Synopses & Reviews
Child Protection Systems is a comparative study of the social policies and professional practices that frame societal responses to the problems of child maltreatment in ten countries: USA, Canada, England, Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Belgium, the Netherlands, Germany and Norway. Focusing on the developments in policy and practice since the mid-1990s, this volume provides a detailed, up-to-date analysis of the similarities and differences in how child protection systems operate and their outcomes. The findings highlight the changing criteria that define child maltreatment, trends in out-of-home placement, professional responses to allegations of maltreatment, and the level of state responsibility for child and family welfare, providing an in-depth understanding of the different ways modern welfare states assume the sensitive responsibility of balancing children's rights and parents' rights.
The changing character of child protection systems worldwide reflects dramatic and rapid organizational, policy, and legislative changes; the expansion of child welfare systems; the rise of formal procedures and evidence-based initiatives; the increased challenges posed by race and ethnicity; and the extent to which countries adopt either a child protection or a family service approach to child abuse. Each chapter analyzes these developments and the directions in which they are heading, such as movements toward privatization and devolution of child welfare service delivery. Against this backdrop, a third approach begins to emerge-a child-focused orientation-that aims to promote and improve children's development and well-being.
A vital book for understanding contemporary trends and policy issues in the design of child protection systems, this will be must reading for comparative scholars of child welfare, family policy, and the welfare state.
Review
"The seismic change in child protection systems both in the United States and around the world are clearly illustrated and analyzed in this wonderful book. The creative, disruptive approaches toward child protection adopted by various countries around the world lead to new and promising orientations toward preserving the welfare and future of children. This is the most important contribution toward international understanding of child protection currently available." -- Duncan Lindsey, Professor of Social Welfare, University of California, Los Angeles and Editor-in-Chief, Children and Youth Services Review
"This is a superb contribution to the understanding of the evolution of child protection in ten European and Anglo-American countries. It is an essential text for policy makers and practitioners, as it clearly delineates and compares central changes in approaches and guiding assumptions, and the compelling ways in which states fashion their interventions as a response to the competing claims and philosophies of child protection, family service, and child focus approaches. Outstanding, well written, and destined to become a benchmark for the field as a whole." -- Jim Torczyner, Professor of Social Work and Founder/Director, Montreal Consortium for Human Rights Advocacy Training, McGill University
"This timely volume provides an illuminating look at how child welfare systems operate in ten countries, including several representatives each from the Anglo-American, Continental European, and Nordic groups. Written by country experts, the chapters document the approaches these disparate countries have taken to address the challenge of protecting children while also supporting families. The results not only shed light on different program models and approaches but also offer some larger lessons as to what advanced societies can and should do to promote the well-being of their most vulnerable children." -- Jane Waldfogel, Professor of Social Work and Public Affairs, Columbia University School of Social Work
"Child Protection Systems is a well-written, thought-provoking work that updates Combatting Child Abuse: International Perspectives and Trends... This book is an excellent tool for graduate students and professionals to compare and contrast child protection systems, how those systems reflect a society's history and cultural thinking, and how systems address the world-wide problem of child abuse and neglect." -- Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare
"This volume succeeds on multiple levels. First, it makes a strong and coherent
case for the desirability of cross-national perspectives in child welfare policy and
practices.... Second, this slim volume attempts at least in a beginning way to connect the
dots from social expenditure (including benefits and supports) to preventive
and remedial services." -- James K. Whittaker, Social Service Review
About the Author
Neil Gilbert, PhD, is Chernin Professor of Social Welfare at the School of Social Welfare, University of California at Berkeley, and Co-Director of the Center for Child and Youth Policy.
Nigel Parton, PhD, is NSPCC Professor in Applied Childhood Studies, University of Huddersfield.
Marit Skivenes, PhD, is Senior Researcher, Bergen University College.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
Neil Gilbert, Nigel Parton, and Marit Skivenes
I. ANGLO-AMERICAN SYSTEMS
2. Trends and Issues in the U.S. Child Welfare System
Jill Duerr Berrick
3. Canadian Child Welfare: Child Protection and the Status Quo
Karen Swift
4. Child Protection in England
Nigel Parton and David Berridge
II. NORDIC SYSTEMS
5. The Dark Side of the Universal Welfare State? Child Abuse and Protection in Sweden
Madeleine Cocozza and Sven E. O. Hort
6. Combatting Child Abuse in Finland: From Family to Child-Centered Orientation
Tarja Pösö
7. Denmark: A Child Welfare System Under Reframing
Anne-Dorthe Hestbæk
8. Norway: Towards a Child-Centric Perspective
Marit Skivenes
III. CONTINENTAL SYSTEMS
9. Child Protection in an Age of Uncertainty: Germany's Response
Reinhart Wolff, Kay Biesel, and Stefan Heinitz
10. Policy Towards Child Abuse and Neglect in Belgium: In Search of a Democratic Approach
Kristof Desair and Peter Adriaenssens
11. Child Welfare in the Netherlands: Between Privacy and Protection
Trudie Knijn and Carolus van Nijnatten
IV. CONCLUSION
12. Changing Patterns of Response and Emerging Orientations
Neil Gilbert, Nigel Parton, and Marit Skivenes