Cart
|
|
my account
|
wish list
|
help
|
800-878-7323
Hello, |
Login
MENU
Browse
See All Subjects
New Arrivals
Bestsellers
Featured Preorders
Award Winners
Audio Books
Used
Staff Picks
Staff Picks
Picks of the Month
25 Best 21st Century Sci-Fi & Fantasy
25 Books to Read Before You Die
25 PNW Books to Read Before You Die
25 Women to Read Before You Die
50 Books for 50 Years
Gifts
Gift Cards & eGift Cards
Powell's Souvenirs
Journals and Notebooks
Games
Sell Books
Events
Find A Store
Don't Miss
Creatives on Creating Sale
Comfort Me With Novels Sale
Welcome to the Chapterverse Sale
Powell's Author Events
Oregon Battle of the Books
Audio Books
Get the Powell's newsletter
Visit Our Stores
Powell's Staff:
Five Book Friday: In Memoriam
(0 comment)
Every year, the booksellers at Powell’s submit their Top Fives: their five favorite books that were released in 2023. It’s a list that, when put together, shows just how varied and interesting the book tastes of Powell’s booksellers are. I highly recommend digging into the recommendations — we would never lead you astray — but today...
Read More
»
Brontez Purnell:
Powell’s Q&A: Brontez Purnell, author of ‘Ten Bridges I’ve Burnt’
(0 comment)
Rachael P.:
Starter Pack: Where to Begin with Ursula K. Le Guin
(0 comment)
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
Customer Comments
MAA has commented on (130) products
Betrayal at Little Gibraltar A German Fortress a Treacherous American General & the Battle to End World War I
by
William T Walker
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Another good read about a little-known piece of history. This time, an attempt to correct a mis-understanding of this event, and in particular the active efforts to suppress the story in order to protect the legacy of a famous American general, at the expense of the soldiers who actually fought the battle & ultimately prevailed, despite the ineptitude, and then cover-up.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
1955 Hit
by
Bryce Carlson and Vanesa R Del Rey
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Good graphics & story. Set in LA, my home town, so parts of it resonated with me (maybe more so than others ... )
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Secondhand Time The Last Of The Soviets An Oral History
by
Svetlana Alexievich
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Great insight into popular, and disparate, views of Russians and their experience in the Soviet Union. Told as individual perspectives in the interviewee's own words. As such, was a challenge to keep the threads: I had to remind myself that this was like listening to fragments of conversation in rooms full of people, sometimes one interrupting the others. Fascinating to hear how many Russians can look back fondly of Stalin's dictatorship - at least there was order (if not law ... ).
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Dead Mountain: The Untold True Story of the Dyatlov Pass Incident
by
Eichar, Donnie
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Well written story, of little known incident. Decent insight into the vagaries of Russian access, and paranoia around the apparat of the Soviet Union, especially nuclear weaponry.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Secret War Spies Ciphers & Guerrillas 1939 1945
by
Max Hastings
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Well researched & written by well regarded historian. Plenty of details on the efforts by all players in WWII to get an edge via espionage, codebreaking, partisans, fifth columns, and the like.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
All Too Human A Political Education
by
George Stephanopoulos
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Great 'tell-it-like-it-is' to get insight into how the political world actually works, not the widespread sugar-coated civics fantasies. Not quite the self-serving hagiographic 'memoirs' or 'autobiographies' now common among our politicians. Read this during the rise of Hillary Clinton, and was motivated to read more behind-the-scenes eye-witness accounts, such as one from a secret service agent. This is the best written. Chilling in its frankness, and frightening in its depiction of the Clintons, from someone who was a long-time supporter. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Shigeru Mizuki's Hitler
by
Shigeru Mizuki
MAA
, February 05, 2017
I love Mizuki's work, and this is no exception. One has to get used to the manga style, and some might object to the occasional farcical humor, but this is all par for the course in this oeuvre. Another view of one of the most controversial subjects in history, and for that reason alone, worth it. Recommended for those interested in history, and open to alternative views.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Olympic Dream The Story of Samia Yusuf Omar
by
Reinhard Kleist
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Good story & good account, with decent artwork. Does what a graphic novel should: tell a good story integrating text & art.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Submarines Leviathans of the Deep
by
T L Francis
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Good, comprehensive coverage of this subject from the begins centuries ago. Drawback is publication date (1997), which naturally ends the narrative. And some question about the quality of the historical facts ... but as long as one doesn't take this as gospel, the pictures & illustrates are worth it.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Jack Jackson's American History: Los Tejanos and Lost Cause
by
Jack Jackson
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Another brilliant piece from one of the greats. Well researched, and commentary notes the various controversies regarding the Texian/Texican/Tejanos break from Spain & Mexico. This work does justice to the controversies, while maintaining its own view. My people on my father's side come from Texas, so this resonated with me. Recommended for those interested in another view of the struggles with Mexico over land & heritage.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Normandy: A Graphic History of D-Day the Allied Invasion of Hitler's Fortress Europe
by
Wayne Vansant
MAA
, February 05, 2017
This is one in a series of historical graphic novels on war. Recommended, although I felt that a few of the details might be off - par for the course with summarized history, graphic novel or otherwise. Great art & reasonably thorough coverage of the event, with good details.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Rosalie Lightning: A Graphic Memoir
by
Tom Hart
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Wonderful, touching recounting of a child's death. As a father of a daughter, hit home for me.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Far Side Gallery 3
by
Gary Larson
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Still brilliant, although some of the referents may be a bit dated for newcomers. Recommend all of Larson's works - his pieces were often on people's frigs, desks, doors, etc., and for good reason.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Fifties Flashback The American Car
by
Dennis Adler
MAA
, February 05, 2017
GOOD, solid history of the cars of the '50s, with great photos of not only cars, but aircraft, etc. of the times, from which much of the styling comes.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Speed & Luxury The Great Cars
by
Dennis Adler
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Great photos, and good commentary. The one knock against it was no consistent coordination of text with illustrations - and really could have given the large format, and ability to size the pictures. Could have been a great book - but just a 'good' one.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Tintin: The Complete Companion
by
Michael Farr
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Good for fans interested in the historical context of the books. As a longtime TinTin fan, I found the commentary fascinating and informative. Did tire of the occasional panel-by-panel disection, but a worthwhile to the series.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Calvin and Hobbes Tenth Anniversary Book
by
Bill Watterson
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Still brilliant! For those new to Calvin&Hobbs, as well as fans, can't beat any of his collections, but this one stands out as it includes Watterson's reflections on life, art, and publishing. Can't recommend this highly enough.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Stranger Than Life: Cartoons and Comics 1970-2013
by
M. K. Brown
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Worth going through. Series of short pieces and one-offs, many of which I enjoyed (and some I didn't). Shows the development of the artist's work, and for someone who grew up in the '50s-'70s, many blasts-from-the-pasts.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Party, After You Left
by
Roz Chast
MAA
, February 05, 2017
LOVE Roz's work, and this is a great collection. The cover doesn't mislead (like many other graphic novel covers do - they pick a spectacular artist to do a bang-up job to get one's attention) - this is a wry, often hilarious, series of short pieces. Well worth it.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Mary Wept Over the Feet of Jesus
by
Chester Brown
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Don't let the title throw you. Yes, this addresses Mary, prostitutes, and religion, but it does much, much more than that. From the beginning sequence regarding Cain & Abel, this gives a whole new perspective to Bible Stories - not the ones I grew up with ;-). Not only are the 'graphic' stories worthwhile on their own, but this novel shares the author's thought-processes in studying the bible accounts, and giving his alternative readings depth & weight. You really should read 'til the end, as he continues to interweave graphics & prose writing. Brilliant, and highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Such a Lovely Little War: Saigon 1961-63
by
Marcelino Truong
MAA
, February 05, 2017
BRILLIANT! Highly recommended. One of the best graphic novels I've read in a while, and one of the best accounts of the VietNam war. As a child of the '60s, this is an important piece of history long missing & overdue: how this was viewed by another child of the '60s, half-vietnamese (the other half french) and living in Saigon at the early stages of the conflict.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Battle Lines: A Graphic History of the Civil War
by
Ari Kelman, Jonathan Fetter Vorm
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Recommended. Good artwork & excellent framing-device of what could have been contemporary newspaper headlines. In just a few words captured some of the more important less-well-known facts of the Civil War. For example, gives instants of what we would consider abuse-of-power by Lincoln (suspension of habeus corpus, indefinite detention, arrest & imprisonment of political opponents, refusal to consider peace overtures, etc.) so one can understand why many Northerners, as well as Southerners, considered Lincoln a tyrant. And gives the added perspective of individuals on both sides of the conflict: soldiers, family members, and civilians.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The Long Ships
by
Bengtsson, Frans G.
