Watchmen

What Our Readers Are Saying

Share your thoughts on this title!

Average customer rating 4.8 (9 comments)

---

`

Not the first graphic novel by any means, but one of the best that the genre has produced. Watchmen operates from the proposition that even superheroes, no matter how powerful they may be, still suffer all the frailties and limitations of human nature. While some have suggested that Watchmen is a deconstruction of the superhero concept, I prefer to think that it simply adds a welcome dimension of realism. Whether you've seen the movie, or you are just curious about graphic novels, this book is essential reading.

`

This is an amazing work of literature that shows the power of combining the visual with the written to make something beyond either form.

`

This was my first graphic novel, and while I’m not really into the genre, I think it is a very good example of the medium. If nothing else, Watchmen gets points for presenting some intelligent philosophical arguments as well as for quoting Blake. Kinda makes me want to read V for Vendetta now. We’ll see.

`

If you don't already know, the other reviews will fill you in on the Watchmen's story and it's significance to the comic medium. I'm here to tell you about this edition of the book, which is basically an oversized version of the long out of print Graphitti Designs hardcover version complete with all of that edition's exclusive extras (which is fantastic since that out of print volume goes for major bucks on Ebay when it does rarely surface). Until now, that Graphitti Designs edition was the one to own...This tops it due to it's oversized pages and superior quality printing. Want to see how this story was originally about about Captain Atom, Blue Beetle, and the Question (along with other Charlton characters) and how it changed to what it is? There is a very indepth look at the original proposal included here. Want to see early Gibbon's art? it's here. How about rarely seen teaser strips published long before the first issue? Again included. Alan Moore's script samples? You got it. Bottom line, I can't think of anything that could possibly be done or included that would make a superior edition to this.

`

This has to be my all time favorite graphic novel, this was in fact the first graphic novel that I have ever read and I must say it has kept me reading them for many many years. The drawings, the story-line, and the characters are all amazing, The best character in this book is by far Rorschach (ror shack) with his dark personality and crooked view on life. If you are thinking of getting into graphic novels or want to see the movie, this is a must buy.

`

The Watchmen is a graphic novel (comic book) written by Alan Moore and illustrated by Dave Gibbons. The Watchmen is a story with a non-linear plotline in which much of it consists of sporadic flashbacks. In the 1930’s throughout the 1980’s there were a group of masked vigilantes who could be considered superheroes who banded together to create various teams to stop crime. It is set in an alternate universe where there is a constant threat of nuclear war and tells the story of two generations of superheroes and a conspiracy to kill them. The main characters are the Comedian, Dr. Manhattan, the vigilante Rorschach, Nite-Owl, and Laurie Juspeczyk, and Adrian Veidt. In the 1980’s Edward Blake, who is revealed to be the Comedian, by Rorschach, is murdered. Since Rorschach is paranoid he is convinced that there is someone trying to kill all the retired masked heroes. He thinks it could either be the government, a villain, or someone unknown. All sorts of crazy things happen, and some of the heroes come out of retirement, and there are a lot of flashbacks for each superhero which reveals more about what is really happening and how it can all be related to corruption, insanity, and nuclear war. The ending of the story is one of the best I’ve read in a comic book or even written novel. The villain is not contemporary and is actually smart unlike most generic comic book villains which just flex their muscles and attempt to smash as many faces before they overdose on the roids or their muscles explode. Intellectually the villain actually knows what he is doing, and he knows people will die for his cause, but what makes his cause so much different than any other villains is that his ultimate goal is not world domination, but the prevention of nuclear war and the unification of all the nations. Although the way he wants to go about this is controversial, it also seems necessary, so it provides a moral dilemma to the heroes as to what they should do in order to prevent the mass killing or if the plan will actually end up bettering the world. This question is posed not just to the masked heroes, but to the reader as well. Is it ok to sacrifice thousands for millions? The only true hero with super powers in the novel, Dr. Manhattan offers a different perspective on everything. His melancholy attitude and slightly cynical view of the human race is a criticism of what the human race has become. Although he probably has the power to save the human race, he chooses not to because what he sees is a civilization which only seems capable of destruction and barbarism. Throughout the story the reader is subject to his analysis of the human race, which although can seem harsh at some times, are also quite true. What have we accomplished in our time on earth except for mass killings of each other and our own planet? Sure we have made advances in technology, modified the world to our own specifications, but was it really all worth it? In the process we have also depleted much of this world’s resources, destroyed the habitats of countless organisms, and warred constantly with each other. This is how Dr. Manhattan views our world, and it is why he doesn’t use his power to help us. Interestingly enough, he is also referred to as the walking H-bomb, so there could also be a correlation to how even though humans are capable of untold destruction, the humanity and compassion of Dr. Manhattan himself also suggests that we are capable of loving and caring as well. The Watchmen is a great critique on what people have done in the past and what we could become. Nuclear war is not a pretty thing to think about, but it could be quite possible in the future, and the Watchmen offers a stance on what things could be like were it to be in an alternate universe.

`

One of the things I loved about Watchmen was how human the super humans were. You get all the stuff you love about comics (errr...graphic novels), but with a gritty accessibility that you don't often find in this genre.

`

I really liked this book, it broke away from traditional pulpy comics, and presented a dark, intricate story filled with emotion, current events and action. I recommend it strongly.

`

One of the best graphic novels I have ever read. This book is incredibly thought provoking and dark. It is similar to the more popular "Sin City" in its violence content but a much different style and quite a bit loftier in the issues it presents.