "Inside" by Rio Shimamoto is mature beyond her
years, caught between a mother struggling with illness, an indifferent father,
and the end of her parents' troubled marriage.
There is one particularly
disturbing piece in the collection. (It has a one-word title that hints at the
story's crudeness.) It's a sexually explicit tale by Yuzuki Muroi about a young
Tokyo prostitute on the eve of her 20th birthday, who copes with the degrading
circumstances of her life by believing in the promises of the abusive men she
In the ironic "My Son's Lips" by Shungiku Uchida, a hassled
working mother reluctantly finds herself at a taxi driver's home, giving his wife
some domestic lessons. In Chiya Fujino's "Her Room," a divorced woman
finds it impossible to say no to a tenacious acquaintance of her cousin's who
is inexplicably determined to establish a friendship.
by Amy Yamada is an allegory of sorts in which the parts of a desperate woman's
splintered psyche -- Desire, Obsession, Passion, Pride and so on -- bond together
in fury to confront the object of her unrequited love. In "The Unfertilized
Egg" by Junko Hasegawa, a single woman facing a dead-end affair with her
married boss, sinks into bizarre dreams as she nears her 36th birthday, which
she sees as her last chance to have a "B-[blood] type girl in the Year of
the Horse" and carry on a three-generation family legacy.
story, "The Shadow of the Orchid" by Nobuko Takagi, features the collection's
oldest woman, who has devotedly served her doctor-husband and their successful
doctor-son. She now faces life alone, troubled by the specter of a young woman
who died in her husband's care.
The quality of these stories is uneven,
varying widely from piece to piece. But what some may lack in literary merit is
made up for by what they offer collectively: a still-rare glimpse into the lives
of Japanese women.
As contemporary harbingers of a writing tradition that
began a thousand years ago with Lady Murasaki Shikibu's "The Tale of Genji,"
these writers capture small and large moments of the everyday. Thankfully, you'll
find no Hollywood geishas here ... just women living -- and surviving -- the challenges
of their daily lives.
Terry Hong is media arts
consultant at the Smithsonian Asian Pacific American Program.
News, Culture, and 21 FREE issues
The Christian Science
Monitor offers independent, thoughtful journalism, together with stimulating cultural criticism. This award-winning newspaper is hard to find at
newsstands. But you can get the entire paper weekdays in a convenient PDF, with a hyperlinked table of contents. The Monitor Treeless Edition costs only $8 a month, half the cost of a print subscription, and now you can try it free for one month.
Find out more about this special offer.