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Concur with other readers as well as the Foreward by Chabon: great adventure stories with a wry Viking point-of-view. Took only a short time to get into the rhythm & translator's language, which seemed true to the original. The only significant drawback for me was length - but was compelling enough to want to keep going, and read in it a few long chunks of time.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Honor Before Glory The Epic World War II Story of the Japanese American GIs Who Rescued the Lost Battalion
by
Scott Mcgaugh
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Well written account of what is probably familiar to those who have followed US WWII history, but here told from the perspective of individual soldiers, with brief backstories for each. Even-handed accounts of both the Japanese-American and 'White'/Texans rescued. Good, easy, read. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
White Trash: The 400-Year Untold History of Class in America
by
Nancy Isenberg
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Another great work with a different perspective in 'whiteness' 'studies'. Refreshing to learn the history of this 'racial' category stemming from class origins. And wonderful counter to the dominant narratives of white v. black that have tended to ignore this inconvenient truth: there are many 'whites' who, historically have often been considered below black slaves. Would recommend reading 'Not quite white : white trash' - a similar study; as well as 'Hillbilly Elegy', a contemporary personal account of growing up 'poor white'.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis
by
J.D. Vance
MAA
, February 05, 2017
One of many newer works re-examining 'racism' from the historical perspective of 'white trash' VERY well written in a unique style - unpretentious, direct language & honest personal understanding of one's own limitations & perspectives. As a YLS grad, could relate to his own issues rubbing shoulders with the East Coast elite, and feeling like an outsider. Gives one a very different picture of these issues. Highly recommended as a antidote to the current narratives of - white v. black. Recommend along with other similar works including more academic works like: 'White Trash : the 400-year untold history of class in America' & ''Not quite white' by Mary Wray.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Not Quite White: White Trash and the Boundaries of Whiteness
by
Matt Wray
MAA
, February 05, 2017
One of many newer works re-examining 'racism' from the historical perspective of 'white trash' from the earliest colonization of America. Gives one a very different picture of these issues. What struck me especially was the fact that the term 'white trash' was most likely coined by black slaves to denote a class of people below even them. For example, 'po' whites' were often given the most dangerous work because black slaves actually had monetary value as property, whereas these poor whites had none. Highly recommended as a antidote to the current narratives of - white v. black. Recommend along with other similar works including: 'White Trash : the 400-year untold history of class in America' & 'Hillbilly Elegy'.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
An Obvious Fact
by
Craig Johnson
MAA
, February 05, 2017
The latest in a long series. The usual twists, with a few good turns: motorcycles, especially Indians (for the gearheads like me), and the Sturgis annual conclave; exploration of the militarization of our local law enforcement (MRAP 'tanks', and newer weaponry); as well as Sherlock Holmes references thruout. Have gotten tired of some of the 'macho' quirks of our protagonist Sheriff Longmire, as well as his oft-times foul-mouthed antagonist-colleague undersheriff Vic, so downgraded from a 5 for yet another excellently written work, to a 4 because these characters never seem to grow up. Especially given the better Netflix series that does a much better job of character development.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Feast of Love (Widescreen)
by
Sergio Garcia
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Quirky film set in Powell's home town of Portland ... and reflects some of the vibe that draws people here. Slower paced than many American films, which allows the intertwined stories to unfold. Set in and about Portland, with a college-town feel, starring Reed College and Portland State University, as well as the athletic field next to the Multnomah Athletic Club (whatever name it had then & has now ... ) Recommended for a more mature audience - not because of violence or swearing or smoking (just a light here & there) - but because pre-teens may not really appreciate it.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Spare Parts
by
McNamara, Sean
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Well done, altho' familiar plot-line. It's not giving anything away to say this is one of any number of feel-good tear-jerkers regarding young people struggling in competition, winners at the end. Really enjoyed Jamie Lee here - low key supporting role, in more ways than 1. Great story, with low-key observation of immigration issues. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
McFarland, USA
by
Caro, Niki
MAA
, February 05, 2017
Well done, altho' familiar plot-line. It's not giving anything away to say this is one of any number of feel-good tear-jerkers regarding young people struggling in competition, winners at the end. Costner, as usual, does a great job. Felt real. As a native Californian this brought back memories of my family's support of Cesar Chavez & the UFWA thru the Migrant Ministry. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Ancillary Sword: Imperial Radch 2
by
Ann Leckie
MAA
, February 12, 2016
Brilliant series. The 1st Ancillary Justice, was highly recommended to me. Justice was difficult for me to get into - but I persevered & was glad I did! Took a bit to 'grok' the gender-bender perspective (female pronouns/identity regardless of how we earthlings identify) & the use of unfamiliar names to give us the 'alien' 'sci-fi' frame, but not so off-putting that I couldn't follow the plot & see character development. (I would rate Justice a 4 rather than 5 because of the relative difficulty for me.) Immediately went to get the 2d & 3d installments, and this one seemed easier to read - and I did in one setting - not something I do very often anymore. Enough plot twists & further character development, as well as philosophical insights, to be well worth it, but this is the kind of series that you'd want to start in sequence. Wish there were a 4th!
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Ancillary Mercy: Imperial Radch 3
by
Ann Leckie
MAA
, February 12, 2016
Great reason for this to be staff fave. My comment on previous books in this series bears repeating here. Brilliant series. The 1st Ancillary Justice, was highly recommended to me. Justice was difficult for me to get into - but I persevered & was glad I did! Took a bit to 'grok' the gender-bender perspective (female pronouns/identity regardless of how we earthlings identify) & the use of unfamiliar names to give us the 'alien' 'sci-fi' frame, but not so off-putting that I couldn't follow the plot & see character development. (I would rate Justice a 4 rather than 5 because of the relative difficulty for me.) Immediately went to get the 2d & 3d installments, and this one seemed even easier to read than the 1st two - and I did this in one setting as well - not something I do very often anymore. Enough plot twists & further character development, as well as philosophical insights, to be well worth it, but this is the kind of series that you'd want to start in sequence. Wish there were a 4th!
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Gates How Microsofts Mogul Reinvented
by
Stephen Manes
MAA
, February 12, 2016
Excellent read, and although written in 1993, still among the best about Gates as it looks at his childhood thru the beginning of Microsoft - so it isn't intended to addressed subsequent developments.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Youll Never Know Book One A Good & Decent Man
by
Carol Tyler
MAA
, December 21, 2015
Brilliant book. I've been engaged in my own research of my father's WWII experience, and found this helpful. Plus the graphics are great. Look forward to the next volumes. Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Plain Truth
by
Jodi Picoult
MAA
, August 24, 2015
Picoult is a very good writer. I started with her Leaving Time, which I still think is her best. I'd put Plain Truth as her next best, out of the others I've read. Great story & characters, and a particularly good portrayal of Amish/Plain Folk life & the many challenges presented by the intense focus on community - which is all-encompassing. Rings true from other books & documentaries I've see. Good enough that I was even able to overlook & suspend my dis-belief at the role of the defense attorney. Having practiced law for over 3 decades, including courtroom experience on both sides of the bar, I'm a bit jaundiced about the over-the-top melo-drama one finds in many current crime/police/courtroom novels. I'd wish they'd get a bit more real. So a demerit for the attorney/courtroom, but still a worthwhile read.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The Pact LP
by
Jodi Picoult
MAA
, August 24, 2015
Picoult is a very good writer, and if this was the 1st of her books I'd read, I'd give it a higher rating. That said, I first read her Leaving Time (LT), her latest - and LT is highly recommended by me. The Pact, and a number of other Picoult titles were my 2d, 3d, and 4th reads, and although good they just didn't match the superb story of Leaving Time. From where I sit, Leaving Time shows her writing has developed & improved over time. Having read a number in succession, her writing style in these older works seems more formulaic - alternating between past & present, his & her story, etc. This has become a typical format for many contemporary writers - rather than the more linear style of many others. Although it works in LT, it didn't seem as fresh somehow in these more 'realistic' novels. And for this particular title, I came away feeling that this story wasn't quite as believable. And that's having read her more fantasy-extra-sensory oriented Leaving Time. I've practised law for over 3 decades, and some of the legal scenes seemed more than a bit melo-dramatic. I get that we need a bit of over-the-top behavior for more action. But I've seen this in too many other works as well, so it's become more old-hat - and tired - for me. So ... a few demerits - one for being a notch off Leaving Time & being more formulaic, and another for a less-than-believable plot here.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Rock with Wings
by
Anne Hillerman
MAA
, August 24, 2015
