Synopses & Reviews
Consumers have taken the lead in rejecting the biotech industry's determination to foist GMOs on an unsuspecting and unconsulted public. This book gives a voice for the first time to farmers. They are the people being pressured by giant corporations to grow genetically engineered crops. What are the possible downsides for them, particularly for those hundreds of millions of farmers living in the developing countries? This important book is a lucid explanation of what is happening.
Review
“This book...is very timely in informing the key actors. The authors are particularly to be congratulated for putting farmers first in this debate and providing a clear explanation of the several terms and phrases being used by media policy makers and scientists.” —Tewolde Berhan Gebre Egziabher, spokesperson for the “Like Minded Group” in the negotiations of the Cartagena Protocol on Safety in Biotechnology
“[This book] embraces the central contributions of southern farmers to the integrity of our food and the diversity of world agriculture.” —Brian Tokar, editor of Redesigning Life?: The Worldwide Challenge to Genetic Engineering
Synopsis
Farmers around the world are being pressured by half a dozen giant corporations to grow genetically engineered crops. What are the possible downsides for them, particularly for those hundreds of millions of farmers living in developing countries? On their environment? On their health? On their independence? On their traditional export crops? On their access to the marketplaces of their own countries? This important book comes out of a dialogue between farmers' representatives and experts. The result is a clear statement of principles and urgently needed measures which should guide governments and communities in bringing this profit-motivated deployment of scientific power under democratic control.
"
About the Author
Robert Ali Brac De La Perrière is an international consultant with a doctorate in plant breeding. Franck Seuret is a journalist who specializes in rural development, economic issues in developing countries and biotechnology.
Table of Contents
About the Authors
Acknowledgements
Abbreviations
Introduction
The seed savers
Informing the communities of the South
The Rishikesh Declaration
1. Seeds Belong to Farmers: The Downside of GM Seeds for Agriculture in the South
Long years of breeding work by farmers
The privatisation of life
Further economic dependence
Programmed elimination of small farmers
From farmer to producer of molecules
Ecological threats in countries of the South
Cocoa in wheat?
Outcry about Biopiracy
2. Terminator, Out!: Farmers’ Autonomy Jeopardised by Sterile Seeds
Terminator: the sterilisation of living organisms
Nothing in it for farmers
A technology that is not devoid of risks
No mercy for Terminator
Is the worst yet to come?
The Apomixis Gene: an Underrated Risk
3. The Precautionary Principle: The Ecological and Health Risks at Stake
Lack of adequate foresight
A commercial success
Gene flow: a major environmental risk
Increasingly resistant insects
Biodiversity in peril
Increased impact on agrarian systems in the South
The dangers for humankind
A plea for the precautionary principle
4. Greater Transparency: The Politics of GMO Secrecy
A false solution to the problem of hunger
Sustainable development or a second Green Revolution?
Intensifying production at the cost of biodiversity
Lack of transparency
The public left out of the equation
Mobilising farmers in developing countries
The urgent need for accountability
5. About Ethics: Tampering with the Foundations of Life
Transgression of the laws of nature
Science serving profit
Seizing the living
Imbalance in North-South relations
Ethics committees under pressure
Outcry from the four corners of the earth
Genes of the Mind and Genes of the Heart
6. Moratorium on Commercialisation: Setting the Rules
The indispensable moratorium
Beyond the moratorium
7. The Battle over Intellectual Property Rights: Living Matter Turned into Private Property
In the beginning was the patent
Article 27 of the WTO Agreement on the Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights
More patents = less innovation?
Patents or sui generis?
What is a Good Sui Generis Sysem?
UPOV a deceptive alternative to patents
UPOV is no suitable for countries of the South
The Convention on Biological Diversity: a major step forward
An imperfect tool
Now or never
An Emergency Exit
The one and only sui generis
Sui Generis: the Thai Approach
Conclusion: Rishikesh at the Crossroads
Appendices
1. How to Get More Information
2. Further Reading List
3. Participants, Rishikesh, 5-10 December 1998
4. Report on the Workshop on Genetically Modified Organisms and the Rights of the Rural Community, Saharanpur, 1999
Index