INTRODUCTION
THE GREAT AMERICAN AUGIE
by Christopher Hitchens
Augie March stands on the Chicago lake-shore at dawn on a New Years Day in the 1930s:
I drank coffee and looked out into the brilliant first morning of the year. There was a Greek church in the next street of which the onion dome stood in the snow-polished and purified blue, cross and crown together, the united powers of earth and heaven, snow in all the clefts, a snow like the sand of sugar. I passed over the church too and rested only on the great profound blue. The days have not changed, though the times have. The sailors who first saw America, that sweet sight, where the belly of the ocean had brought them, didnt see more beautiful color than this.
Nick Carraway stands on the Long Island shoreline at the close of The Great Gatsby:
And as the moon rose higher the inessential houses began to melt away until gradually I became aware of the old island here that flowered once for Dutch sailors eyesa fresh green breast of the new world...the trees that had made way for Gatsbys house had once pandered in whispers to the last and greatest of all human dreams; for a transitory enchanted moment man must have held his breath in the presence of this continent...face to face for the last time in history with something commensurate to his capacity for wonder.
One man is reflecting at days end, and one at days beginning. Both have just been put through it by flawed and wretched humanityCarraway has been to several funerals and Augie has had a close shave while helping a girl who isnt his girlfriend to survive an illegal abortion. (I pause to note that one is a belly man, while the other favors the breast.) Both draw strength from the idea of America. But Carraway derives consolation, while it might be truer to say that Augie finds inspiration. Reflecting on Gatsbys futile questhis dreamCarraway decides that: He did not know that it was already behind him, somewhere back in that vast obscurity beyond the city, where the dark fields of the republic rolled on under the night. Augie doesnt take much stock in dreams, and he is about to venture on to those very fields.
I do not set myself up as a member of the jury in the Great American Novel contest, if only because Id prefer to see the white whale evade capture for a while longer. Its more interesting that way. However, we do belong to a ranking species, and theres no denying that this contest is a real one. The great advantage that Augie March possesses over Gatsby lies in its scope and its optimism and, I would venture, in its principles. Or its principlein the opening pages Augie states it clearly and never loses sight of it:
What did Danton lose his head for, or why was there a Napoleon, if it wasnt to make a nobility of us all? And this universal eligibility to be noble, taught everywhere, was what gave Simon airs of honor.
Simon is Augies older brother, but this universal eligibility to be noble (eligibility connotes being elected as well as being chosen) is as potent a statement of the American dream as has ever been uttered. Simon doesnt make it; thats not the point. Augie doesnt exactly make it either; well, its an ideal not a promise. He decides to match himself against the continent, seeking no ones permission and deferring to no idea of limitation. His making, like his omnivorous education, will be his own.
This was the first time in American literature that an immigrant would act and think like a rightful Discoverer, or a pioneer. The paradox of the American immigrant experience had hitherto been exactly that so many immigrants came to the New World not in order to spread their wings but to adapt, to conform, to fit in. When we are first introduced to Augie he is in cramped conditions; a poor Jewish family semi-stifled by its own warmth and replete with dreads about the wider world. Our hero doesnt know any better than this, and yet he does know. I am an American, Chicago born, he proclaims in the very first line of his narrative. Its important to understand what this assertion meant when it was made, both to Bellow himself and to the audiences he had in mind.
Barely a half-century before The Adventures of Augie March was published, Henry James had returned to New York from Europe and found its new character unsettling in the extreme. In The American Scene, published in 1907, he registered the revulsion he felt at having to share the sanctity of his American consciousness, the intimacy of his American patriotism, with the inconceivable alien (my italics). On the Lower East Side he discerned the hard glitter of Israel. In the Café Royale, a locus of Yiddish-speaking authors and performers, he found himself in one of the torture rooms of the living idiom. And he asked himself: Who can ever tell, in any conditions, what the genius of Israel may, or may not, really be up to? The Master was by no means alone in expressing sentiments and sensitivities of this kind. With Augie March, and its bold initial annexation of the brave name of American, his descendants got the answer to the question about what the genius was up to.
Saul Bellow was bornand named Solomonin 1915, across the border in Lachine, Quebec. (Lachine itself was named by a Columbus-minded French military officer who was sent to look for China and declared hed found it.) Bellows parents smuggled him across the Great Lakes as an infant, and he did not discover that he was an illegal immigrant until he signed up for the United States armed forces in the Second World War. The authorities sent him back to Canada and compelled him to reapplykept him hanging about, in other words. Among other things, Augie March is a farewell to the age of Bellows own uncertainty, an adieu to the self of his two earlier novels, Dangling Man (1944) and The Victim (1947).