Daughter Anne picks up from where her father Tony left off. Tony had a long string of superb books starring Lieutenant Leaphorn & Officer Chee, exploring life, history, and culture in Four Corners (the conjunction of the 4 states on which the Navajo Nation overlaps, and which borders on a number of other Indian territories). In this second by Anne she continues the character development of Bernie - a policewoman introduced by Tony towards the end of his series before Tony's death, and Bernie's relationship with her now-husband now-Sergeant Chee. Anne gets good marks for further development of Bernie & Chee, but we were a bit disappointed with her move away from exploring Navaho & other Indian traditions, into a present drifting away from those traditions. Sign of the times, perhaps, but not quite the caliber of her father's works for us - those insights into Indian traditions was a major draw for us. And we found some of the plotline barely believable. For Chee's he seems to leap from some very obscure clues into startling conclusions. For Bernie's Anne resorts to what we've seen as far-too-dramatic rough-n'tumble scenes, a la Walt Longmire. So down a few points from her father's high standards, but up a point for good characterizations - engaging enough that we'll probably read her next.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Pirate Latitudes
by
Michael Crichton
MAA
, August 24, 2015
Good read. I've enjoyed many of Crichton's other works, and found this a refreshing change. Reflects much research into the time & place, with many details that give it verisimility. Not only a good read, but a relatively short one - compared to his other works. I'm becoming more & more impressed by those writers who can capture engaging detail without getting bogged down in detail or diversion. Matched by my increasing distress at the length of far too many books now where writers seem to bolster the material to demonstrate how much they've researched, and how many threads/sub-plots they can weave. From where I sit now, seems trying a bit too hard to impress others, rather than laying out the facts (or plot, or characterization). So succinctness adds a point. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Splendid Outcast
by
Beryl Markham
MAA
, August 24, 2015
Beryl is a good writer - her memoir West with the Wind is superb & highly recommended. But the writing here is uneven. What makes some copies of this title worthwhile are the editor's comments, putting each of the short stories in context. We learn about the controversies regarding how much of each story is actually her's, or her husband's or various editors. And a number of these are romances written for WWII morale/propaganda purposes. So putting the stories in historical context elevates what might otherwise be a '3' to a '4', at least in my book.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
West With The Night
by
Beryl Markham
MAA
, August 24, 2015
There is a quote from Hemingway upon his reading of this - 'she has written so well, and marvelously well ... can write rings around all of us who consider ourselves writers ... parts of it that I know about ... are absolutely true.' Could hardly say it better myself. I've flagged so many passages for the beautiful use of language, turn of phrase, or verisimilitude that the book is dogeared. I plan to use it as an exemplar for English usage. The one caveat I would share is that she wrote in an era of romantic heroism - of colonial Africa between the wars - and although many of its depictions still ring true - my daughter is now in South Africa & I follow current events there - her accounts may be dated. But this is the best of her writings - the others just OK. She seems best able to write about her personal experiences, rather than trying to convert to fiction, even though many of her stories are tall-tales. That said, one of the best reads I've had in a while - and I read a lot, including more & more on Africa.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(2 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Falling from Horses
by
Molly Gloss
MAA
, May 21, 2015
Another great read - a real pleasure to read a good writer. Doesn't try to wrap things up neatly - a bugaboo of mine for the last few years. Many books peter out somewhere in the middle, with trite, cliched ends. Not this one. Makes me want to read the rest of her work. Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Leaving Time
by
Jodi Picoult
MAA
, May 21, 2015
One of the best books I've read in quite a while (and I average a few a week, down from 1 a day ... ) Part account of the plight of elephants, and their mental & emotional responses to death, part mystery with many twists & turns to the plot, and about letting go - 'leaving time'. Kept me guessing until the end - in a good way. Not the usual 'hide the ball' - the clues are there & not just revealed at the end. FWIW - my daughter has spent time with elephants in thailand & is now studying to be a 'large animal' vet - and she lived thru a mother elephant losing its calf, observing the devastating effects - so that part of the book is accurate.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(0 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
The Distraction Addiction: Getting the Information You Need and the Communication You Want, Without Enraging Your Family, Annoying Your Colleague
by
Soojung-Kim Pang, Alex
MAA
, January 29, 2014
Other comments are good - so I'll be brief & add the following: One of the better books popularizing various 'scientific' research - I've moved on from the Malcolm Gladwell genre of journalistic popularization which often gets some of the research wrong, and now look for those with academic/scientific credentials - they tend to get the research better, with all the caveats that should come with so-called sociological/psychological study - simply very difficult to overcome practical & ethical challenges in social science. Also appreciate the focus on 'zen' approaches to dealing with the avalanche of multi-media intrusions on our personal & shared spaces. Yes, breathe ... & take meditative breaks thruout the day & week ... Good (enough) science to support that too, as well as anecdotal stories.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Everything Volume 1 Blabber Blabber Blabber Comics from around 1978 81
by
Lynda Barry
MAA
, January 29, 2014
Lynda Barry is brilliant - I've read everything of hers I could get - but this gives us something new - her work from the beginning - back to those crazy 60s & 70s ... & 80s ... I'm dating myself, but this does transport me back. Quirky like it should be, so not for everyone, but that's part of the appeal.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Approximate Continuum Comics
by
Lewis Trondheim
MAA
, January 29, 2014
I love much of Trondheim translations. I'm a Francophile, so I probably 'get' the French sensibility, but I'd venture to guess that even those less than enamored with the Frogs will have plenty to enjoy. I've got it tagged with lots of stickies to go back & re-read. That's how good it is. Bonus feature - additional feed/push-back from those he has caricatured! Ah, those French ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
No One You Know
by
Bruce Eric Kaplan
MAA
, January 29, 2014
Simply Brilliant. New Yorker features great 1-shots, but this is best collection yet. Can't recommend highly enough. Really!
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Book of Five Rings A Graphic Novel
by
Sean Michael Wilson, Chie Kutsuwada, William Scott Wilson
MAA
, January 29, 2014
It could be worse ... but not by much. Poor drawings (but I've seen much worse). I'll assume that translations are correct, but if so, adaptation should have considered more bridge-work to make transitions better. Sigh ... far too many poor graphic publications these days ... makes Marvel/DC superhero stuff look good again. There must be better out there. Having seen Mifune movie & this claiming to be adaptation - couldn't be further from the truth. Just sayin'
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(0 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Grant vs. Lee: The Graphic History of the Civil War's Greatest Rivals During the Last Year of the War
by
Wayne Vansant
MAA
, January 29, 2014
Great artwork & history! What keeps it from being a '5' then? Editing of word balloons - too many misplaced words & letters. As I've noted elsewhere editing has gone downhill as apparent cost-cutting measure. When I worked at Dark Horse, editing was very important & we strove to deliver top quality. Those were the days ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Stargazing Dog
by
Takashi Murakami
MAA
, January 29, 2014
Very Good - thoughtful & good illustration. But ... flipped translation from the Japanese, and a few places where Romanesque letters appear backwards. Needs a bit more editing, like most American manga nowadays. If you're going to flip artwork in English format, go to Studio Proteus/Dark Horse publications from the last century (1990s - ah, the good 'ol days ... ). nbm ComicsLit has done better in the past, but I suppose costs enter into the equation a bit much now.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Meow Meow
by
Jose Fonollosa
MAA
, January 29, 2014
Lots of fun Good illustrations & so so true - we have 2 cats - 1 white 1 grey sisters - and this captures many of their moments ;-)
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
No Fighting No Biting An I Can Read
by
Else Holmelund Minarik, Maurice Sendak
MAA
, August 26, 2013
One of my favorites from my childhood. Just recommended to friend for grandchild who is ... biting ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Imperial Cruise A Secret History of Empire & War
by
James Bradley
MAA
, August 24, 2013
Bully! A welcome corrective to the recent relative Roosevelt hagiographies. Eye-opening, mind-expanding, ear-popping tales of Teddy, the Japan-Roosevelt-Monroe sphere-of-influence doctrines, Open-Door policies that appeal to the 'humanitarians' taking on the White Man's Burden, the overwhelming economic role of Jesus opium - including the fortunes of Delano & Roosevelt families, opposing the Yellow Peril from China & the Phillipines by enlisting the 'Aryan' Japanese!! Well written, altho' one gets the feeling that Bradley lays it on just a little thick to counter the Bully-Boy syndrome of late.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(2 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Man Who Quit Money
by
Mark Sundeen
MAA
, August 02, 2012
Read this book - it is that good - I'm recommending it to family & friends. The subject: our relationship to $. The object: to educate us, inform us, engage us. The result: I'm encouraged to find those with the courage to take our spiritual guides seriously, who follow them by emulating them. Let go of our death-grip attachment to the abstraction of $ that makes many of us its slaves and becomes a god. Relatively short, to-the-point, portrait by a good writer - the absence of which I have noted elsewhere. Too many books today are far too long, need editing & pruning, and lose me about 100 pages in. Not this one. Again, read this book!
