|
Doug Korty
, January 02, 2024
(view all comments by Doug Korty)
This is Mr. Hing's 10th book about immigration. He believes we should get rid of ICE and essentially open our borders. He doesn't explicitly support open borders but that is the implication of his work. The book is mostly stories about the mistreatment of particular people with the implication that we should radically change the way we deal with everything we do about immigration. There is no real analysis or general argument, there is only what could be called an attempt to make readers more sympathetic to all immigrants based on the sad stories of particular immigrants. This is not logical and not good social science. Readers may be sympathetic but there is no reason to support the author's call for radical change in the system. That is not to say that the system does not need to change. Only that this author has not made a reasonable argument for any change. Not recommended. Better information and books on immigration here: mwir-immigration.blogspot.
|