Affirmatively, almost defiantly American, the novel is by no means a paean to assimilation and amnesia. As a youth, Bellow composed and performed a stand-up spoof of The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock in Yiddish, and he has always remained acutely aware of his Russian roots. He helped Irving Howe and Partisan Review in the first translations of his future fellow- Nobelist Isaac Bashevis Singer. One triumph of Augie March is that it takes Yiddishkeit out of the torture rooms and out of the ghetto, and helps make it an indissoluble and inseparable element in the great American tongue. Those of us who inherit Lenny Bruce, Walter Matthau, Woody Allen, and Philip Roth as part of our vernacular birthright take for granted this linguistic faculty and facility. But it was not a birthright in 1953.
Only in the preceding year, for one thing, had Bellows peers and cothinkers and kibitzers got around to producing the famous Partisan Review symposium Our Country and Our Culture. In those pages, the veterans of the cultural combat of the 1930smost but not all of them Jewishhad asked if perhaps the time had not come to rewrite their project of permanent opposition. There were demurrals and reservations, but on the whole the formerly alienated began to speak as lawfully adopted sons and daughters of the United States. The exceptions, those who distrusted what they saw as a coming age of conformism, included Irving Howe and Delmore Schwartz. But when Augie astonished the critics by showing that an egghead novel could be a literary and a commercial success, Schwartz was won over. His review of it opened with the simple declaration that Saul Bellows new novel is a new kind of book. He compared it favorably with the grandest efforts of Mark Twain and John Dos Passos. And he was struck at once by the essential matter, which is the language and the style:
Augie March rises from the streets of the modern city to encounter the reality of experience with an attitude of satirical acceptance, ironic affirmation, the comic transcendence of affirmation and rejection.
Indeed, he made the immigrant vengeance on the old guard quite explicit:
For the first time in fiction Americas social mobility has been transformed into a spiritual energy which is not doomed to flight, renunciation, exile, denunciation, the agonised hyper-intelligence of Henry James, or the hysterical cheering of Walter Whitman.
Schwartz, who would be the inspiration for the protagonist of Bellows Humboldts Gift (Let me in! Im a poet! I have a big cock!), admired Augie the character for the very quality that some reviewers distrusted: his unreadiness to be committed or, as Augie puts it, recruited. Among the hostile reviewers was Norman Podhoretz, who, as recently as the year 2000, revisited the squabble andalmost incredibly but probably unconsciouslyechoed Henry Jamess anti-Jewishness in accusing Bellow of twisting and torturing the language!
If Ive succeeded at all in establishing this context, I hope Ive helped explain why it is that Augie March still constitutes a template for modern American literature. Just as it formed and altered the Jewish and the Anglo-Saxon attitudes of its timeso it still waits for readers and critics and helps them to measure their own perspective on America. (This pilot-light effect can be seen in the work of Martin Amis, who in 1987 wrote that for all its marvels, Augie March, like Henderson the Rain King, often resembles a lecture on destiny fed through a thesaurus of low-life patois. In 1995, he began an essay as follows: The Adventures of Augie March is the Great American Novel. Search no further. All the trails went cold forty-two years ago. The quest did what quests very rarely do; it ended. Not unrelatedly, perhaps, but in sharp reverse, Kingsley Amis greeted the original publication by telling the readers of the Spectator of Bellows gaiety and good humour, his fizzing dialogue, his vitality. Two decades later he wrote: Bellow is a Ukrainian-Canadian, I believe. It is painful to watch him trying to pick his way between the unidiomatic on the one hand and the affected on the other. Twenty years further on he had sunk into the belief that everyone in America was either a Jew or a hick.)
Augie himself is little better than the by-blow of a traveling man. He informs us early on that the expression various jobs is the Rosetta Stone of his life. But the awareness of eligibility is in him, and hell fight his corner for it and never be a hick. What I guess about you, says one of his palsguessing correctlyis that you have a nobility syndrome. You cant adjust to the reality situation....You want to accept. But how do you know what youre accepting? You have to be nuts to take it come one come all....You should accept the data of experience. To which Augie replies, more confidently perhaps than he feels, It can never be right to offer to die, and if thats what the data of experience tell you, then you must get along without them.
Even while he is still stranded at home in Chicago, knowing somehow that there must be more to life and America, Augie invests his banal surroundings with a halo of the numinous and the heroic. For a start, he transfigures the cliché of the Jewish mother:
[Mama] occupied a place, I suppose, among women conquered by a superior force of love, like those women whom Zeus got the better of in animal form and who next had to take cover from his furious wife. Not that I can see my big, gentle, dilapidated, scrubbing, and lugging mother as a fugitive of immense beauty from such classy wrath.