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(4 of 6 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Two-Fisted Science
by
Jim Ottaviani
MAA
, July 22, 2012
Excellent overview of physicists 20th century context. Ottaviani's entire series of science graphic novels are topnotch. Highly recommended, as are all of his graphic novels.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Fallout J Robert Oppenheimer Leo Szilard & the Political Science of the Atomic Bomb
by
Jim Ottaviani
MAA
, July 22, 2012
Excellent. Ottaviani's entire series of science graphic novels are topnotch. Here, a number of different artists make their own contributions to the overall work. Highly recommended, as are all of his graphic novels.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Levitation: Physics and Psychology in the Service of Deception
by
Jim Ottaviani
MAA
, July 22, 2012
Excellent. Ottaviani's entire series of science graphic novels are topnotch. Highly recommended, as are all of his graphic novels.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Bone Sharps Cowboys & Thunder Lizards Edward Drinker Cope Othniel Charles Marsh & the Gilded Age of Paleontology
by
Ottaviani, Jim
MAA
, July 22, 2012
Excellent and dramatic retelling of a relatively unknown corner of paleontology history. Brings to life the 'gilded age.' Ottaviani's entire series of science graphic novels are topnotch. Highly recommended, as are all of his graphic novels.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Suspended in Language: Niels Bohrs Life, Discoveries, and the Century He Shaped
by
Jim Ottaviani
MAA
, July 22, 2012
Excellent, and relatively detailed, overview of Bohr & the physicist's 20th century context. Ottaviani's entire series of science graphic novels are topnotch. Here, a number of different authors & artists make their own contributions to the overall work - plus a fun booklet on teleportation. Highly recommended, as are all of his graphic novels.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Suspended in Language Niels Bohrs Life Discoveries & the Century He Shaped
by
Jim Ottaviani
MAA
, July 22, 2012
Excellent, and relatively detailed, overview of Bohr & the physicist's 20th century context. Ottaviani's entire series of science graphic novels are topnotch. Here, a number of different authors & artists make their own contributions to the overall work - plus a fun booklet on teleportation. Highly recommended, as are all of his graphic novels.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The Great Fatherland War (Rise and Fall of the Soviet Union)
by
Melanie Reim
MAA
, March 02, 2011
I'll give this 1 more star than some other young adult histories - I'm a bit taken aback by a brace of these, but this is one of the better ones. In the process of making these books more accessible, they have non-historians writing them, and as a result, they make some obvious errors. I happen to have studied quite a bit of WWII history, and I still have more to learn. I did get a better understanding of the Soviet perspective, but the account is marred by what are to me obvious errors, which leads me to question how much of the rest of it is faulty. As an example, the author characterizes a Panther as a 'light tank' - well, perhaps compared to the Tiger, or some of the Soviet behemoths, it certainly was lighter than those -- but not compared to most other Allied or German or Japanese tanks. At more than 44 tons, it was one of the heavier tanks in the war. If you can't get something like this correct - a relatively objective description - what else didn't he get right? It is important to note that more than 1 'history,' including this one, 'defines' 'communism' as 'ownership by the community as a whole.' This is, at best, a gross oversimplification, of some idealized version of "small 'c'" communism. But in this context, this is simply disingenuous. By the 30's, it was clear that 'the community' (in some kind of democratic or representative form) certainly did not run any 'communist' country, or anything else - they were all controlled and dictated by the State, by then in the name of Stalin and The Party in the USSR. This is beyond trying to be balanced by giving a neutral definition of communism -- again, by the 30s, there simply hadn't been any 'communist' government or economic system that was owned or run by 'the people' - unless one is using the euphemism to refer to 'My People' - and it is misleading to define it as such in the Glossary. This kind of error permeates this genre - oversimplification & an attempt to be politically correct mars what could otherwise be a decent overview & introduction to the Russian Front. So, it gets 1 star for a decent overview, and some glimpse at the horrors of Stalin's Soviet Union, but minus 1 for the misleading 'definition' of 'communism' (without any attempt to provide further context to the use of that term), minus another 1 for getting some of the obvious objective details wrong, which leads to another minus 1 for raising questions about its accuracy.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Fdr's Alphabet Soup: New Deal America 1932-1939
by
Tonya Bolden
MAA
, March 02, 2011
I'm a bit taken aback by a brace of 'young adult' histories. In the process of making these books more accessible, they have non-historians writing them, and as a result, they make some obvious errors. Here, this is compounded by breezy, slangy, writing, and what appears to be a 'leftist' slant, notwithstanding some attempt to provide a balanced view of the pros & cons advanced at the time. Some other reviewers have commented on the choppy style & graphic packaging, so I won't belabor that here. But I do think it important to note that more than 1 'history' 'defines' 'communism' as 'ownership of the means of production by the people.' This is, at best, a gross oversimplification, of some idealized version of "small 'c'" communism. But in this context, this is simply disingenuous. By the 30's, it was clear that 'the people' (in some kind of democratic or representative form) certainly did not 'own' the means of production, or anything else - they were all owned, controlled, and dictated by the State, by then in the name of Stalin and The Party in the USSR. This is beyond trying to be balanced by giving a neutral definition of communism -- again, by the 30s, there simply hadn't been any 'communist' government or economic system that was owned or run by 'the people' - unless one is using the euphemism to refer to 'My People' - and it is misleading to define it as such in the Glossary. This kind of error permeates this genre - oversimplification & an attempt to be politically correct mars what could otherwise be a decent overview & introduction to the New Deal. So, it gets 1 star for a decent overview, and some glimpse at the various controversies, but minus 1 for the misleading 'definition' of 'communism' (without any attempt to provide further context to the use of that term), minus another 1 for the slang - most of which is out of context & wouldn't be recognized by people in the 30s, minus another 1 for the otherwise breezy, casual, writing style, and minus another 1 for the choppy presentation.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
You Are There
by
Jacques Tardi
MAA
, October 08, 2010
Quirky French graphic novel. Decent translation, but takes a bit to get into the rhythm & flow of the plot, which twists & turns all the way to the end! Tardi's artwork superb. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(4 of 7 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
It Was the War of the Trenches
by
Jacques Tardi
MAA
, October 08, 2010
Ranks right up there with Charlie's War as the best of graphics novels for taking you Over There. Wonderful artwork, and the translation works well. Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Broken Trail (Widescreen)
by
MAA
, October 08, 2010
As another reviewer has said - regardless of original format (tv series), this is one of the best westerns ever. Take a few points off for the occasional black-out separation between scenes, and the division into 2 1-1/2 hour 'movies' - that still leaves a great story, and great performances. Many realistic details - clothing, Chinese language, gritty Western towns, and for those of us in the Northwest references to John Day, Burns, and points east in Idaho. Great dialogue, with plenty of action in between otherwise measured pace, with the stories unfolding, then being woven into the ongoing plot arc.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Mongol
by
MAA
, May 02, 2010
Good epic of Genghis Khan's early life. Very realistic feel -- the recent documentaries about Mongol life on the steppes suggest life hasn't changed all that much in the millenia. Parts felt a bit slow, and the film starts approaching the limits of seat comfort, but the story is engaging enough to have kept me in my seat until the end. The only detraction from my western view was the 'kung-fu' moves & blood spurts -- an oriental film culture artifact that thankfully takes up only a small part of the story & action.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Museum Vaults Excerpts from the Journal of an Expert
by
Marc Antoin Mathieu
MAA
, May 02, 2010
Another great piece in this series! I often look for NBM/ComicsLit works - and this one meets my high expectations for this imprint. Great tour thru the Louvre & environs, and art history. Refreshing view of that history & 'art.' Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
J. Edgar Hoover: A Graphic Biography
by
Rick Geary
MAA
, April 21, 2010
I've read much of Geary's work, and this is one of his better ones. For me, his bland, straightforward ('just the facts') accounts take a bit getting used to, as does his distinctive 'squared off' artwork. Nonetheless, they give what appear to be evenly balanced summaries of important lives & events of our past 2 centuries. And this one - the life & times of J Edgar - provides a greater breadth that others. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Paul Has A Summer Job
by
Michel Rabagliati
MAA
, April 21, 2010
Highly recommended. This whole series has been great! Perhaps I enjoy these more because they speak to me of my adolescence in the '70s -- I can attest that he captures the time well. As for the place - I love Quebec, but grew up & now live on the West Coast - USA. From my few years' stint on the East Coast, he seems to have captured that summer-in-the-mountains well. This is well written & illustrated work that deserves the literate nom 'graphic novel'. Cheers
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Big Kahn
by
Neil Kleid
MAA
, April 21, 2010
Highly recommended. Great thought-provoking story about family lies & secrets, faith communities and their lack-of-faith, fair weather friends, and integrity in the face of adversity. The writer's Brownsville is also recommended. The one drawback to this work is the art -- altho it does help convey some of the emotional impact of the story, I was wishing for better.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Glacial Period
by
Nicolas De Crecy
MAA
, April 21, 2010
Recommended. Great satire on our archeological & sociological digs in particular, and our proclivity to make up stories in our efforts to 'make sense' of the past in general. Also a more thought-provoking scenario for genetic manipulation and 'species bias.' And finally, a survey of art in the Louvre. I very much wanted a bigger format, in order to better enjoy the wonderful artwork - both that of the Louvre and of the graphic artist.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Miss Dont Touch Me
by
Hubert
MAA
, April 18, 2010
Delicious French view of fin de siecle manners & (im)morals, while taking us thru a murder mystery. Superb artwork, and what appears to be great transliteration from French. Enough twists & turns in the plot to keep the mystery story alive, and plenty of 'twists' & 'turns' in the S&M/brothel world catering to the upper classes. Both naughty & nice - highly recommended for mature audience -- the violence is actually tame by superhero standards of today, but the discussion & depiction of the S&M world is for a more discerning mind. The one quibble I have is with the format: although this is produced on high quality paper, the fine artwork is lost in this small size format -- this could well have benefited greatly from larger format that ComicsLit has done in the past with Vittorio Giardino.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Helmet Of Fate 01
by
Gail Simone
MAA
, April 17, 2010
I wasn't familiar with the underlying comic 'saga,' but these short stories helped pull me into this world. Each section has a different writer/artist team, and each does a good job. The dialogue has a bit too much of the self-conscious adolescent smart-talk in it for me (I'm an old fart who'd like a bit more 'mature/intelligent' content, like Dark Horse more often publishes). Enough substance for me to recommend it -- you don't have to have immersed yourself in the rest of the superhero sagas to get something worthwhile out of a read.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Classic Airplanes Pioneering Aircraft & The Visionaries Who Built Them
by
Harold Rabinowitz
MAA
, April 17, 2010
Recommended - surprizingly good writing for what might otherwise have been just another 'coffee table' 'art book.' The author demonstrates a good deal of knowledge about his subject, and a much better writing style than one usually finds in military history. One might quibble about his choices, but they give us a good overview of aviation history in wonderful narrative summaries. I ended up wanting a bit more info, and certainly even more photos, and the reproduction quality was perhaps just a bit off perfect. And, having been written a while ago, its ending seems dated, but a mere quibble.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Beowulf Director's Cut (Blu-ray)
by
MAA
, April 17, 2010
OK - but just. Intriguing CGI effects overlaying live-action, but ultimately gives feel of advanced computer game: movements seem a bit jerky. Story is decent, and some extras worth watching. And i wouldn't call this scifi -- just because it uses CGI doesn't automatically put it in that genre: this is fantasy, or 'historical fiction,' if anything - nothing 'sciency' about story.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Moon (Blu-ray)
by
MAA
, April 17, 2010
Wow! What a sleeper ;-)! Highly recommended: this is the best scifi I've seen in a long, long time - reminiscent of the best of the 70s & 80s. And watching some of the extra commentary, this was intentional. The 'old school' special effects work extremely well - I didn't know it was 'old' effects until the commentary. Sam does a helluva job acting here, and the story kept taking unexpected turns, altho' about mid-way thru I was starting to piece things together. So this is more than just scifi: it is also character study, detective/mystery, and philosophically thought-provoking. All this from an 'indie' production - kudos to Sony for picking this up after Sundance. Cheers
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Distant Neighborhood Volume 1 By Jiro Taniguchi
by
Jiro Taniguchi
MAA
, April 12, 2010
Great read - it was hard to put it down when finished: I actually went back thru the book, looking more closely at the illustrations. Good artwork, and good story, with enough detail and twists to keep the plot moving, and wanting to get to the next book soon to continue. The transitions from his 'dream' visitations to his future 'past' to his new 'present' are subtle, and it took me a bit to realize when one started and the other finished, but the protagonist isn't sure where he is either. The transliteration seems good, and I prefer this 'flopped' Western left to right reading. I approve of the larger format as well -- I'm no fan of the current manga fad with translations that keep the small cheap paper in right to left format -- OK for reading, but done as much to save printing costs as it does to preserve the original Japanese aesthetics. One quibble - there are 1 or 2 spots where the translation to American English appears to have dropped a preposition (but this happens in 'American' comics as well), & there appears to be a more modern car in the background of a scene that should be from WWII -- was this intentional (the time warp theme), or an oversight? Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Pixu The Mark of Evil
by
Gabriel Ba
MAA
, April 03, 2010
Gripping read: I picked it up, and couldn't put it down before I had finished. That said, I'm not a fan of the latest 'edgy' drawing that passes for art nowadays. The uneven quality probably reflects different hands for different chapters, and the 'edginess' is appropriate for this series of vignettes ... but I still don't like it. Hence, the story gets a '4', some of the art a '2', leaving me to give this a '3.'
