Synopses & Reviews
In the second volume of The Story About the Story, editor J. C. Hallman continues to argue for an alternative to the staid five-paragraph-essay writing that has inoculated so many against the effects of good books. Writers have long approached writing about reading from an intensely personal perspective, incorporating their pasts and their passions into their process of interpretation. Never before collected in a single volume, the many essays Hallman has compiled build on the idea of a "creative criticism," and offers new possibilities for how to write about reading. The Story About the Story Vol. II documents not only an identifiable trend in writing about books that can and should be emulated, it also offers lessons from a remarkable range of celebrated authors that amount to an invaluable course on both how to write and how to read well. Whether they discuss a staple of the canon (Thomas Mann on Leo Tolstoy), the merits of a contemporary (Vivian Gornick on Grace Paley), a pillar of genre-writing (Jane Tompkins on Louis L'Amour), or, arguably, the funniest man on the planet (David Shields on Bill Murray), these essays are by turns poignant, smart, suggestive, intellectual, humorous, sassy, scathing, laudatory, wistful, and hopeful--and above all deeply engaged in a process of careful reading. The essays in The Story About the Story Vol. II chart a trajectory that digs deep into the past and aims toward a future in which literature can play a new and more profound role in how we think, read, live, and write.
Review
Praise for the Story About The Story series"More than just a beautiful read . . . .The series is in its own way important to the world. Because if theres any justice out there, itll eventually find its way into those dull high-school curricula.
To counteract the joyless misreadings and picking of scabs that have become todays literary criticism, Hallman is collecting writing about books that is every bit as personal, humane and emotionally rich as the books themselves."
The Willamette Week
"The problem with this book: too many irresistible things.”
James Salter, author of A Sport and a Pastime
"All great criticism begins with love. After all, we read books not from obligation but for pleasure, for mental excitement, for what A.E. Housman called the tingle at the back of the neck. In The Story About the Story there are no merely literary essays: Instead J.C. Hallman has gathered love letters, exuberant appreciations, confessions of envy and admiration. In these pages some of our finest writers stand up and testify to the power of literature to shake and shape our very souls."
Michael Dirda, Pulitzer Prize-winning critic and author of Bound to Please
"An invaluable guide for any reader of literature, as well as for the practitioners themselves."
Daniel Halpern; editor of The Art of the Story
There is no better path to the heart of a great writers expression than keen intuition born of deep regard, and no one more likely to have both than a fellow writer. This collection of master reader-writers appraising their admirations is not in the least predictable. Turn the pages: surprise, surprise, surprise!”
Sven Birkerts, author of Reading Life: Books for the Ages and The Gutenberg Elegies: The Fate of Reading in an Electronic Age
A novel, yes. A film, yes. But when have you ever been sorry for a book of essays to end? I was with this book. Each of these essays investigates good writing by writing well about it. They are all formally elegant and smart, smart, smart. And a delight to read.”
Mary Jo Bang, author of Elegy
"If you love literature, don' borrow The Story About the Story, because you'll never give it back. Buy it."
Salon.com
Synopsis
The essays in The Story About the Story Vol. II chart a trajectory that digs deep into the past and aims toward a future in which literature can play a new and more profound role in how we think, read, live, and write.
About the Author
In addition to editing
The Story About the Story,
J.C. Hallman is the author of several books, including
The Chess Artist,
In Utopia,
Wm and H'ry, and
B and Me: A True Story of Literary Arousal.
The list of contributors includes:
1) Wendy Lesser on Cervantes
2) Philip Lopate on Stendhal
3) John Berryman on Anne Frank
4) David Shields on Bill Murray
5) Zadie Smith on Hurston F
6) Charles Baxter on Chekhov
7) Thomas Mann on Tolstoy
8) Jane Tompkins on LAmour
9) Joyce Carol Oates on Mary Shelley
10) Martin Amis on Larkin
11) Margaret Atwood on Wells
12) Michael Dirda on Sir Gawain and the Green Knight”
13) Walter Benjamin on Leskov
14) Nicholson Baker on Defoe
15) James Thurber on James
16) Elizabeth Hardwick on Melville
17) David Foster Wallace on Updike
18) Jacque Barzun on Abraham Lincoln
19) Vivian Gornick on Paley
20) H.L. Mencken on Dreiser
21) Susan Cheever on Alcott
22) Ralph Ellison on Crane
23) Joseph Conrad on Crane
24) Francisco Goldman on Bolano
25) Katherine Anne Porter on Cather
26) Harold Bloom on Hans Christian Andersen
Table of Contents
Ecstatically: How to Write About Reading J.C. Hallman
Criticism Henry James
1) The First Novel Wendy Lesser
2) Portrait Inside My Head Phillip Lopate
3) The Development of Anne Frank John Berryman
4) The Only Solution to the Soul is the Senses: A Mediation on Bil Murray and Myself David Shields
5) Their Eyes Were Watching God: What Does Soulful Mean? Zadie Smith Hurston
6) Sonyas Last Speech, or, Double-Voicing: An Essay in Sixteen Sections Charles Baxter
7) Thomas Mann on Leo Tolstoy Thomas Mann
8) The Last of the Breed: Homage to Louis LAmour Jane Tompkins
9) Frankensteins Fallen Angel Joyce Carol Oates
10) Philip Larkin 1922 1985 Martin Amis
11) Ten Ways of Looking at The Island of Doctor Moreau by H.G. Wells ¬ Margaret Atwood
12) Sir Gawain and the Green Knight Michael Dirda
13) The Storyteller: Reflections on the Works of Nikolai Leskov Walter Benjamin
14) Defoe, Truthteller Nicholson Baker
15) The Wings of Henry James James Thurber
16) Billy Budd Elizabeth Hardwick
17) Certainly the End of Something or Other, One Would Sort of Have to Think David Foster Wallace
18) Lincoln the Writer Jacque Barzun
19) Grace Paley Vivian Gornick
20) Theodore Dreiser H.L. Mencken
21) Little Women Susan Cheever
22) Stephen Crane and the Mainstream of American Fiction Ralph Ellison
23) Joseph Conrad on Stephen Crane Joseph Conrad
24) Brick Francisco Goldman
25) Reflections on Willa Cather Katherine Anne Porter
26) Trust the Tale, Not the Teller: Hans Christian Andersen Harold Bloom
Exclusive Essay
Read an exclusive essay by J. C. Hallman