And then there is old Einhorn, the lamed and misshapen local organizer and fixer and memoirist, whom Augie (Im not kidding when I enter Einhorn in this eminent list) ranks with Caesar, Machiavelli, Ulysses, and Croesus. Its Einhorn who so memorably lectures Augie after he has a narrow squeak with a two-bit, no-account piece of larceny that could have turned nasty:
That was what you let yourself in for. Yes, thats right, Augie, a dead cop or two. You know what cop-killers get, from the station onwardtheir faces beaten off, their hands smashed, and worse; and that would be your start in life....But wait. All of a sudden I catch on to something about you. Youve got opposition in you. You dont slide through everything. You just make it look so.
Einhorn then takes the role of Augies missing father, releasing in his listener a spurt of love that hes too wised-up to acknowledge at the time:
Dont be a sap, Augie, and fall into the first trap life digs for you. Young fellows brought up in bad luck, like you, are naturals to keep the jails filledthe reformatories, all the institutions. What the state orders bread and beans long in advance for. It knows theres an element that can be depended on to come behind bars to eat it....Its practically determined. And if youre going to let it be determined for you too, youre a sucker. Just whats predicted. Those sad and tragic things are waiting to take you inthe clinks and clinics and soup lines know whos the natural to be beat up and squashed, made old, pooped, farted away, no-purposed away. If it should happen to you, whod be surprised? Youre a setup for it.
Then he added, But I think Id be surprised.
Before Einhorn is through with his homily, he adds one more thing. Im not a lowlife when I think, and really think, says the poolroom king and genius swindler. In the end you cant save your soul and life by thought. But if you think, the least of the consolation prizes is the world.
I judge this as a hinge moment in a novel that sometimes has difficulty with its dramatic unities. Einhorn summons the shades of the prison house for the growing boy, and evokes for us the omnipresence of violence, injustice and stupidity. He senses the lower depths of the underclass, while we sense in him what we feel in reading Thomas Grays Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard: the unrealized potential of a great man who might have been. He, too, has felt the eligibility. And he has an untrained instinct for the examined life. Whatever this isand its demotic American English, all rightits not lowlife patois.
So when Augie breaks free and sets out, he is no Candide or Copperfield. And this novel is no Horatio Alger tale. Many of Augies ground-down relatives do end up in institutions, all of them achingly well-drawn and onethe home for Augies retarded baby brother poignantly so. Bellows Chicago is not vastly different from The Jungle of Upton Sinclair. Even in the peace and prosperity of the 1950s, Bellow was able to recall the bitterness of want and exploitation, the reek of the hobos met on stolen train rides, the sharpness of class warfare, the acuteness of ethnic differences among poor whites in the days before all nonblacks were absurdly classified as Caucasian. (One of Simons coal-yard drivers has a dread of running over a kid in a Bohunk neighborhoodexactly the sort of confrontation nightmare that is now reserved for Chicagos black South Side.)
Of all the odd jobs that Augie takes (and these include being a butler as well as a shoe salesman, a paint seller as well as a literary looker-upper), the three best-described are those that obliquely or directly involve his oppositionism. As a dog groomer for the upper classes, he feels a sense of wasteful absurdity in the work; as a contract book-stealer, he increases his knowledge of the classics and also his acquaintance with Marxist intellectuals; as a union organizer for the CIO, he is brushed by the grandeur of the American labor movement, which briefly did unite all trades and ethnicities in a collective demand for justice. This episode of mobilization and jacquerie calls on all of Bellows power of taxonomy and onomatopoeia:
There were Greek and Negro chambermaids from all the hotels, porters, doormen, checkroom attendants, waitresses....All kinds were coming. The humanity of the under- galleries of pipes, storage, and coal made an appearance, maintenance men, short-order grovelers....And then old snowbirds and white hound-looking faces, guys with Wobbly cards from an earlier time, old Bohunk women with letters explaining what was wanted, and all varieties of assaulted kissers, infirmity, drunkenness, dazedness, innocence, limping, crawling, insanity, prejudice, and from downright leprosy the whole way again to the most vigorous straight-backed beauty. So if this collection of people has nothing in common with what would have brought up the back of a Xerxes army or a Constantines, new things have been formed; but what struck me in them was a feeling of antiquity and thick crust.
Later, when adrift in Mexico, Augie meets that incarnation of opposition Leon Trotsky himself:
I was excited by this famous figure, and I believe what it was about him that stirred me up was the instant impression he gaveno matter about the old heap he rode in or the peculiarity of his retinueof navigation by the great stars, of the highest considerations, of being fit to speak the most important human words and universal terms. When you are as reduced to a different kind of navigation from this high starry kind as I was and are only sculling on the shallow bay, crawling from one clam-rake to the next, its stirring to have a glimpse of deep-water greatness.
(Bellow himself had been to Mexico in order to try to see Trotsky; he arrived the day after the old mans assassination and viewed the body with blood still in its white hair. In an early draft of the novel, Augie signs up to work for the exiled heretic.)