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Five Books Of Blood Question
by
Greg Rucka
MAA
, April 01, 2010
Uh oh ... this can't be the same Rucka who wrote Whiteout, and Queen & Country ... can it? The premise was intriguing, and given my love of the 2 named series, I read til the end. But I wouldn't have without Rucka's reputation. To me, seemed too gimmicky, what with fanciful 'ancient' script and all. And I'm not a fan of the glossy paper computer colorized print that passes for art nowadays. Decent art -- I've seen much worse -- but it also could have been much better. Oh well, can't win 'em all. I highly recommend Whiteout & Queen&Country -- 2 of my faves, actually. But I can't recommend this: not my cup o' tea ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Paul Goes Fishing
by
Michel Rabagliati
MAA
, April 01, 2010
This is a great read! My first introduction to "Paul," I was pulled into the story immediately. It becomes clear that Paul is the alter ego of our author, which lends some cache to the underlying reality of the story. But, for me, it didn't need it: I related to so many of the events here: 1st time fishing, visiting a log cabin on a beautiful lake, and most poignantly, the issues surrounding 1st time parents. His recounting of his life as a graphic artist are particularly apt: I worked in the biz last century (1990s ;-)), contemporaneously with the time period he portrays here -- and it feels spot on. Unlike some reviewers, I didn't find this 'boring' at all; quite the contrary. But then, I'm into 'slice of life' stories, where the real truth often lays. Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Ponyo
by
Hayao Miyazaki
MAA
, March 30, 2010
Good movie, well done. I love the Ghibli Studio work, and have seen most all of its production. This one is up to the imaginative & evocative wizardry of the 'old style' animation, but for me, seemed to gloss over the darker aspects a bit too much for me. This might make it more suitable for the 'G' audience, but I liked the shadows of Totoro, et al, more. Worth seeing, but I'd recommend any of the other Ghibli Studios works first.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Heaven Can Wait
by
MAA
, March 30, 2010
Good film well done. But it is the Criterion collection edition that gets the '4,' for their usual edifying interviews, documentaries, and other extras. For me, simply watching the movie without the extra context, I would have given it a '3'. My spouse actually got up & left - for her, it was too bland & boring to keep her attention. As I've noted elsewhere, I enjoy the slice of life, slower paced, movies. This one was on the cusp for me. But then I saw the film critique with 2 critics, and the bios on the screenwriter playwright. Gave me a better appreciation of the film. Makes the film a solid 3 -- again, with Criterion bonuses, moves it to a 4.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Healing of America
by
T R Reid
MAA
, March 29, 2010
Worthwhile read, with significant caveats. Well written narrative about the author's search for relief from a bum shoulder, and his observations about the various 'sick care' systems he visits. His basic point -- that the US care system has problems, and we can learn from others -- is obviously true. And he adds to the discussion with his own case-in-point. However, he has missed, or glossed over, some obvious factors, and drawn what I see as weakly supported conclusions. He is not alone here: much of the debate in the US misses major points, showing what I believe to be significant unexamined biases and prejudices. 1st major point: the best relief he receives is from ... India, using non-allopathic medicine [non-Western MD]. The treatment philosophy? The body heals itself. The result? He is more or less pain free at low cost now without further interventions, whereas Western medicine only offered ongoing steroids, or significant surgery, at significant cost. He also notes the significant role of public health, versus individual treatment, but then drops that as he focuses back on sick care. So why does he go on & tout expensive drug & surgery Western medicine as the 'cure'? Probably a significant bias/prejudice in favor of Western medicine, notwithstanding his own experience. 2nd major point: he notes that all the 'universal health care' systems are struggling with costs ... but then more or less drops the subject as if all these wealthy nations are going to somehow solve that problem. With respect to Europe & Japan, if you've been reading the news lately, all have significant economic problems: Greece essentially bankrupt, with Portugal, Ireland, and Italy on the cusp. Why? Costs for social welfare far exceeding revenues, with no politically palatable way of resolving issue, short of borrowing from others (deferring problem to the future). If we adopt their model, we get ... major economic problems (as if we didn't have enough already). 3d major point: he neglects to compare the US to the other, now former, superpower, Russia fka USSR, or to the upcoming superpower, China. He does note that China has moved from a universal system run by the state, to a private out=of-pocket, but again, leaves that dangling. And India, the other large country with a diverse population, also has an out-of-pocket non-universal system, and it is the one place he gets a cure! Hmm ... . Goes to show you that theory triumphs over facts -- here, that Western medicine is the 'cure' for 'health care,' and that the US should follow other Western European models, notwithstanding his own case. He ignores the lessons of these 3 'non-Western' countries, which have significant attributes to be considered in the mix: they have populations comparable to the US - large (100 million+) ethnically, culturally, and economically diverse/heterogeneous, unlike the much smaller, homogenous, and richer populations of the richer Western countries he surveys. 4th major point: he focuses on 'ethics' and 'morals' of care, even though 'values' would be a more descriptive, unloaded, term. One of the challenges we face is heterogeneous values -- we simply don't agree on all things, in part because many of us came from different cultures. Speaking of values: why does he implicitly elevate health care over food security, housing, clothing? These 3 are far more basic - and I would submit - important. Why does he elevate taking care of our own already rich country, when most of the world doesn't have even food or shelter? 5th major point: he doesn't discuss the doctor & nurse shortages we have in the US, or how we might address that. In short: He doesn't even address, much less answer, many of these questions. He may ultimately be right, but he doesn't demonstrate it here: in fact, his own example undercuts it. Phew ... So ... worth reading, but doesn't provide well-supported answers, and in that sense, misleading. Disclaimer: my spouse is an allopathic physician (MD) practicing a hybrid of allopathic & 'healing touch' medicine in the US, outside of the insurance-funded system by choice (cash at the time of service) because she can then spend more time with her patients. I practiced law advising health practitioners and insurers for over a decade, authoring short articles on health care antitrust.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(0 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Cars (Widescreen)
by
John Lasseter
MAA
, March 23, 2010
This is about as good as it gets! Good story; great action, character voices, music/soundtrack; good extras -- all short & entertaining: the inspiration interview is great, and well worth watching. All this, and a 'G' rating -- everyone can watch (except the very young or excitable, who shouldn't be watching videos/TV/movies anyway). Racing sounds enhanced with the surround sound option. This is my second viewing - after the big screen a while ago - and I still enjoyed it, but then I'm a gearhead.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
De Tales Stories From Urban Brazil
by
Fabio Moon
MAA
, March 22, 2010
Great intro to these 2 young artists. I enjoyed the short story format, and the variation in style presented. Look forward to more.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Gunsmith Cats Burst 04
by
Kenichi Sonoda
MAA
, March 22, 2010
Still a great series, as we see the return of an unexpected visitor. The characters' lives are about to be altered in significant ways -- they don't know it yet, but they are splitting up and going each their own way -- at least for the moment. More focus on character development, with plenty of gunfire, but absent as much car talk. I'm now off to find #5 ... Note: I still prefer Studio Proteus flipped-page transliterations, but this 'original format' (= less expensive transfer on cheap paper & small format) will have to do for the foreseeable future.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Trial Run
by
Dick Francis
MAA
, March 18, 2010
Another great read from Francis. I don't enjoy every Francis book, but I enjoy a number of them: and this is one of his tops for me. The usual 'horsy' backdrop plays a prominent role here, but the setting is Moscow preparing for the Olympics. This is written during the cold war, after Munich, but before the changes in the '80s. Quite a bit of political analysis & intrigue on the long running infatuation some Brits had for the Soviet, and his take on the realities. So, I not only enjoyed the usual mystery, but enjoyed his take on the '70s setting.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Appaloosa
by
MAA
, March 18, 2010
Decent western with a twist, 2 decent 'buddy' depictions, but with one marred performance. Disclaimer: I dislike Renee Zellweger portrayals ... altho' she was good in Bridget Jones, I haven't enjoyed any of her other performances. But I didn't expect her performance to drag down the rest of the film. Ed Harris & Vigo Mortensen give intriguing take on western buddy/sidekick schtick. It works ... until Renee shows up. For me, clear that she will be trouble from the get-go ... and she definitely is. For me, film goes downhill from there, and even the twist for an ending doesn't fully redeem it. Oh well, ... still good for par [3] here. But I keep wondering what it would have been like without her ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Julie and Julia (Widescreen)
by
MAA
, March 18, 2010
