Synopses & Reviews
Attempting to steer moral philosophy away from abstract theorizing, Moral Disquiet and Human Life argues that moral philosophy should be a practical, rational, and argumentative engagement with reality, and that moral reflection should have direct effects on our lives and the world in which we live. Illustrating her discussion with vivid examples from literature, music, drama, and current events, the noted French philosopher Monique Canto-Sperber resumes the most ancient pursuit of philosophy: the examination of human life itself. What did Socrates mean when he said that the unexamined life is not worth living? How can reflecting on one's existence incorporate human singularity, the contingency of events, the certainty of death, the presence of the past, or the irreversibility of time? Carefully analyzing and proposing answers to such questions, Moral Disquiet and Human Life eloquently calls for a redefinition of the task of moral philosophy and of its limits.
Review
"[A]n extremely rich and wide-ranging work, written by one of the foremost contemporary moral philosophers in France. . . . Without at all sacrificing rigor, [Monique Canto-Sperber] demonstrates in a most resounding way that philosophy at its very best is plentiful in its resources to speak quite illuminatingly to the circumstances of life that agonize us so."--Laurence Thomas, Ethics
Review
"Canto-Sperber not only holds up the history of moral philosophy as relevant and insightful, but she retells the grand story in her own fashion. Anglophones will find her narrative of the Ancients, her homage to the pre-Moderns (like Anselm), her 'inside story' approach to the existentialists, and her comparisons of French philosophers to non-French thinkers, both entertaining and revealing. But her incisive critique of the Enlightenment project of secularization, written in a dramatic and ever-surprising style of prose, is what makes this work unique and provocative."--Albert D. Spalding, Philosophy in Review
About the Author
Monique Canto-Sperber is a philosopher and the director of the École normale supérieure in Paris. She is the author of many books on philosophy and classics, and is the editor of Le Dictionnaire d'éthique et de philosophie morale.
Table of Contents
Acknowledgments ix
Part One: Moral Disquiet
Chapter 1: Ethics and the Challenge to Moral Philosophy 3
Critique of "Ethical Ideology": Truth and Falsehoods 10
Moral Philosophy and Ethics 17
Myths of Our Time: Moral Grandstanding and Ethical Self-Indulgence 20
Morals and Religion: The Misconception That Atheism Is a Prerequisite for Moral Deliberation 24
Ethics, Meaning, and the Sacred: Unlikely Consolations 32
The Myth of Modernity 38
Mauled Individualism 44
"All Books Are Open in Front of Me" 47
Chapter 2: Goals of Ethical Reflection 53
Moral Disquiet 55
A New Morality? Reflections on Responsibility 57
Law versus Morality: The Issue of Abortion 63
Description and Dissociation in Ethical Reflection: The Concept of Person 66
Practical Rationality and Moral Decisions 70
The Normative Character of Human Acts and Practices 72
Pluralism and Objectivity: The Debate on Human Cloning 74
Justification and Moral Theories 77
Ethical Reflection and Freethinking 79
Confusing Ethics and Democracy 81
Ethics without Solace 83
Chapter 3: French Moral Philosophy and Its Past Misfortunes 86
A Philosophical Revival: French Moral Philosophy in the Early 1900s 86
The International Congress in Philosophy, August 1900 89
French Moral Philosophy in the First Half of the Twentieth-Century: A Dwindling Discipline 91
The 1960s: Moral Philosophy's Rebirth in Great Britain, Germany, and the United States 97
The 1960s: French Moral Philosophy, Stranded between Suspicion and Neglect 101
What Caused These Developments? 104
The First Signs of Moral Philosophy's Revival in the 1980s 111
Part Two: Human Life
Chapter 4: The Absurd and the Meaning of Life 121
The Meaning of Life: A Meaningless Question? 121
Philosophers' Answer to the Existential Question 123
The Impossibility of a Final Justification 125
Immortality and the Vanity of Human Life 127
The Meaning of Life in a Naturalistic World 130
The Existential Question and the Feeling of Absurdity 131
Reflecting on Human Life and Confronting the Absurd 134
Chapter 5: The Invariants of Human Life 139
"Most Living" through Reflection 139
Existential Justifications and Self-Reflection 143
The Personal Perspective 146
Events in Human Life 153
The Boredom of Living Forever 157
Living Life Forward and Understanding It Backward 160
Chapter 6: The Good in Human Life 167
Morals and Existential Justifications 167
Happiness and the Subjectivity of Human Good 170
Objective Human Goods 172
Human Goods 173
Good Life and "Human Flourishing" 174
The Good in Human Life: Formal Good and Philosophy 176
Notes 181
Index 213