Synopses & Reviews
Drawing on newly-opened Soviet archives, especially the letters of complaint and petition with which peasants deluged the Soviet authorities in the 1930s,
Stalin's Peasants analyzes peasants' strategies of resistance and survival in the new world of the collectivized village.
Stalin's Peasants is a story of struggle between transformationally-minded Communists and traditionally-minded peasants over the terms of collectivization--a struggle of opposing practices, not a struggle in which either side clearly articulated its position. But it is also a story about the impact of collectivization on the internal social relations and culture of the village, exploring questions of authority and leadership, feuds, denunciations, rumors, and changes in religious observance. For the first time, it is possible to see the real people behind the facade of the "Potemkin village" created by Soviet propagandists. In the Potemkin village, happy peasants clustered around a kolkhoz (collective farm) tractor, praising Stalin and promising to produce more grain as a patriotic duty. In the real Russian village of the 1930s, as we learn from Soviet political police reports, sullen and hungry peasants described collectivization as a "second serfdom," cursed all Communists, and blamed Stalin personally for their plight.
Sheila Fitzpatrick's work is truly a landmark in studies of the Stalinist period--a richly-documented social history told from the traumatic experiences of the long-suffering underclass of peasants. Anyone interested in Soviet and Russian history, peasant studies, or social history will appreciate this major contribution to our understanding of life in Stalin's Russia.
Review
"Believing in nothing if not economies of scale, beginning in 1928 the Bolsheviks tried to make all Russia—that is, the USSR—one big factory, part of which was devoted to providing food for the other part and for export. They found the peasants tougher and harder to crack than the workers and other urban dwellers. This came as a surprise to the Bolsheviks, who proceeded to slaughter them the way Depression-era farmers in the United States despatched piglets, only with less sentimentality. The peasants fought back with everything they had, which in the end was not much more than the ability to run away to the cities, or to get and stay drunk. The moral degradation so evident today comes from Bolshevik economies of scale and inhumanity." Reviewed by Daniel Weiss, Virginia Quarterly Review (Copyright 2006 Virginia Quarterly Review)
Review
"In this pathbreaking study, Sheila Fitzpatrick portrays collective farm life in the 1930s from the perspective of the peasantry...Stalin's Peasants is an accessible and fascinating glimpse into the Soviet countryside."--Journal of Social History
"Fitzpatrick makes her account vivid with quotations of first-person experiences, but she resists the temptation to oversimplify the issues."--Kirkus Reviews
Review
"In this pathbreaking study, Sheila Fitzpatrick portrays collective farm life in the 1930s from the perspective of the peasantry...Stalin's Peasants is an accessible and fascinating glimpse into the Soviet countryside."--Journal of Social History
"Fitzpatrick makes her account vivid with quotations of first-person experiences, but she resists the temptation to oversimplify the issues."--Kirkus Reviews
"A pioneering piece of historical sociology that delineates the deplorable reality of ideological utopias."--ALA Booklist
"Stalin's Peasants is well-researched and richly detailed. It adds a great deal of new information on rural conditions and attitudes in the 1930s. No other work comes close to it in recounting the tragedy of collectivization from the peasant's point of view."--Times Literary Supplement (UK)
"This is an outstanding contribution both to the history of the USSR and the social history of peasants by a remarkable historian. She makes us hear the Russian peasants of the Stalin era speak (largely via hitherto closed archival records) and the echo of their voices in post-Soviet Russia today."--Eric Hobsbawm, The New School for Social Research
"Fitzpatrick's study is truly a landmark in the historiography of the Stalinist period of Soviet history, something that has been long overdue--a thickly documented social history of 1930s, not from the perspective of the "system" of Stalinism, but of the traumatic experiences and changes in life texture of that long-suffering underclass, the Russian peasantry."--Allan Wildman, Ohio State University
"With prodigious energy and diligence in newly-opened archives and employing the theoretical insights of recent historical and anthropological studies, Sheila Fitzpatrick shows how in the Russian village after collectivization peasants used the 'weapons of the weak' to pry from the Stalinist state what they needed in order to survive. She tells a tragic story filled with small triumphs by the subaltern in dynamic and moving prose. This is an empirical and conceptual tour de force."--Ronald Grigor Suny, The University of Michigan
"Sheila Fitzpatrick has written yet another path-breaking book, introducing us once more to an untold history and hitherto unused sources. She shows that Stalin's peasants were unmistakably kin to the peasants of Peter and Catherine, and the two Nicholases. They resisted the often unbearable pressure of the state as best they could, exploited the regime's dependence upon peasant cooperation, adopted the language of the regime as they pursued their own intravillage feuds, and remained cynically indifferent to the regime's goals."--John Bushnell, Northwestern University
"Fitzpatrick offers the first large-scale study of collectivization and its impact upon the peasantry since the opening of the archives in the late 1980s....Fitzpatrick has written a pioneering book that will inspire future researchers."--International Labor and Working-Class History
"...A work that should be read by all students of Russian and Soviet culture, and will be of interest to sociologists, anthropologists, and anyone interested in cultural theory."--Russian Review
About the Author
Sheila Fitzpatrick is Bernadotte E. Schmitt Professor of History at the University of Chicago. She is the author or editor of numerous books including
The Cultural Front: Power and Culture in Revolutionary Russia (1992).