Heretic warning: despite accolades & awards, I think this is just a so-so movie. My spouse liked it ... but I didn't. Disclosure: I'm not a cooking fan, nor a Meryl Streep one, and I'm unimpressed with stream-of-consciousness blogging. I had avoided seeing this movie for those reasons: I sensed I had been over-exposed to Meryl, and this film presented Meryl, et al, with a tall order (pun intended). However, I am a writing fan, and it was this theme that keep me in my seat until the end. That said, I never really felt anything in the movie was real. Meryl/Julia's affected speech (even if that accurately depicted Julia's), the attempt by Meryl to portray the tall Julia, Amy Adams' 'bitchy' Julie (especially if that portrayed the 'real' Julie), the thin roles for the 2 male lead/husbands, ... . I didn't relate to any of it ... except the writing. Decent depiction of the rollercoaster ride for writers. If it hadn't been for that, and the Meryl/Julia half, I wouldn't have watched til the end (and you wouldn't have seen this review -- NB: I only rate those books/films that I have finished, and I'm at a point in life where I simply move on to another if I feel it is under par [3]). So, this would have been a 2 without Meryl & co. in her half, a 3 with.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(0 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
The Informant! (Widescreen)
by
Matt Damon
MAA
, March 16, 2010
For me, this is a 5+! I was given this DVD by my sister, who had seen it while flying to Australia. I didn't realize it was supposed to be a 'comedy,' and was taken in by the serious manner in which the story opened. As it happens, I did antitrust work, and was familiar with the ADM conspiracy, so the story unfolded in very lifelike fashion. But it didn't take long for me to be startled by the successive plot twists & turns, and start laughing. Each succeeding piece of the story got me laughing harder & harder until I hurt ... ! Seriously, this is the most I have laughed in many, many years. Matt Damon is a genius -- my estimation of his talents has just gone sky high. Scott Bakula impresses -- I didn't much appreciate his Star Trek run, but he is great here. And look for the vignettes by Tom Smothers and others .. all played straight. Do we have a bit of Arrested Development here? I can't recommend this highly enough - my only fear is that somehow its tongue-in-cheek / play-it-straight presentation is too subtle, or it just hit my funnybone at the right time & place, and others might not 'get' the humor. However, my sister kept suppressing her smiles as I was rolling around laughing out loud -- she didn't want to spoil the fun. She stated afterwards that she was surprised it didn't pick up more nominations & awards, and she is someone who generally has seen all the movies up for awards. Here, I agree - Matt Damon earned Best Actor, and the film earned Best Film, whether or not nominated or won by others.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The Hurt Locker (Widescreen)
by
Kathryn Bigelow
MAA
, March 16, 2010
Good, engaging, film. Well worth all the awards & accolades. Manages to develop 3 team member characters, and leaves me wanting to know more about them. Avoids many of the cliches that might otherwise appear in such a film -- doesn't neatly tie up all the loose ends, or have good triumph over evil ... . Well written, well acted, well directed/edited, with a score that integrates with & enhances the story. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Henry Poole Is Here
by
Luke Wilson
MAA
, March 11, 2010
A sleeper ... slowly awakes. Wonderful film. Luke Wilson does a marvelous job, his eyes conveying a good deal more than most actors can put into their entire bodies. He runs the gamut from sad, angry, sullen, irritated, depressed, back to angry, but then expands to curious, engaged, intrigued, caring. Although there are moments of humor here, this is a 'comedy' only in the original sense of 'happy ending.' Much more drama, and corresponding depth, than you would get from reading the various blurbs. Great supporting cast, including the authentic Mexican neighbor, and the young girl. Or am I just not getting the jokes? I sure hope folks aren't laughing at the many sad moments in this film -- if so, and this passes as humor, we live in a very cynical time. I choose to believe that this film saves itself from the saccharin treacle it could have been, and redeems itself in the deft way it handles heavier themes. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Man Named Pearl
by
MAA
, March 09, 2010
My spouse especially enjoyed this documentary of a self-taught gardening sculptor, using topiary as his medium. I enjoyed it too, as a character study of this individual, his family, his community, and the South. Slow paced, matching his measured development of his topiary masterpieces. Some of the comments focus on his long-range planning -- some of these topiaries literally take years to develop, as the branches grow out to the scale he envisions. Wonderful South Carolina accents, black, white, and all the colors in between. His personal philosophy unfolds throughout, but it wasn't until the short interview afterwards that I put together his steady work with topiary to his steady work with youngsters. Well worth the time - it is a short film, but you need to hang in there with its slow pace.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Flash of Genius
by
MAA
, March 06, 2010
Good picture of the pitfalls of entrepreneurial invention, engineering, 'partnering' with large corporations, and the patent enforcement system -- justice might ultimately be gained, but at a high human cost. Kinnear does a marvelous job as our protagonist, and the young actors & actresses as his family do so as well. Nice side bits by a number of other good actors, but none are really fleshed out much. Worth seeing more for the 'documentary'/based on a real story feel, than for character development.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Pluto Urasawa X Tezuka Volume 1
by
Naoki Urasawa
MAA
, March 06, 2010
Wow! Just came across this, and happy to see that there are many more volumes! Great take on the original Astro Boy story. Great artwork. Great commentary & notes at the end, too. English translation using 'original' (right to left) Japanese format works here. That said, I still prefer the transliteration ('flopped' version left to right) from Studio Proteus, and the older Dark Horse manga publications, and not just for the more natural ease of reading English left to right, but for the higher quality transliteration - including 'sound' effects -- and paper stock. At least Pluto is in larger-than-normal American 'manga' page size, the better to appreciate the artwork. Can't wait to read the next in the series. Enjoy.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Grendel Devils Reign
by
Matt Wagner, Tim Sale
MAA
, March 03, 2010
Matt Wagner is awesome, and his Grendel series captivating. This volume is a must for the completist. But I have mixed feelings about this volume as a stand-alone. Ambitious, and in order to capture the span of this epic, the author tries a different tack: he uses a 'He/She' dialog box, rather than simple word balloons. For me, I found this a bit wearing -- perhaps the intent was to set this up for a movie -- it almost reads like a screenplay. Also, this volume could have benefitted from a bigger format -- the artwork should have been displayed; instead, it felt a bit cramped. Perhaps the storyline might want to convey this sense? For me, I would have preferred a bigger format, and they could then have dropped the 'He/She' dialog boxes. Oh well, ... the story was compelling enough for me to slog thru to the end, and be glad I did.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Slay Ride
by
Dick Francis
MAA
, March 03, 2010
Another great read from Dick Francis - god rest his soul. This time, we travel to Norway. Less violence than many of his others -- perhaps its the Norwegian setting, and only 1 murder, until the end ... . But what a ride 'til then! I'm a big fan, and have read many of his mysteries, and I'd put this one near the top. Easier read than some of his others, and, as usual, keeps you guessing right up to the end.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
90 Classic Books For People In A Hurry
by
Henrik Lange
MAA
, March 01, 2010
What a hoot! Breezy, succinct, and usually spot-on 1-page summaries of 90 classics. My favorites include: "No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency" - 'she solves some everyday problems ... '; "The Trial" - 'Score 1 for the legal system!'; & "The Bible" - 'in the end we're all probably going to h... '. Drawings sketchy, but hey, these are supposed to be sketches ;-)
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Slumdog Millionaire (Widescreen)
by
MAA
, March 01, 2010
Worth all the accolades. Alternating present with past thru flashbacks, this film takes us from childhood in the 20th century slums of Bombay to the modern trappings of 21st century Mumbai. In many ways, the more things change, the more they are the same. The number of continuity questions that arise, partly as a result of the shifts from past to present, are relatively easily suspended -- we come to believe that, indeed, the protagonist's life follows its own destiny. The occasionally violent episodes are brief enough, and integral enough to the story that even my spouse -- who will walk away from film violence -- stayed with this movie to the end.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(2 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Coraline (Widescreen)
by
Henry Selick
MAA
, February 27, 2010
Well worth all the praise - highly recommended. This film exceeded my expectations - animation was wonderful, seamless (pun intended). My spouse, who is not a fan of animation, was engrossed the entire film. That said, the day after, all I'm left with is images -- no moral, storyline, or thought provoked. So, like Avatar, great eye candy, with a plot & characters that engage, but ... the morning after, not much to say, other than I'd recommend the experience to others. By the way, we didn't view thru 3D glasses -- we'd been there & done that decades ago, and the paper frames & lens look the same after all these years. Having seen Avatar on IMAX in 3D, with wraparound 'shades' - the newer 3D technology can be impressive. However, the 2D version is plenty impressive on its own -- 3D might add another dimension, but not another star ;-)
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Oh My Goddess 34
by
Kosuke Fujishima
MAA
, February 25, 2010
Another great addition to this wonderful manga series. Highly recommended - especially for 'monkey' wrench-heads. Weaves in extended discussion of Honda Monkeys, Gorillas, and Supercubs, motors, transmissions, and related mods. Also includes, for the completeist, author commentary (translated, natch) from earlier series. My continued quibble -- I prefer Dark Horse's early collaboration with Studio Proteus - 'flopped' transliteration on larger format, higher quality paper.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The Family Stone (Widescreen)