Opposition is, however, only one of Augies internal compasses. The other, operating both more and less predictably, is love and sex. To be blunt, young Mr. March is led around by his cock. He prefers earthy and honest expressions for this preoccupation, mentioning at one point stupendous quiff and at another a girl whose virtue was that she made no bones about what they were together for. Occasionally, he can be rhapsodic (the paramour of Guillaume the dog trainer is a great work of ripple-assed luxury with an immense mozzarella bust). And he can also be tender. There are few sweeter girls in fiction than Sophie Geratis, the staunch little Greek union militant (She had a set of hard-worked hands and she lived with her beauty on rough terms. I couldnt for even a minute pretend that I didnt go for her). But he doesnt feel the thunderbolt until he meets Thea Fenchel.
Thea has an eagle named Caligula, and she wants Augie to help her man the eagle and train it to smash full-grown iguanas in Mexico. He falls in with the plan because hes fallen completely for the woman. He falls so completely for the woman becausethis is his weaknessshe is so utterly sold on him. The magnificence of the bird he can appreciate; the project of making it into a trained hunter gives him a chill. And the lordly avian Caligula turns out to be, of all things (and in Theas contemptuous word), chicken. It will not fight Stone Age lizards, and it will not obey. Once she sees that Augie doesnt mind thisindeed, secretly approves itTheas respect for Augie is gone. Not all reviewers admire this long and necessary section of the novel, and many have puzzled over the significance of the bird. (Is an eagle symbolically American? Not if its called Caligula its not. Not if its chicken its not.) But I think it is essential as it shows that Augie is compelled to admire anything, especially something so noble, that will not permit itself to be domesticated. The price is high. He suffers appalling torment at the loss of Thea; lovesickness and sexual jealousy have seldom been more flayingly depicted. But the wrench does get him back to Chicago, that somber city, to take stock and begin again.
Love, Poverty, and War, they say, are the essential elements in the shaping of a man, as of a bildungsroman. And when war deposes the Depression as the great disciplinarian of the lower orders, Augie signs up for the navy right away, thinking the while, What use was war without also love? (This, by the way, may be the most masculine sentence ever penned.) He lucks out with Stella. His brief and near-terminal combat experience gives him his best opportunity yet to release the animal ridens within himself; a man of various jobs is never going to be more at home than in the lower deck of a ship, and he makes comedy out of the confidences of his messmates. Here again, Bellows ear is unerring:
You think I maybe have an inferiority complex, do you think? one of them asked me. . . . I passed out advice in moderate amounts; nobody is perfect. I advocated love, especially.
After a harrowing experience in an open boat when his ship is torpedoed (They found one reason after another to detain me at the hospital, Augie laconically phrases it), he hopes at wars end for a safe and tranquil harbor. But how true it is that: Brother! You never are through, you just think you are! For a very brief while he imagines being a sort of Catcher in the Rye, running a foster home where his broken-up family could also shelter. But life isnt through with him yet, and he has to live up to the great sentence on the novels opening page: Everybody knows there is no fineness or accuracy of suppression; if you hold down one thing you hold down the adjoining. To hold down his own curiosity would be to betray his profoundest instinct. And thus we find him sardonically installed at a table in a European café at the novels close, working as a middleman for an Armenian entrepreneur and declaring that I was an American, Chicago born, and all these other events and notions. (Bellow, incidentally, boasts that not one word of Augie March was written in Chicago; he took himself off to Positano, Rome, Paris, and London. There is nothing provincial about his Americanism.)
If we reflect along with Augie, we look back at a host of brilliantly realized minor characters in the novel, warranting comparison with Dickens and with that remarkable boy on the Mississippi who also had The Adventures of in his title. One shouldnt play favorites perhaps, but Guillaume, the fancy dog trainer who relies too much on the hypodermic when dealing with recalcitrant pooches (Thees jag-off is goin to get it), will always be mine. And Jimmy, the Struldbrug-like cop in the bowels of that Detroit precinct, who has everyones face and rap sheet in his head . . .
The two key words that encapsulate the ambitions of Bellows novel are democratic and cosmopolitan. Not entirely by coincidence, these are the two great stand-or-fall hopes of America. The two qualities that carry Augie through are his capacity for love and his capacity for irony. These, together with reason, are the great stand-or-fall hopes of humanity. The Metaphysical poets used the evocative word America as their term for the new and the hopeful, even addressing lovers by that name. Augie March concludes, more cannily, by seeing the unfunny side of the funny side:
Or is the laugh at natureincluding eternitythat it thinks it can win over us and the power of hope? Nah, nah! I think. It never will. But that probably is the joke, on one or the other, and laughing is an enigma that includes both. Look at me, going everywhere! Why, I am a sort of Columbus of those near-at-hand and believe you can come to them in this immediate terra incognita that spreads out in every gaze. I may well be a flop at this line of endeavor. Columbus too thought he was a flop, probably, when they sent him back in chains. Which didnt prove there was no America.