Synopses & Reviews
In the prevailing liberal ethos, if there is one thing that is beyond the reach of others, it is our body in particular, and our person in general: our legal and political tradition is such that we have the right to deny others access to our person and body, even though doing so would harm those who need personal services from us, or body parts. However, we lack the right to use ourselves as we wish in order to raise income, even though we do not necessarily harm others by doing so--even though we might in fact benefit them by doing so.
Cecile Fabre's aim in this book is to show that, according to the principles of distributive justice which inform most liberal democracies, both in practice and in theory, it should be exactly the other way around: that is, if it is true that we lack the right to withhold access to material resources from those who need them, we also lack the right to withhold access to our body from those who need it; but we do, under some circumstances, have the right to decide how to use it in order to raise income. More specifically, she argues in favor of the confiscation of body parts and personal services, as well as of the commercialization of organs, sex, and reproductive capacities.
Review
"An original attempt to "delineate the rights individuals have over their own and other people's bodies", set against the background of a sufficientist theory of liberal egalitarian justice...carefully argued in a clear and linear prose"--Anca Gheaus, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews
Synopsis
If there is one thing that is beyond the reach of others, it is our body in particular, and our person in general. Our legal and political tradition is such that we have the right to deny others access to our person and body, even though doing so would harm those who need personal services from us, or body parts. But are these rights as watertight as they seem? Cécile Fabre's controversial and original book teases out the unexplored implications that arguments for distributive justice have for the rights we have over ourselves, by looking at topical issues such as good Samaritanism, organ confiscation, organ sales, prostitution, and surrogate motherhood.
Table of Contents
1. A Rights-based Theory of Justice
2. Good Samaritanism
3. A Civilian Service
4. Confiscating Cadaveric Organs
5. Confiscating Live Body Parts
6. Organ Sales
7. Prostitution
8. Surrogacy Contracts
Conclusion