by
Diane Keaton
MAA
, February 20, 2010
Recommended, with caveats. I have very mixed feelings about this movie. Some excellent performances, and a much meatier movie than first meets the eye. But I had to get thru the first 15 minutes to start appreciating it. Sorry, but I'm not a big fan of what passes for 'comedy' these days. Dysfunctional relationships, cursing, forced intimacy, stereotypes, cliches, and political correctness ruin many a recent movie for me. I'm not Pollyanna, but I also don't need to expose myself to any more tokens tearing each other down. That said, the movie starts getting some welcome reality as the stick-figure characters get some flesh & start taking on life. What could have become a set-piece soap (my god, we've got a deaf gay, a black gay, a pregnant daughter with no dad in sight, a bitchy mom with breast cancer, the young bitchy daughter, the uptight fiancee, the laid-back dope-smoking younger brother, the strong-silent oldest son, the huggy dad, the little girl with glasses, ... ), starts exploring some of the deeper currents of these lives, in subtle unfolding. ... Only to be ruined, for me, by an extended ending where everyone lives happily ever after ... The movie could have ended earlier, on an open-ended note, and there is even a brief black-out transition, which would have been a better ending, for me. See it for yourself.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Logicomix An Epic Search for Truth
by
Apostolos Doxiadis, Bertrand Russel
MAA
, February 19, 2010
Highly recommended. Great as a graphic novel. Great as a presentation of philosophy, mathematics, and logic. Great as a biography of Bertrand Russell. Great as a thumbnail sketch of the great minds & ideas of the 20th century. So ... it's great! This might work as a more accessible introduction to these subjects for students, and get folks turned on to this wonderful world of ideas, and how they apply to our everyday world.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(5 of 5 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
RASL Volume 01 The Drift
by
Jeff Smith
MAA
, February 19, 2010
Recommended. I loved Smith's Bone, and couldn't wait to read this. Large format is great, as is story. But ... I was a bit disappointed with the artwork. Especially with big format, I found myself wanting more. Nonetheless, I'm tracking down the rest of the series because of the story.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Loyal 47 Ronin
by
MAA
, February 19, 2010
Highly recommended. Wonderfully acted & filmed version of this classic Japanese story. For a 1958 movie, this is an exceptional print - beautiful color that captures the various dress, costume, and armor of the period. Some might find it a bit long, but I didn't mind the character & plot development: for me, it added more depth to what could otherwise be cut to a simple action flick. Extras are worthwhile additions -- in particular the Program Notes -- altho' citation to Wikipedia gives one brief pause. Just a few glitches with the translations, but these are minor quibbles for a great film.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Top Ten Book 2
by
Alan Moore
MAA
, February 17, 2010
As with volume 1, great writing by Moore, and good artwork by Ha, et al. For me, though, the artwork in this series is a bit too dense -- too much happening, too busy. I had occasion to re-read Masamune's Dominion manga graphic novel, and although the artwork there also has much going on in the background and in the margins, it isn't overwhelming. Perhaps the color in the Top 10 series is the culprit for me. I prefer the old Studio Proteus/Dark Horse Dominion volumes to these Top 10.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Au Revoir Les Enfants
by
MAA
, February 17, 2010
Classic French film on occupied France, with one story of sheltering Jews from the death camps amid its more sordid general history of anti-semitism & collaboration with the Nazis. Based on the author's own experience during WWII, this is a realistic portrayal of a young man's coming of age while only dimly aware of the larger events in his own world. It ends with his awakening to those larger issues ... The Criterion series is great, and here one is provided with a well done booklet. It also states it has an improved English translation for the subtitles -- I took French for many years, and this seemed like a good translation. This package well worth it.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Life & Times Martha Washington
by
Frank Miller
MAA
, February 04, 2010
Great collection! Great story arc(s), with appropriate large format, high-quality paper, hardback, with additional intros, transitional pieces, and other goodies. Steep price, but well worth it. You don't get much better than this with any graphic novel. So, why not a '5'? Well, its my review, so I get to have my own idiosyncratic quibble - I guess I'm old school, but I just don't like the crisp, clean digital artwork. Notwithstanding all the wonderful things one can do with computers nowadays, I still prefer hands-on coloring. To each his own ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Queen & Country Definitive Edition 04
by
Greg Rucka
MAA
, February 04, 2010
One of best graphic novel series, and my personal favorite, and this edition is no exception. Collection of 3 previously published issues, with extended interviews and glossary at end. The 'definitive edition' is indeed worth the packaging. I've read, and re-read, various versions (the original issues, this edition), and keep coming back. Note - this includes one issue not written by Rucka, but that doesn't detract from quality. So, what keeps this from being a '5'? For me, collecting these 3 into one larger edition actually has a drawback -- each has a different focus, a different time period, a different setting, and a different artist. Without some intro, or connecting transitions, I was a bit jarred moving from one to the next -- and I've read them before! The interviews & glossary at the end help a bit, but that was after the fact. Each issue/story-arc stands on its own, which has been the beauty of the entire series, but when put together, I was left wanting something more by way of setup or framing. Nonetheless, highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The Visitor (Full Screen)
by
Richard Jenkins
MAA
, February 02, 2010
Thought-provoking sleeper -- Our lead actor portrays our protagonist as a man awakening from a long slumber - a modern-day Rip Van Winkle. Thoroughly believable, even as it presents initially dream-like situations that come to make sense. The plot twists & turns keep interest, as the musical score engages you on another level. Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Prisoner of the Mountains
by
Sergei, Jr. Bodrov
MAA
, January 26, 2010
Better than most 'antiwar' films. Highly recommended. Only a few drawbacks keep me from rating this a '5'. Tremendous story, great acting, terrific character portraits, made me feel like I was there, living & breathing these moments. Beautiful setting, great pacing, attention to detail -- what's not to like? Well, I almost turned it off after the first few minutes, and it wasn't until the end of the first real action scene that I got into the movie -- and very glad I did. For me, the drunken soldier scene undid me -- seemed overdone, hammy, perhaps campy. And the drunken soldier then engages in what, to me, also seemed like overdone 'acting' in the action scene. Perhaps there is a cultural barrier here -- there are a few places where there must be some cultural referent or symbolism, because I've seen similar scenes in other Russian flicks. All in all, though, one of best war films depicting wars effect on the local populace, and the human interactions that are seldom shown onscreen.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Beaufort
by
MAA
, January 25, 2010
A prayer to warriors. Well done, realistic depiction of young soldiers guarding an aging outpost. For the most part, this story could be set at any time in military history -- it happens to be shot in Lebanon regarding the Israeli incursion from 1982, to retirement in 2000. The 18 year term means that the teenage soldiers were mere infants when it was taken. Slow paced character studies, interspersed with intense action sequences, reflects the reality of much war -- long periods of boredom punctuated with short bursts of terror. Although many see this an an 'antiwar' film, I see it more as just a war film. It does focus on the futility of war -- but that is like saying a film of failure in adventure is an 'anti-adventure' story. Well worth seeing -- as is the 'filming of' documentary.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Risk
by
Dick Francis
MAA
, January 18, 2010
One of the best! I've read most of the author's mysteries, and certain elements follow the author's standard plot & character development. But this one had me twisting & turning more than most -- and kept me engaged the entire time. In addition to featuring a jockey protagonist, and a horse race here & there, we are treated to sailing, kidnapping, accounting, romance, and more. Anyone who can make accounting an exciting profession gets thumbs up here! And exciting it is, in one of the author's best - highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Charley's War: Blue's Story
by
Pat Mills
MAA
, December 25, 2009
This whole series is superior -- large format & great commentary help put this into the top of the graphic novel pantheon -- and I'd rate them all '5' star. Excellent portrayal of the gritty & grim WWI trench warfare, where soldiers often had more to fear from their officers than with the ostensible 'enemy.' Not for the faint of heart -- although there isn't any gratuitous blood & guts -- this is a black & white straightforward account with great line art.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
A Christmas Story: Special Edition
by
Bob Clark
MAA
, December 25, 2009
One of the trio of my favorite movie Christmas Stories -- and there is a reason it is considered a classic. Wonderful performances by all, with a by-turns funny & sad telling of one Christmas in the life of an American post-WWII family. Even if you didn't live thru it, anyone should be able to relate to the family & school dynamics, with many classic parent-to-child lines - 'You'll shoot your eyes out!' The special edition includes a number of documentary & other story shorts -- and for the 'completist' like me, I purchased in addition to the VHS we already had -- DVD gives better rendering (and now on my Blu Ray, even better). Enjoy!
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 3 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Usagi Yojimbo 23 Bridge Of Tears
by
Stan Sakai
MAA
, December 25, 2009
Stan Sakai's Usagi simply is one of the best comic book/graphic novel series ever written & drawn, and this volume is one of the best. Shows a darker side to the life of a ronin (wandering samurai), and the death & grief that follow. As a bonus, includes an extended tongue-in-cheek tribute to Stan on his '100th' Dark Horse volume, with guest writers & artists giving you an insight into the inner workings of the biz. Can't recommend it highly enough -- and you can start here if you haven't been introduced to this world before.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(0 of 1 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Oh My Goddess Colors
by
Kosuke Fujishima
MAA
, December 25, 2009
Must have! for OMG fans - and an excellent place to start if you are new to Manga. Large format quality paper allows more detail than usual small, cheap reprints -- and most of it in gorgeous color. Not only a great starter for those new to OMG, but new to manga in general. The annotations give context, the glossary further insight, and the 'rules' a better understanding of the 'logic' of manga -- Japanese, not American. The only quibbles are with the story outlines given after the colored manga -- a bit too cute for me -- and call me retrograde, but I preferred the earlier left-to-right 'American' transliterations of Studio Proteus/Toren Smith. Highly recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Patton (Blu-ray)
by
MAA
, December 20, 2009
One of my favorite films of all time - and Blu Ray does indeed enhance viewing. Having read much more about Patton now, coming back to the film was a chance to see how authentic it was -- for the storyline, it was. George C. Scott earns his Oscar here. However, I was a bit disappointed to note more modern equipment being used, especially the tanks. Yes ... it was getting more difficult to get authentic equipment, but for a film of this scope, I was expecting more. Funny, I don't recall feelling that way when this first came out on the big screen, but I noticed it enough this time around that it was a bit distracting. For most folks, they won't know the difference, and it won't detract from this great film -- but for the nitpicks, this is a pretty big nit. Worth seeing again notwithstanding.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Up (Widescreen)
by
Pixar
MAA
, December 20, 2009
Yet another hit from Pixar! Plenty of reasons to see this on DVD -- good character development, nice longer pauses for effect, wonder CGI/animation, good story ... that has us coming back for more. And yet ... with all the buildup given this for theatres, I was expecting a '5' star film. Perhaps its that old bugaboo - expectations - but for me, this merits more a '4.'
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Heaven Knows MR. Allison
by
MAA
, December 20, 2009
Surprizingly good '50s 'war' film - Mitchum and Kerr give understated yet powerful performances in wonderful character studies in the midst of WWII. Although not explicit, and not the thrust of this film, there are more nuanced views of war to ponder for any adult. If you are more interested in action - this film has some great Pacific War island-hopping moments, including air, land, and sea (Air Force, Army, and Marines/Navy), and big explosions. Authentic period WWII touches (the rubber raft, web belts, uniforms, etc.) to ground this in reality. And a surprizing end -- especially considering the formula endings I see often nowadays. Goes to show you that each generation has had its share of good, solid, well-acted, stories captured on film. I'm ready to see this again already.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
The EC Archives: Two-Fisted Tales Volume 1
by
Al Feldstein
MAA
, December 20, 2009
I finished the Haunted Tank first, and this suffers by comparison. Story-telling is sometimes a stretch, but I much prefer the artwork in Haunted Tank. Altho' many of the big names show up here, for my money, they just don't hold a candle -- uneven from my perspective. Still, this has some historic value, and the large format color is gorgeous.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Showcase Presents the Haunted Tank Volume Two
by
Russ Heath
MAA
, December 20, 2009
Great art! Most realistic depictions of tank combat in graphic form - from the showcased Stuart, to the more ubiquitous WWII Sherman, Patton, Tiger, Panther, and other Panzers. Even the uniforms and small arms are authentically portrayed. I had to do some research, but the light Stuart, when upgraded to the armor-piercing ammo later in the war, could indeed knock off a Tiger -- but it would have to be at point blank range and hit the weakest chink! Literary license allowed for the more extreme pushes of the envelope, including the episodic continuity issues (the ersatz tank at the end seems to switch rollers & treads, and altho' dismantled in one episode, comes back again ... ). If you like your war comics realistic, this is one to get.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Sherman: Lessons in Leadership
by
Steven E. Woodworth
MAA
, December 10, 2009
Short, well-written military biography. Quick and easy to read, with enough detail and analysis to give me a better feel for the subject without bogging down. What keeps this from being 'very good' (5) is a tendency towards hagiography: the primary source reliance is on Sherman's own memoirs. This author is so intent on correcting what he perceives as myths about Sherman, that I felt he might be leaving out significant points of view. Nevertheless, a good read, and recommended for most readers, including youth.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Some New Kind Of Slaughter
by
Marvin Mann
MAA
, November 30, 2009
This book held a lot of promise ... and I was disappointed at its execution. The premise - exploring flood stories (myths) - enticed me. A quick glance enjoyed the graphic art. But, for me, things never did come together & gel. A number of parallels were made between and among the various flood stories across time, but I was more confused than enlightened. Nice try - but no cigar from me. Thought provoking, but also thought muddling. Could - and should - have been much better.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Drifting Life
by
Yoshihiro Tatsumi
MAA
, November 24, 2009
Highly recommended. Masterful account of postwar Japan and the development of manga. The title is slightly misleading - transliterations often don't come across quite the same as in the original language. Tatsumi doesn't 'drift' so much as 'go with the flow' ... This translation makes it much easier for those not intimately familiar with manga to access and understand this important contribution to world literature. Stands with the best Japanese to English translations, like Studio Proteus with Dark Horse in the 90s -- reads left to right/front to back, the dialogue makes perfect sense in American English, many of the Japanese character signs and sound effects are translated, and the work is published on better quality paper in larger format (Oh My Goddess! and Gunsmith Cats are but 2 examples - compare the 90s editions with some more recent). Perhaps I am 'old school', but I find this production much, much better than most current 'manga' - which simply takes the flipped right-to-left pages in Japanese, gives a cursory translation, and prints on small, lower quality paper. The few drawbacks here are mere quibbles beside the monumental effort put into this work: some of the further translations of 'minor' panel material listed at the very end could - & should - have been given in or near the panel, especially the extended translations of 2 key pieces of correspondence - the gekiga manifesto, and the plea regarding collective action. And the length does present a challenge, but I found it wonderful to put it down from time to time, and reflect upon the development of the characters, and the backdrop of history. As I've gotten older, I rarely read more than 100 pages of anything -- if they haven't come to the point, I move on to the next book. This was a major exception -- the 'point' was the slowly developing, unfolding, of a young man, and a nation rising from the ashes. The length is necessary to convey the breadth & depth of this process in the fullness of time. Well worth pondering ...
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(2 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Local
by
Brian Wood
MAA
, November 02, 2009
Story starts in Portland Oregon - so 'locals' can get into it earlier. Next chapter - another North American city - another experience - another entree for another set of 'locals'. Our protagonist images various scenarios as she makes her next move, often from the frying pan into the fire. As the journey takes some bizarre twists & turns, we hope - we pray, that Megan will actually learn something & do it differently next time. By the middle of the 12 chapters (and 12 years), I was about ready to abandon hope, and chuck the book. Yet another series of down & out drug & alcohol abusers & abused -- don't 'comic' book artists have anything else to explore? But something drew me back, and I'm glad I persevered. Finally, a 'dark' comic that has something to say - other than dystopia. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Asterios Polyp
by
David Mazzucchelli
MAA
, November 01, 2009
What a 'graphic novel' ought to be -- a story well told, with each picture worth a thousand words ... Entices & seduces you while meandering, wandering, thru philosophy, art, and the quantum universe, with 'real' americans & imagined. Pokes & prods verities of academe, and this modern world. Recommended.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(3 of 5 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment
Its A Good Life If You Dont Weaken
by
Seth
MAA
, October 04, 2009
Good read, in a similar vein to such works as American Splendor and Blankets - other award-winning graphic novels. More of a novella -- shorter, but definitely not sweeter -- in the slice-of-life auto-biographical memoirs and musings of cartoonist artists. Deadpan delivery matches the somber tones of the artwork.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Positive Power Of Negative Thinking Usin
by
Julie K Norem
MAA
, October 04, 2009
Very well written with enough here to satisfy a basic reader, and kindle the curious to learn more. Short, sweet, and to the point. Addresses and dispenses with many myths about 'negativity' (defensive pessimism) and 'positive' psychology (strategic optimism), based on her own and others' extensive research on the different ways we can and do approach situations, and the attendant advantages and disadvantages. For example, she mentions other research suggesting that the most 'confident' are sometimes the least competent. Open-ended exploration of the strengths and weaknesses of each approach, and the potential pitfalls of extreme positivity or negativity (e.g., denial, arrogance, narcissism, depression, self-defeating behavior). I positively recommend this!
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
report this comment
Look Me in the Eye My Life with Aspergers
by
John Elder Robison
MAA
, July 27, 2009
Great read! Straightforward storytelling in concrete language, demonstrating unexpected facility illustrating the daily, lifelong challenges that those on the Asperger/autism spectrum confront. More importantly, showing that insight into the differences, and advantages, of being on that spectrum, can lead to a happier, more fulfilling, life. A good book for anyone (everyone?) who has felt 'different' and misunderstood; and for those who interact with them. Oh, heck, I recommend it to everyone -- whether you have experienced any of this or not, it is a great window into appreciating differences.
Was this comment helpful? |
Yes
|
No
(1 of 2 readers found this comment helpful)
report this comment